Paper 1 Q4: a headline and a hook that open the article in role
Question 4
Imagine you are Immy Hart, the captain of the robotics team. A week after the competition, you write an article for your school magazine about the team's day in Halbury.
In your article you should:
- describe what happened to Magpie during the competition, and how the team dealt with it
- explain how the team felt at different points in the day, and how other people reacted to you
- give your views on what the school should do to support the robotics club in future.
Base your article on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three bullet points.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (opening only, not a full exam answer). Write only the headline, an optional strapline (the one-line summary under a headline) and the first paragraph of Immy's article, in about 50 to 100 words in total. An opening cannot be marked out of 20 on its own, so the commentary judges which level writing of this standard would support within a complete article.
Insert · Text C
Forty Seconds
In this account, a fifteen-year-old describes her school team's day at a regional robotics competition.
1 Our robot was called Magpie, because most of it was stolen. Not really stolen: borrowed, begged and rescued. Its wheels came from a broken toy truck, its gripping arm from a printer the school office had thrown out, and its brain from a starter kit that Mr Osei, our physics technician, had bought with his own money and refused to talk about. We built it on Tuesday evenings in a storeroom at Larchfield School that we shared with the cleaners' mops, and by March it could pick up a coloured block, carry it across a table and drop it in the right tray. In forty seconds, the length of a round, it could manage five.
2 The regional final was held in a sports hall in Halbury, an hour away. There were four of us in the team: Immy Hart, our captain, who drove the robot with a games controller; Joel Mensah, who wrote the code; Sami Rauf, a Year 8 who had joined because he liked taking things apart; and me. Twenty schools had come. Most had matching T-shirts. The team from Kingsmere College had matching jackets with a sponsor's logo on the back and a robot that gleamed like a kitchen appliance.
3 In our first practice round, Magpie would not turn left. Immy pushed the stick and it swung to the right, again and again, round and round in tight circles like a dog chasing its tail, while a block sat untouched in the middle of the table. Somebody in a jacket laughed. Then several people laughed. Immy's face went the colour of the red tray.
4 Back in the pit area, Joel announced that the code was fine and therefore the robot was 'cursed'. He wanted to withdraw. I wanted to cry, which is not the same thing but felt close. Mr Osei sat on a plastic chair with his arms folded. Under the competition rules, only students may touch a robot once it has been checked in, and he took this so seriously that he sat on his hands. 'It's your robot,' he kept saying. 'Ask it what's wrong.'
5 It was Sami who asked it. He lay on the floor with a torch between his teeth and found that a wire to the left motor had worked loose on the bumpy minibus journey. We had no spare connector. Sami pulled a hair grip from Immy's fringe, bent it into a clip and pinched the wire in place, and then, because nobody believed it would hold, wrapped the whole thing in an elastic band from Joel's lunchbox.
6 In the next round Magpie turned left. It turned left beautifully. It collected six blocks, our best score ever, and when the buzzer went we screamed so loudly that a judge put her fingers in her ears. We won two more rounds that afternoon and reached the semi-final, where, with eight seconds left and a block in its grip, Magpie simply stopped. The battery was flat. We had a spare, but someone (Joel) had borrowed the charger at lunchtime for his phone.
7 We came fourth out of twenty. As we packed up, the Kingsmere captain wandered over, looked at the hair grip for a long moment and asked how we had found the fault so quickly. Sami explained, at length. Then the head judge called Larchfield's name for the Engineering Spirit Award, given, she said, 'to the team that fixed the most with the least'. It is a small glass block with a cog etched inside it. It is the only trophy our school has ever won for anything that is not sport.
8 Sami fell asleep on the minibus with the trophy in his lap. Joel was rewriting the battery-warning code on his phone. Mr Osei drove without the radio on, and when we stopped for petrol he told us, quietly, that the storeroom would become a staff kitchen in September and that he did not yet know where the club would go. Nobody said much after that. I sat looking at the dark fields and thinking about the forty seconds, and how much of our year had gone into them.
- 1
Fix the voice and the reader before the first word. Who: Immy Hart, the captain, who was at the controls all day. To whom: students and staff who read the school magazine, most of whom were not in Halbury. Table F Level 5 asks for a consistent voice, and Table G credits fitness for audience and purpose, so the opening has to sound like a captain talking to her own school, not like a report of Text C.
- 2
Choose a headline that promises a story. A good article headline is short, concrete and makes the reader want the next line. 'Robotics Competition' names a topic; 'Forty Seconds and a Hair Grip' puts two surprising, specific details side by side and asks the reader to find out how they connect. Avoid copying the title of Text C as it stands, and avoid a full sentence that gives the ending away.
- 3
Use the strapline to set the angle. One line under the headline tells the reader what the article thinks: here, that a team with almost nothing achieved something the school has never achieved before. That angle prepares the third bullet (what the school should do) from the very start, which is what 'a thread an editor would follow' means.
- 4
Open with a contrast or a scene, not an announcement. 'In this article I will tell you about…' wastes the first sentence. A before-and-after contrast (spinning in circles in the morning, a trophy by the evening) is a hook built from Text C: it re-expresses paragraphs 3 and 7 in Immy's words and makes the reader ask how. Close the paragraph by telling the reader why the captain is writing.
Model opening (top level)
91 words
Forty Seconds and a Hair Grip
How Larchfield's robotics club won the school's first trophy that isn't for sport
Last Saturday morning, in a sports hall in Halbury, our robot spun in helpless circles while twenty schools watched, and some of them laughed. By the evening, that same robot was riding home on the minibus beside a glass trophy. As captain of the robotics club, I want to tell you how we got from one to the other, because the answer was held together by something taken from my own fringe.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full article: an opening of this standard would support Table G, Level 5. The headline pairs two concrete details and creates curiosity; the strapline states the angle (a first non-sporting trophy) that the third bullet will need. The first paragraph is built on a deliberate contrast of morning and evening, and the final clause teases the hair grip without explaining it, so the reader has a reason to continue. For Table F, the voice is Immy's from the first line ('our robot', 'my own fringe'), and the details from paragraphs 3, 6 and 7 are re-expressed, not lifted: 'spun in helpless circles' replaces the narrator's dog simile.
Weak opening (for comparison)
54 words
Robotics Competition
In this article I am going to tell you about the robotics competition in Halbury. There were four of us in the team and twenty schools had come. In our first practice round, Magpie would not turn left. It spun round and round in tight circles like a dog chasing its tail.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full article: an opening like this would hold the writing towards Table G, Level 2–3. The headline names a topic and promises nothing. 'In this article I am going to tell you' is an announcement, not a hook, and the paragraph then begins retelling Text C in its own order. 'Magpie' is never explained to readers who were not there. For Table F, the simile 'like a dog chasing its tail' is lifted from paragraph 3, which is noted at Level 2 as 'some lifting', and nothing yet suggests Immy's voice or a view.
What earns the marks
- A short, concrete headline that makes the reader curious (not a topic label, not Text C's title).
- An optional strapline that sets the article's angle and points towards the third bullet.
- A hook built from Text C in Immy's own words: a scene or contrast (spinning in the morning, a trophy by the evening).
- A final sentence saying who is writing and why, in a voice fitted to the school magazine's readers.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: an opening that announces the article ('In this article I will…') or starts retelling Text C from its first paragraph tells the examiner you are reporting the text, not writing an article. Spend one minute on the headline and the first sentence: both should make a reader who was not there want to know what happened next.