A given last line: earning the ending instead of bolting it on
Narrative writing
Write a story which ends with the words, '… and I put it back exactly where I had found it.'
Write about 350 to 450 words. Up to 16 marks are available for the content and structure of your answer and up to 24 marks for the style and accuracy of your writing.
Practice task (content and structure, Table D: 16 marks in the full composition). Two candidates planned this story in seven minutes.
Plan A. I find a wallet full of money on the bus. I think about keeping it and buying new trainers. A man runs after the bus shouting. I give it back and he gives me a reward. Last line.
Plan B. Grandad's watch, kept in the drawer of the hall table since he died. I take it to school to show a friend without asking Mum. It gets scratched in PE. I spend all evening trying to polish the scratch out. Mum finds me. Last line.
(a) Explain why neither plan yet earns the given last line, and which Table D level each would be likely to reach if written as planned.
(b) Rebuild Plan B so that the last line lands as the resolution of the story. Show where its key words are prepared.
- 1
Read the line for what it demands. '… and I put it back exactly where I had found it' tells you four things: there is an object; the narrator took it; it had a particular place; and exactly matters. A precise return suggests either hiding something (so nobody will know) or respect (because the place itself means something). A Level 6 story can use both: the action is the same, but its meaning changes between the middle and the end. That change is what makes an ending feel earned rather than bolted on.
- 2
(a) Diagnose Plan A. The wallet goes back to its owner, not to the place it was found, so the given words would contradict the plot: the line could only be stuck on. The structure (temptation, a chase, a reward) is 'straightforward' and the characters are functions: a finder and an owner. Written well, this sits at about Table D Level 3 (around 6/16): some focus on the task, a plot with limited use of the features of narrative writing, and an ending that does not belong to the story.
- 3
(a) Diagnose Plan B. Much better: there is an object with a place, a taking and a reason to restore it. But the plan stops at 'Mum finds me'. Nothing turns at the climax, so the narrator would simply put the watch back to hide the damage, and the last line would only report the cover-up. With a relevant and cohesive plot but no developed climax, this is likely to reach about Table D Level 4 (around 9/16). Level 6 asks for a well-developed plot with an effective climax and structure managed for deliberate effect.
- 4
(b) Plan the climax first, then plant the line's words. Decide what Mum does that changes what 'putting it back' means: she knows every mark on the watch and accepts the new one. Then plant exactly (the narrator notices how the watch lies, and memorises it before taking it) and put it back (her first plan is to return it so nobody will know). When the same action happens at the end, the reader feels the difference.
- 5
Budget the words towards the climax. The taking and the damage are quick (about 130 words together); the cover-up and the climax get the space (about 190). The resolution is short: the line itself does the work, so nothing follows it and nothing explains it.
Rebuilt plan (supports Table D Level 6)
233 words
Climax first: Mum finds me polishing the scratch and, instead of shouting, shows me she knows every mark on the watch.
- Opening (about 70 words): the hall-table drawer. Grandad's watch lies face up on a folded handkerchief, strap curled, the dial turned towards the window. Mum opens the drawer every Sunday and closes it without a word. (Plants 'exactly'.)
- The taking (about 60 words): I borrow it to show Jonah, who does not believe Grandad was a ship's engineer. Before I lift it I memorise how it lies: strap, dial, the fold of the handkerchief. (Plants 'put it back'.)
- The damage (about 70 words): the changing-room bench, a bright new scratch across the glass.
- The cover-up (about 80 words): toothpaste, a cloth, an hour; the scratch only shines. I will put it back exactly as it was and nobody will know. (The line's first, guilty meaning.)
- Climax (about 110 words): Mum in the doorway. She tilts the watch to the lamp and names the old marks one by one: the dent from the engine room, the chip from the day I was born, when he dropped it. She touches the new scratch. 'And this one's yours.'
- Resolution (about 50 words): she does not put it back herself; she hands it to me. Strap curled, dial to the window. Last line. (Same action, new meaning: respect, not hiding.)
How it is marked
Why this plan supports Table D Level 6. The given words are integral: the whole plot is built so that the final action happens twice in the narrator's mind, first as a cover-up and then as an act of respect, which is structure 'managed for deliberate effect'. The climax is a genuine turning point caused by a character (Mum's knowledge of every mark), not by luck. Characterisation is planned through behaviour: the Sunday drawer, the memorised position, the named scratches. The budget gives the climax the most words and leaves the resolution to a single action.
Why Plan B as written stops at Level 4. It is relevant and cohesive, but the plot ends where the story should turn. 'Mum finds me' followed by the last line gives the reader an ending without a climax, and the line only repeats what the narrator was already planning to do.
What earns the marks
(a) Plan A: the wallet returns to its owner, not to where it was found, so the given words contradict the plot; a straightforward temptation-and-reward story, about Table D Level 3 (around 6/16). Plan B: a fitting object and situation, but no climax, so the line only reports a cover-up; relevant and cohesive, about Level 4 (around 9/16).
(b) A rebuilt plan in which: the watch's exact position is planted in the opening and memorised before the taking; the narrator's first motive for putting it back is to hide the damage; Mum's knowledge of every old mark (and her acceptance of the new one) is the climax; and the final action repeats the planned cover-up with a new meaning, ending on the given words with nothing after them.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: a given last line is a destination, not a decoration. Plan backwards from it, and check that every key word in it (here 'put it back' and 'exactly') has been prepared earlier in the story. The strongest endings repeat an action or image the reader already knows but change what it means. If the line could be removed without the story losing anything, it has been bolted on, and Table D will not credit the structure as deliberate.