Paper 2 Q1(a): evaluating an ironic writer's attitude to a beaver trial
Read Text A and Text B in the insert and then answer Section A, Question 1(a) and 1(b).
(a) Reread Text B.
Use your own words to evaluate Gwen Talbot's attitude to the beaver trial and to the people who support it. Give details from the text to justify your answer. [5]
Insert · Text A
Beaver Trial Divides Hollin Valley as Decision Nears
This report appeared in the Westmarch Gazette.
Two years after six beavers were released into the upper River Hollin under a government-licensed trial, the animals have become the most argued-about residents of the valley. The colony now numbers about thirty, and the Westmarch Wildlife Trust, which runs the trial, will ask in March for the licence to be extended to the whole catchment.
The trust says the results so far are striking. A river gauge at Kelby Bridge, below the beavers' dams, recorded flood peaks 28 per cent lower last winter than the average for the previous five winters. The ponds behind the dams now hold water through dry spells, and surveys have counted eleven species of dragonfly where there were four. 'Beavers do for free what would cost the taxpayer millions,' said the trust's chief executive, Owen Price. Kelby, where forty-two homes flooded in 2021, would be the first village to benefit.
Not everyone is persuaded by the numbers. Dr Nia Brennan, a hydrologist at Westmarch University who is not involved in the trial, called the gauge readings 'encouraging but far from proof'. 'It is one gauge and one winter, and last winter brought fewer big storms than usual,' she said. 'Ask me again after five years.'
For three of the valley's forty-one farms, the costs are already clear. Dams have backed water up into drains and waterlogged about seventeen hectares of grazing land, and one orchard has lost more than thirty young trees to gnawing. A compensation scheme pays £150 a hectare a year, but the Hollin Valley Farmers' Group says claims have taken up to eight months to be paid, and that farmers must ask permission before removing even a small dam from a field drain.
A petition supporting the extension has gathered 2,300 signatures, many from outside the county. The licensing body's decision is expected in late March.
Insert · Text B
Nature's Engineers? Then Send Them an Invoice
In this newspaper column, Gwen Talbot, who farms sheep at Upper Hollin, responds to the beaver trial.
I am told I should be grateful. My bottom field, I learn from a leaflet, is now 'a thriving wetland'. My sheep, ungrateful creatures, preferred it as a field. So did the bank that lends me money on the assumption that grass grows there.
Let me be clear about one thing, because it keeps getting lost: I like beavers. I grew up on this river when there were no otters in it, and I cheered when the otters came back. If the beavers had arrived on their own, I would probably have given them names. What I object to is being told, by people who drive up from the city at weekends to photograph them, that my losses are a small price to pay. Small for whom?
The trust's favourite number is 28 per cent. I do not doubt it was measured honestly. I simply note that it was measured in the mildest winter I can remember, at one bridge, and that nobody has yet measured what it costs to farm a field that is underwater from November to April. The compensation, when it finally arrives, would not rent me half the land I have lost.
Here is what I would put to the licensing body. Extend the trial, by all means, but onto land whose owners want it; there are several who do. Pay claims within a month, not eight. And let farmers clear a blocked drain without filling in a form and waiting for a man with a clipboard. Treat us as partners and you will find us surprisingly reasonable. Treat us as an obstacle and, I promise you, we can be a very large one.
- 1
Read the irony before you read the content. Talbot opens by saying she is 'told' she should be 'grateful' and that her field is 'a thriving wetland'. She means the opposite: she is mocking the cheerful language used to describe her loss. 'My sheep, ungrateful creatures' continues the joke. A candidate who reports that she 'feels grateful' or that she 'says the field is thriving' has misread the attitude, and Table A cannot place a misreading at the top level.
- 2
Notice that the question has two targets. Her attitude to the beavers is warm ('I like beavers'; she would have named them). Her attitude to the trial's supporters is resentful: visitors from the city call her losses 'a small price to pay'. Her attitude to the trial itself is conditional: she says 'Extend the trial, by all means', on terms. An answer that calls her simply 'against the trial' has missed the point she says 'keeps getting lost'.
- 3
Evaluate, then show how it is conveyed. 'Evaluate' wants a judgement, not a list of what she said. R4 is assessed in 1(a), so the top answer also says how the language carries the attitude: the sarcasm, the short rhetorical question 'Small for whom?', the fair concession that the 28 per cent was 'measured honestly', and the closing pair of sentences ('Treat us as partners... Treat us as an obstacle') that turns a reasonable offer into a warning.
- 4
Keep it in proportion. Five marks out of forty: about six to eight lines. Put the judgement first, give each part a short detail, re-expressed or briefly quoted, and finish with an overall verdict that pulls the parts together.
Model answer (top level)
117 words
Talbot is resentful of the trial's supporters but far from hostile to beavers themselves. Her sarcasm about being expected to feel 'grateful' for a 'thriving wetland' mocks the cheerful language used to dress up her losses, and the rhetorical question 'Small for whom?' exposes the condescension of visitors who bear none of the cost. Yet she insists she likes beavers, and she treats the 28 per cent figure as honestly measured but incomplete, which makes her scepticism sound reasoned rather than bitter. Her closing proposals show a practical, conditional attitude: she will cooperate if treated as a partner, and her final warning that farmers can be a very large obstacle shows how firmly she sets those conditions.
How it is marked
Table A, Level 3: 5 marks. The answer opens with a judgement that separates the two targets of the attitude (resentment of supporters; no hostility to beavers) and holds that distinction throughout. Each part is justified with a short, precise detail, and the irony is read correctly. It meets R4 by explaining how the language works: the sarcasm 'mocks', the rhetorical question 'exposes', the concession makes her 'sound reasoned', the closing contrast turns an offer into a warning. The final sentence draws the parts into an overall evaluation: practical, conditional, firm.
Near-miss answer (for comparison)
86 words
Gwen Talbot is unhappy about the beaver trial. Her bottom field has turned into a wetland and her sheep cannot graze on it. She says she likes beavers and was pleased when the otters came back to the river. She thinks the 28 per cent figure was measured in a mild winter at only one bridge. She wants claims to be paid within a month and wants farmers to be able to clear drains without asking permission. She says farmers can be a very large obstacle.
How it is marked
Table A, Level 2: 3 marks. Every detail is accurate and mostly in the candidate's own words, so this is a sound reading. But it describes rather than evaluates: the only judgement is 'unhappy', which does not distinguish her warmth towards the beavers from her resentment of the supporters, and the answer works through Text B paragraph by paragraph. Nothing is said about how the attitude is conveyed: the sarcasm of the opening is reported as plain fact ('her field has turned into a wetland') and 'Small for whom?' is left out.
What separates it from the model: the model forms a view of the whole attitude and shows how the language creates it. The near-miss tells the examiner what Talbot says, which is the material for an evaluation, not the evaluation itself.
What earns the marks
Creditable judgements, each supported by a detail:
- Resentful of the trial's supporters and their condescension: the sarcastic 'grateful' and 'thriving wetland'; 'Small for whom?'; visitors who photograph the beavers but bear no cost.
- Not hostile to beavers: she likes them, welcomed the otters, would have named them.
- Sceptical but fair about the evidence: the 28 per cent was 'measured honestly' but in a mild winter at one bridge.
- Practical and conditional about the trial: extend it onto willing land, pay within a month, let farmers clear drains; cooperative if treated as a partner, a formidable opponent if not.
- How it is conveyed (R4): irony, rhetorical question, concession, the closing balanced warning.
Top level: a clear evaluative judgement in own words, justified with details and showing how the language conveys the attitude. [5]
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: when a writer opens with 'I am told I should be grateful', test every statement for irony before you report it. Then check whether the question names more than one target; a writer can like the thing and dislike the people promoting it. A judgement that holds both, with a word on how the language creates each, is what lifts a 1(a) answer from accurate description to the top of Table A.