Paper 1 Q4 interview: develop the feeling answer instead of repeating it
Question 4
Imagine you are Elin. Three months after the expedition, you are interviewed on The Outdoor Hour, an evening radio programme for people who love the outdoors. The presenter asks you these three questions:
- What went wrong on the ice cap?
- How did you feel about making the decision to turn back?
- Some listeners will say the expedition was a failure. Do you agree?
Write the words of the interview.
Base your interview on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three questions.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (one answer, not a full exam answer). Write only the second exchange: the presenter's second question and Elin's answer, in about 110 to 150 words. A single answer cannot be marked out of 20 on its own, so the commentary judges which level writing of this standard would support within a complete interview.
Insert · Text C
Thirty Kilometres Short
In this account, nineteen-year-old Elin Marsh describes a student expedition across the Kallvik Ice Cap that did not reach its goal.
1 In 1934 a surveyor named Aksel Rinde crossed the Kallvik Ice Cap on skis and photographed the glaciers from eleven stone cairns he built along the way. Ninety years later, four of us from the university mountaineering club set out to stand where he had stood and take the same photographs, so that anyone could see how far the ice had shrunk. Jonas Brekke, who had planned the trip for two years, was our leader. Fern Achebe was in charge of navigation, Luca Daly carried the cameras, and I was the medic, which meant that I had done a first-aid course and carried the heaviest bag.
2 The first week went better than any of us had dared to hope. We covered twenty kilometres a day, found five of Rinde's cairns still standing, and took photographs from each. At the third cairn, the glacier he had photographed lapping at the foot of a ridge was simply gone; there was a grey lake and a kilometre of bare rock where it had been. Luca stared at the screen of his camera for a long time and then said, quite quietly, 'Well, that's the point, isn't it.'
3 On day seven the wind arrived. For three days we lay in the tent while it tried to tear the fabric from the poles, taking turns to go outside and dig the snow away from the walls. We ate half rations to make the food last. Jonas worked out, on the back of the route card, that if we skied an extra hour each day after the storm we could still reach the eleventh cairn, the one that mattered most, because it looked down on the largest glacier on the ice cap.
4 On the morning of day eleven I noticed that Luca was skiing oddly, with his weight on his heels. When I made him take off his boot that evening, three of his toes were white and hard, and the skin around them had turned a mottled purple. He had felt them go numb two days earlier and said nothing, because he did not want to be the reason we stopped. I warmed his foot against my stomach inside my jacket, which is what the course had taught me, and I tried to keep my face still.
5 The eleventh cairn was thirty kilometres away. The hut we had started from was sixty kilometres behind us. Jonas wanted to go on: two more days, he said, take the photographs, then call for a ski-plane to collect us from the far side. Fern said nothing for a long time and then said that she would do whatever the medic said. I said that if Luca's toes froze again we could not warm them a second time, and that no plane could land in the kind of wind we had just had. I said we were turning back. Jonas walked away from the tent and stood with his back to us for nearly half an hour.
6 It took us four days to ski out, with Luca's foot wrapped in a spare sleeping-bag liner and Jonas breaking trail at the front without a word. At the hut there was a radio, and a doctor in the valley told us that we had done the right thing. Luca kept all his toes. He also has a scar across two of them that he likes to show people.
7 The reaction at home was not what I had expected. Our main sponsor, a camera company, quietly dropped the film it had promised to make about us. Someone online wrote that we were 'unprepared students playing at explorers', and the comment was shared hundreds of times. But in the spring a glaciologist at the university, Dr Halvorsen, asked for our photographs from the first five cairns. She says they are the clearest record yet of how far the ice has retreated since 1934, and she is using them in a research paper.
8 Jonas and I did not speak for six weeks. Then a postcard arrived with an old photograph of Rinde standing beside the eleventh cairn, and two words on the back: 'Next year?' I have pinned it above my desk. I have not answered it yet.
- 1
Know what Level 5 is asking for. Table F Level 5 wants 'well-sustained development'; Level 3 describes ideas that are 'rarely developed'. In a feeling answer, development means giving the feeling a cause, a complication and a consequence. Saying the same feeling again in different words ('terrible', 'awful', 'hard') looks like development because it adds words, but it adds no ideas, and markers do not credit a point twice.
- 2
Find the layers of feeling in Text C. Elin never names her feelings; they sit in the details. She tries 'to keep my face still' (paragraph 4), so she was frightened but hiding it. Fern hands the decision to 'the medic' (paragraph 5), so the choice became Elin's alone. Jonas stands with his back to them for half an hour, so she felt she had taken something from him. She has not answered the postcard (paragraph 8), so the feeling is not resolved. Reading feelings from actions is R2.
- 3
Give the feeling a reason that comes from the text. Her reasoning in paragraph 5 is practical: toes cannot be rewarmed twice, and a plane cannot land in that wind. A Level 5 answer turns this into insight into her own state of mind, for example that the decision came from arithmetic rather than courage. That is an idea, not a repeated emotion.
- 4
End on where the feeling has gone since. A judgement about her own feeling now (she would make the same decision, but the guilt about Jonas lingers) moves the answer forward. A sentence that restates the opening ('it was the hardest decision ever') moves it back.
Model answer (Level 5): question 2 only
133 words
Presenter: How did you feel about making the decision to turn back?
Elin: Sick underneath, and very calm on the outside, because I had to be. I knew the moment I saw Luca's toes, but saying it aloud meant ending two years of Jonas's planning with the last cairn only thirty kilometres away. What carried me was arithmetic, not courage: frozen toes can't be rewarmed twice, and no plane was landing in that wind. The loneliest moment wasn't the ice at all. It was Fern saying she'd do whatever the medic said, and suddenly it was all mine. Then Jonas stood with his back to us for half an hour, and I felt as if I'd taken something from him. I still feel that, a bit. I'd still make the same call tomorrow.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full interview: an answer of this standard would support Table F, Level 5 for question 2. Each sentence adds a new idea rather than a new word for the same feeling: hidden fear (from 'keep my face still'), the cost to Jonas, the reasoning that made the choice bearable, the isolation when Fern handed it over, the guilt when Jonas turned away, and a settled judgement now. Details from paragraphs 4, 5 and 8 are integrated and re-expressed. For Table G, the opening reply is crisp, the contrast 'arithmetic, not courage' is shaped for a listener, and the short closing sentences give the answer a deliberate ending.
Near-miss answer (for comparison)
138 words
Presenter: How did you feel about making the decision to turn back?
Elin: It was really hard. I felt terrible about it, because we had come so far and the eleventh cairn was only thirty kilometres away. It was the most important cairn and we were so close to it, so turning back felt awful. I knew Luca's toes were frostbitten and I knew it was dangerous to carry on, because if they froze again we couldn't warm them. So I felt I had no choice, really. But I still felt terrible, because Jonas had planned it for two years and it meant so much to him. I felt guilty and sad. Overall it was the hardest decision I have ever made and I felt awful about it, but I knew it was the right thing to do.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full interview: this would hold question 2 at the lower end of Table F, Level 4. It is accurate, in role and focused on the question, and it gives reasons, which keeps it above Level 3. But it develops by repetition: 'terrible' and 'awful' appear four times between them, the closeness of the cairn is made twice, and the final sentence restates the first. Strip out the repeats and three ideas are left (the cairn was close, the toes made it dangerous, Jonas cared), with none of the material that would extend them: Fern handing over the decision, Jonas turning his back, the feeling that lingers. For Table G, the vocabulary of feeling is narrow and 'Overall' sounds like an essay, not a guest on the radio.
What would lift it: replace each repeated emotion word with the next stage of the feeling, and anchor each stage to a detail from Text C.
What earns the marks
- A feeling answer at Level 5 moves through stages, each anchored in Text C: fear hidden behind a calm face; the reasoning that made the decision possible (toes cannot be rewarmed twice, no plane in that wind); isolation when Fern handed the choice to Elin; guilt at Jonas turning his back; a settled view now.
- No emotion word repeated as a substitute for development.
- Re-expressed details in Elin's spoken voice, with a closing judgement that moves the answer forward.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: after drafting a feeling answer, underline every emotion word. If two of them mean the same thing, delete one and put a new idea in its place: a cause, a complication or what the feeling turned into. Level 4 answers are often as long as Level 5 answers; they simply say less.