Paper 1 Q4: a headline and a first paragraph that make the reader want more
Question 4
Imagine you are Kezia, the student who kept the scores. A week after sports day, you write an article for your school magazine about the day.
In your article you should:
- describe what happened when the rain stopped sports day, and how the day was changed
- explain how students and parents felt during the day
- give your views on how future sports days at Fernhill should be run.
Base your article on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three bullet points.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (opening only, not a full exam answer). Write only the headline, an optional strapline (the one line under a headline that tells the reader what the article is about) and the first paragraph of Kezia's article, in about 50 to 90 words. An opening cannot be marked out of 20 on its own, so the commentary judges which level writing of this standard would support within a complete article.
Insert · Text C
Beanbags in the Sports Hall
In this account, a fifteen-year-old describes a sports day at her school that did not go to plan.
1 Sports day at Fernhill School has always meant the same thing: the running track on the top field, four houses in four colours, and Kingfisher House winning. Kingfisher had won for six years in a row. This year I had volunteered to run the results table, which mostly meant sitting under a gazebo with a laptop, a clipboard and a box of ribbons while the PE teacher, Mr Okafor, shouted times at me through a megaphone.
2 It started raining at ten past nine, during the Year 7 hundred metres. By half past, the lanes had disappeared under brown puddles, and a boy in the long jump landed in the sandpit with a splash rather than a thud. Mr Okafor stood in the middle of the field with water running off the peak of his cap, looked at the sky and blew his whistle three times. Everyone knew what that meant. Sports day was cancelled.
3 Except it was not. Twenty minutes later, the head of PE, Mrs Duarte, called the house captains into the sports hall. She had a stack of cones, a crate of beanbags and an idea. If we could not run on the field, she said, we would compete inside, with events that nobody had trained for: a target throw with beanbags into hoops, a shuttle relay between two benches, a standing jump on the gym mats, and a team balance challenge in which six people had to cross the hall on four mats without touching the floor. Every student would take part in at least one event, not only the fastest runners.
4 That was when things went wrong for me. My laptop, which had spent forty minutes in a damp gazebo, would not turn on. Every result of the morning was on it. I felt sick. Mrs Duarte simply wheeled out the big whiteboard from the drama studio and handed me a marker. For the rest of the day I kept the scores by hand, in four colours, in front of the whole school, and every time I added a point a cheer went up from one side of the hall.
5 The parents who had come to watch squeezed into the balcony above the hall, dripping, holding umbrellas they had nowhere to put. At first some of them grumbled that it was not a proper sports day. By the afternoon they were shouting and stamping their feet so loudly that dust drifted down from the balcony rail.
6 The best moment belonged to Arlo Penn, a Year 7 boy who uses a wheelchair. At every sports day before, at primary school and at Fernhill, he had sat at the side and held the stopwatch. Today he entered the target throw. He landed seven beanbags out of ten in the smallest hoop, the best score of anyone in the school, including the Year 11s. When I wrote his seven on the whiteboard, his whole house stood up and chanted his name, and he spun his chair in a full circle and bowed.
7 Kingfisher did not win. They came third, behind Heron and Swift, and their captain shook my hand and said that being beaten in a sports hall full of beanbags was 'the strangest day of my life'. Heron, my house, won for the first time since before I started at the school. I tried to stay neutral at the whiteboard, but I am told I wrote the final score with a very large flourish.
8 At the end, Mrs Duarte thanked everyone and then said something that made the hall go quiet. The drains under the top field had collapsed, and the field could not be used until they were repaired, which might take a year. Next summer's sports day, she said, might have to be indoors again, and she wanted to know what students thought. On the way out, I heard two Year 9s arguing about it. One said that a sports day without a track was not a real sports day. The other said it was the first one she had ever enjoyed.
- 1
Answer three questions before you write a word. Who am I? Kezia, who kept the scores all day. Who am I writing for? Students, staff and parents who read the school magazine. Some were in the hall; some were not. What form? A magazine article, so it needs a headline and an opening that pulls the reader in. Table F rewards a consistent voice and Table G rewards writing that suits its audience and purpose, so these three answers matter from the first line.
- 2
Write a headline that promises something. A headline is not a label. 'Sports Day' tells the reader the topic and nothing else. A better headline is short, specific and a little surprising: 'Beanbags Beat the Rain' puts two odd details together and makes the reader wonder how they connect. Do not copy the title of Text C, and do not write a long sentence that gives the whole story away.
- 3
Add a strapline if it helps. One line in italics under the headline can tell the reader the angle of the article, for example that a disaster turned into a success. This is optional, but it is a quick way to show that you know what a magazine article looks like.
- 4
Choose one simple hook. Three hooks that work well for beginners: a contrast (what everyone expected against what happened), a moment (one vivid scene from the day), or a surprising fact. Here the contrast is ready-made: by half past nine sports day was cancelled, yet by the afternoon the whole school was cheering. Put it in your own words; do not copy the sentences of Text C.
- 5
Spot the difference between a weak and a sound opening.
Weak opening Sound opening Headline is a label ('Sports Day') Headline makes the reader curious Starts 'In this article I am going to…' Starts with a contrast or a moment Copies the first sentences of Text C Uses details from Text C in Kezia's words Retells the text from paragraph 1 Picks the most interesting moment No sign of who is writing or why Says who is writing and why the day matters
Sound opening (secure level)
72 words
Beanbags Beat the Rain
How Fernhill's wettest sports day turned into one of its best
At half past nine last Friday, sports day was over. The track was under water and the whistle had gone. By the afternoon, the whole school was packed into the sports hall, cheering for beanbags. I kept the scores all day, so I saw every moment, and I think it was a day Fernhill should learn from.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full article: an opening of this standard would support Table G, Level 4 and help towards Table F, Level 4. The headline is short and curious, and the strapline sets the angle (a disaster that became a success). The hook is a clear contrast between the morning and the afternoon, written in Kezia's own words rather than copied from paragraphs 2 and 3. The last sentence tells the reader who is writing and hints at a view, which prepares the third prompt.
How to climb to Level 5: make the final sentence more specific and more tempting. 'I think it was a day Fernhill should learn from' is a little general; a sentence that teases one detail, such as 'and the loudest cheer of all went to a boy who had never competed before', gives the reader a stronger reason to keep reading.
Weak opening (for comparison)
53 words
Sports Day
In this article I am going to write about sports day. Sports day at Fernhill School has always meant the same thing: the running track on the top field, four houses in four colours, and Kingfisher House winning. It started raining at ten past nine, during the Year 7 hundred metres.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full article: an opening like this would hold the writing towards Table G, Level 2–3. The headline is only a label. 'In this article I am going to write about' announces the article instead of starting it. The rest copies the first sentences of paragraphs 1 and 2 word for word, so for Table F it is lifting, which the reading table notes at Level 2. Nothing yet shows that Kezia is writing or what she thinks.
What earns the marks
- A short headline that makes the reader curious, not a label and not the title of Text C.
- An optional strapline that tells the reader the angle.
- A hook in Kezia's own words: a contrast (cancelled in the morning, cheering in the afternoon), a moment or a surprising fact.
- A last sentence saying who is writing and why the day matters.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: the two most common weak openings are 'In this article I will…' and a copy of the first lines of Text C. Both tell the examiner that you are reporting the text rather than writing an article. Spend one minute on the headline and the first sentence before you plan the rest.