Paper 1 Q4 report: spot the difference between a story opening and a news opening
Question 4
You are a reporter for the Castlegate Courier, and you were at the final. Write a news report about the quiz final for the newspaper.
In your report you should:
- describe what happened in the final and how Brook Lane School won
- explain how the team and their supporters felt
- consider what the win means for the school and what happens next.
Base your report on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three bullet points.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
In the exam, Text C is a complete passage; this extract is enough for the practice task.
Practice task (opening only, not a full exam answer). Two candidates began their reports like this.
Opening A
The Final Question
My knees did not stop shaking for two hours. I had never been inside Castlegate Town Hall before and there were four of us on the stage. With one question to go the scores were level and I thought I was going to be sick.
Opening B
Quiz
Mr Pryce, who is a retired headteacher, read out the last question very slowly on the stage at Castlegate Town Hall, and everyone in the hall was waiting to hear what the answer would be.
(a) Explain what goes wrong in each opening.
(b) Write your own headline and first paragraph, in no more than 60 words in total, counting the headline. An opening cannot be marked out of 20 on its own, so the commentary judges which level writing of this standard would support within a complete report.
Insert · Text C (extract)
The Last Question
In this extract from a longer account, Priya Nair, aged fourteen, describes the day her school quiz team competed in a regional final.
1 I had never been inside Castlegate Town Hall before last Thursday, and I hope I never have to sit on that stage again, because my knees did not stop shaking for two hours. There were four of us from Brook Lane School: me, Ollie Grant, Hana Sato and our captain, Marcus Bell, who is in Year 11 and knows the capital of every country in the world. Twelve schools had entered the Wessex Schools Quiz in October. By the final there were only two left: us and St Aldhelm's, who had won it for the last three years.
2 With one question to go, the scores were level at 48 points each. The quizmaster, a retired headteacher called Mr Pryce, read it out slowly: which planet has the shortest day? Marcus looked at me. I had read about it in a library book the week before, and I whispered, 'Jupiter.' He pressed the buzzer. I honestly thought I was going to be sick.
3 When Mr Pryce said 'Correct', the hall erupted. Our head of year, Mrs Okoro, was crying and laughing at the same time. 'I have never been so proud of four people in my life,' she told us. We won a trophy shaped like an owl and £500 for the school library, which Marcus says we should spend on more books about space. In March we go to the national final in Manchester.
- 1
Know what a news opening must do. A reader of the Castlegate Courier should know the whole story from the headline and first paragraph alone: who did what, where, when, and why it matters. This is the five-Ws lead. The most important fact comes first; everything else waits for the paragraphs below.
- 2
Diagnose Opening A: it is a story, not a report. Three signs give it away. It uses 'I', so the candidate has become Priya instead of the reporter the task names; it starts with a feeling ('my knees did not stop shaking') instead of the news; and it copies Priya's words almost exactly, which is lifting. After three sentences the reader still does not know who won. The headline is a title for a story, not a piece of news. Writing like this keeps a whole report near Table F, Level 2, where the voice is inappropriate and there is some lifting.
- 3
Diagnose Opening B: the right voice, the wrong fact. It is in the third person, which is an improvement. But it starts with the least important person in the story, the quizmaster, and keeps the result a secret. A news report is not a mystery: the win is the news, so it goes in the first sentence. 'Quiz' is a label, and a label tells the reader nothing.
- 4
Fill a five-Ws grid from the extract before you write.
W From Text C In the reporter's words Who para 1 four pupils from Brook Lane School What paras 2–3 won the Wessex Schools Quiz final, beating the three-time champions Where para 1 Castlegate Town Hall When para 1 last Thursday Why it matters paras 2–3 won on the very last question; a place in the national final - 5
Write a headline that tells the news. Who + did what, an active verb, no full stop, under twelve words. On Paper 1 the headline earns no marks on its own, so spend seconds on it, not minutes; its job is to show a newspaper register straight away, which helps the writing mark on Table G.
- 6
Write the lead and check it. One sentence, third person, past tense, the result first. Then test it: Is there any 'I'? Is any phrase copied from Priya? Does the reader know who won? Priya's nerves and Mrs Okoro's tears are good material, but they belong in the paragraph that answers bullet 2, not in the opening.
Sound opening (secure level)
43 words
Brook Lane quiz team beat champions with final answer
Four pupils from Brook Lane School won the Wessex Schools Quiz at Castlegate Town Hall last Thursday, beating three-time champions St Aldhelm's by answering the very last question correctly when the scores were tied.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full report: an opening of this standard would support Table F, Level 4 and Table G, Level 4 at least. All five Ws are in one sentence, the result comes first, and the details are in the reporter's words ('three-time champions', 'when the scores were tied'), not Priya's. The headline is short and active, and the register is fixed as a newspaper's from the first line.
How to climb: a Level 5 lead often adds the reason readers should care in a few extra words, for example 'to earn a place in the national final'. Keep it to one sentence, though; a lead that tries to hold every detail becomes hard to read.
What earns the marks
- Opening A is a story: first person, starts with a feeling, lifted from Text C, and the result is missing. Opening B is in the third person but starts with the quizmaster and hides the result; the headline is a label.
- A sound opening: a headline that tells the news (who + active verb + what); a one-sentence lead with who (four Brook Lane pupils), what (won the final, beating the champions), where (Castlegate Town Hall), when (last Thursday) and why it matters (won on the last question).
- Third person, past tense, own words; feelings saved for the bullet 2 paragraph.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: read your first sentence and ask, 'If the reader stopped here, would they know what happened?' If the answer is no, you have written the start of a story. When Text C is told by 'I' and the task makes you a reporter, the narrator becomes a person you mention, such as 'team member Priya Nair, 14', never the voice you write in.