Choosing the descriptive title you can shape
Paper 2 Section B: Composition (40 marks: Table D content and structure 16 + Table E style and accuracy 24; about 350 to 450 words)
These are the four Section B titles. Answer one question only.
2 Describe a hair salon in the last hour before it closes on a Saturday.
3 Describe a room that someone has just moved out of.
4 Write a story with the title, 'The wrong coat'.
5 Write a story which begins, 'Nobody had opened the gate for years.'
You have decided to write a description. Before planning:
(a) Explain what kind of structure each descriptive title (Questions 2 and 3) offers you.
(b) Choose one, and write a short decoding of it: what the description must contain, and what it must keep out.
(This planning decision is rewarded in Table D: content and structure, 16 marks.)
- 1
Sort the four titles first. Questions 2 and 3 say 'Describe'; 4 and 5 say 'Write a story'. Both descriptive titles are marked on the descriptive strand of Table D, which wants well-defined images, close observation and varied focus. Only one answer is marked, so decide on the form before you decide on the content.
- 2
Decode Question 2 word by word. 'Hair salon' is the place; 'last hour' and 'before it closes' give a time frame in which things wind down; 'Saturday' implies it has been busy all day. The shape on offer is a slow fade: noise and people thinning towards an empty, lit room. The risk is that people bring events with them (a customer's haircut going wrong is a story).
- 3
Decode Question 3. 'A room' gives one fixed space; 'someone has just moved out' is a constraint, and the constraint is the content. Every focal point can be a trace of the absent person: the pale rectangle where a poster hung, dents in the carpet from a bed, a forgotten coat hanger. The person never appears, so there are no events to drift into. This is the kind of built-in constraint that hands you a structure.
- 4
Run the one-minute test. Before choosing, try to list five focal points for each title. If five come easily and none of them is an action, the title will hold still. Question 3 passes at once (door, walls, floor, window, cupboard); Question 2 does too, but three of your five may involve people doing things.
- 5
Write the decoding line and the keep-out line. Naming what to exclude before you start is what stops a description turning into a narrative, which Table D names as a limitation at Level 4. Content that is 'highly focused on the task' (Level 6) begins here.
Answer
(a) Question 2 offers a time-bound shape: the salon winding down through its last hour, from busy to empty. Question 3 offers a constraint-led shape: one still room in which every detail is a trace of someone who has gone.
(b) Example decoding (Question 3): 'One empty room, minutes after the last box has gone. Every focal point is a trace of the person: marks, gaps, smells, one forgotten object. Light changes slightly as I look; nothing else happens.' Keep out: the move itself (packing, goodbyes, the van), the person's life story, any dialogue.
A clear choice justified by the structure the title offers, with what to include and exclude, shows the focus and control that Table D Levels 5 and 6 (11–16) reward.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: choose the title you can shape, not the one that sounds most exciting. A title with a built-in limit (a time, an absence, a single object) gives you the structure Table D rewards for free. Before you plan, write one line saying what you will leave out: for a descriptive title, that is almost always the events.