Paper 1 Q4: an opening that speaks to this audience, in role
Question 4
Imagine you are Keziah Mensah, the captain. A month after the final, you give a speech at the club's end-of-season presentation evening to the players, their families and the coaches. Mrs Walsh, who has now announced that she is retiring, is in the audience.
In your speech you should:
- describe what happened on the day of the final
- explain how the team felt during the journey and the match, and how those feelings changed
- say what you think the team has learned from the final, and what you want to say to Mrs Walsh.
Base your speech on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three bullet points.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (opening only, not a full exam answer). Write only the opening of Keziah's speech: the greeting and the first few sentences that set up the occasion and lead into the first bullet, in about 60 to 100 words. An opening cannot be marked out of 20 on its own, so the commentary judges which level writing of this standard would support within a complete speech.
Insert · Text C
Ten Against Eleven
In this account, a man who drives the minibus for a girls' football team describes the day the team played in a county cup final.
1 I have driven the Saltmarsh Under-16s to away matches for four seasons, mostly because my niece, Ama, keeps goal for them and partly because nobody else would. The minibus is older than any of the players. It has a sliding door that sticks, a heater with two settings (too hot and off) and a reputation. On the morning of the County Cup final, the first final in the club's history, I checked the tyres twice.
2 We left the clubhouse at half past seven: fourteen players, their coach Mrs Walsh and me, with kick-off at Hartwell at ten. The fog came in off the estuary before we reached the coast road, so thick that the hedges disappeared and the headlights seemed to stop a few metres in front of the bonnet. The girls, who had been singing, went quiet. At a quarter past eight, on the long hill above Fenmouth, the engine coughed, the temperature needle swung into the red, and steam began to pour from under the bonnet.
3 For a moment nobody said anything. Then Keziah Mensah, the captain, dragged the stubborn door open, stepped out into the fog and said, 'Right. Boots on. We're warming up.' While I lifted the bonnet and Mrs Walsh rang every parent she had a number for, fourteen girls in orange shirts jogged up and down the grass verge in the grey, doing high knees and stretches beside a field of startled sheep. Keziah counted them through every exercise. When Lily Shaw was sick in the hedge, which she said was nerves and was probably my driving, Keziah held her hair back, then went straight back to counting.
4 It took forty minutes for the first two parents' cars to find us, and another twenty for a third. Lily went home in one of them. We reached Hartwell at twenty-five to eleven, ten players and a pale goalkeeper crammed into three hatchbacks. I had assumed the match would have been awarded to Brayford. Instead the referee was standing on the touchline with her watch in her hand, and the Brayford players were still warming up.
5 The game itself I remember in pieces. Brayford scored after six minutes, a low shot that Ama got a hand to and could not keep out. Ten players against eleven is a long morning: every time Brayford switched the ball to the wing there was simply nobody there. But Keziah moved herself back into defence, and twice in the second half she threw herself in front of shots that were going in. With twelve minutes left, Ama punted the ball upfield, it bounced over two defenders, and our smallest player, Grace Liu, ran on to it and scored. The noise our handful of parents made sounded like a stadium. Brayford scored the winner in the last minute.
6 Afterwards, the Brayford players formed two lines and clapped our girls off the pitch. Their captain went to find Keziah and shook her hand for a long time. On the way to the car park, the referee told me quietly that Brayford's coach had asked her to wait as long as the rules allowed. 'He said a final isn't a final if one team isn't in it,' she said.
7 In the car park, while the girls changed, Mrs Walsh leaned on the bonnet of my sister's car and told me what none of the players knew: that this was her last season, after nineteen years, and that the club had not yet found anyone to take her place. 'If nobody comes forward,' she said, 'there may not be an under-16 team next year.' She asked me not to say anything. 'They've had enough for one day.'
8 The girls were quiet on the drive home, but it was not the quiet of the fog. Somewhere past Fenmouth, Keziah turned round in the front seat and said, to nobody in particular, 'Ten of us. Ten of us, and we nearly had them.' Nobody argued. Mrs Walsh looked out of the window and smiled.
- 1
Answer the three voice questions before writing a word. Who is speaking? Keziah, sixteen, the captain. To whom? Players, families and coaches she knows well, at a celebration, with her retiring coach in the room. Why? To retell the day, share what it meant and thank Mrs Walsh. Table F asks for a consistent voice at Level 5 and names a voice that 'may be inappropriate' at Level 2, so these answers decide reading marks as well as writing marks.
- 2
Greet the people actually in the room. A speech is addressed to a present audience, so the first line names them: players, parents, coaches, and Mrs Walsh. 'Hello' or 'Ladies and gentlemen' could open any speech anywhere; naming this audience shows Table G's 'fitness for audience and purpose' from the first sentence.
- 3
Set the occasion and the mood. A presentation evening is warm and a little emotional. A light touch of humour suits it, especially about the coach who is being honoured, as long as it is affectionate. One sentence should place the audience at the start of the story (the minibus, the morning of the final) so the opening leads straight into bullet 1.
- 4
Check every detail against what Keziah knows. She does not know what the referee told the driver about Brayford's coach (paragraph 6), and she does not know that the under-16 team may fold (paragraph 7): Mrs Walsh asked the narrator to keep that quiet. Nor does she share the narrator's thoughts about the minibus's 'reputation'. A speech that drops these in is reporting Text C, not speaking from inside it.
- 5
Never mention the text. Nobody at the presentation evening has read Text C. 'In the text', 'the writer' and 'the narrator' break the role at once.
Model opening (top level)
87 words
Good evening, everyone: players, parents, coaches, and Mrs Walsh, who asked me not to make a fuss of her tonight. I'm going to ignore her.
A month ago, fourteen of us set off for the first final this club has ever played, in a minibus that had other ideas. We didn't bring the cup home. But I'm not sure we came home with nothing, and tonight I want to tell you why. So let me take you back to half past seven on a foggy Saturday morning.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full speech: an opening of this standard would support Table F, Level 5 and Table G, Level 5. The audience is named and present, including the coach being honoured, and the gentle joke ('I'm going to ignore her') fits a celebration and a captain's affection. The voice is unmistakably Keziah's: a teenager speaking to people she knows, using 'we' for the team. Every detail is one she witnessed, and nothing from paragraphs 6 or 7 leaks in. Structurally, the opening previews the speech ('I want to tell you why') and hands over to bullet 1 with a signpost a listener can follow ('let me take you back'), which is the kind of structure Table G credits.
Weak opening (for comparison)
78 words
Hello. In this speech I am going to talk about the County Cup final, which is described in Text C. The writer says he has driven the Saltmarsh Under-16s for four seasons and that the minibus is older than any of the players. On the morning of the final he checked the tyres twice. Mrs Walsh has been our coach for nineteen years and there might not be an under-16 team next year because nobody will replace her.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full speech: an opening like this would pull the reading mark towards Table F, Level 2. 'Text C' and 'The writer says' step outside the role in the first two sentences, and the next two report the narrator's details in his words. The last sentence is worse: Keziah cannot know that the team may fold, because Mrs Walsh told only the narrator, and announcing it at a celebration would be a serious misjudgement of the occasion. For Table G, 'Hello' and 'In this speech I am going to talk about' greet nobody in particular and set up an essay rather than a speech.
What earns the marks
- Greet the audience in the room by name and role: players, parents, coaches, Mrs Walsh.
- Set the occasion and a fitting tone (warm, lightly humorous about the coach being honoured).
- Preview the speech and hand over to bullet 1 with a spoken signpost.
- Use only what Keziah knows; leave out the referee's private remark (paragraph 6) and the threat to the team (paragraph 7); never refer to 'the text' or 'the writer'.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: in Question 4 the narrator and your character are usually different people, and the most tempting details are often the private ones the narrator overhears. Before you plan, put a line through every paragraph your character could not have witnessed. Then write a first line that only this speaker could say to this audience on this evening. If your opening would work for any speech on any topic, rewrite it.