Disadvantages of a cash-free town: concessions out, examples compressed
Read Text B, The last coin in Holmbridge, in the insert and then answer Question 2(a).
(a) According to Text B, what are the disadvantages of Holmbridge becoming a cash-free town?
Use continuous writing (not note form) and use your own words as far as possible.
Your summary should not be more than 120 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for reading and up to 5 marks for writing. [15]
Insert · Text B
The last coin in Holmbridge
In this newspaper column, Nell Ashworth writes about her market town, Holmbridge, which has stopped using cash.
When the last bank branch in Holmbridge closed in March, its cash machine went with it. Within six months, the bakery, the newsagent and even the parish church's collection plate had switched to card readers. The town council now describes Holmbridge, without apparent irony, as 'the first cash-free market town in the county'. I have been trying to work out what we have lost.
Let me be fair to the machines first. Paying by card or phone is undeniably quick: queues at the bakery move faster, and shopkeepers no longer spend an hour each evening counting coins and driving to a bank that is now forty minutes away. Businesses say that break-ins have almost stopped, since there is nothing in the till worth stealing. I enjoy tapping my phone as much as anyone.
But the convenience is not shared equally. Around one adult in twelve in the county has no bank account, according to the citizens' advice centre, and many more rely on cash because it lets them see exactly what they have left. Margaret Hale, who is eighty-four, told me she used to divide her pension into envelopes on the kitchen table: one for the gas, one for food, one for her grandchildren's birthdays. 'Now it is all numbers on a screen,' she said, 'and the numbers never feel real until they have gone.' People on tight budgets are, in other words, losing a simple way to control their spending.
Then there are the people the new systems simply forget. Card readers depend on a phone signal, and Holmbridge's signal disappears in heavy rain; on the wettest Saturday in October, the market stalls could take no payments at all for most of the morning. Several older residents have no smartphone and struggle with the small screens on card machines. Children, too, have lost something: a ten-year-old cannot be handed a few coins and sent to buy bread, and the pocket money that once taught a generation the value of saving now arrives, if at all, as an app their parents control.
Privacy is the quieter cost. Every tap leaves a record of where we were and what we bought, held by companies whose business is selling insight into our habits. Cash asked no questions. A card payment answers dozens.
Charities have noticed the change most sharply. The church's collection is down by a third since the plate was replaced by a card reader by the door, and the street collectors who raise money for the lifeboat station report that people walking past simply say they have nothing on them. Small acts of generosity, it turns out, depended on loose change.
Nor is a cashless town a cheap one for its traders. Each card payment costs the seller a small fee, and for the market's fruit stall, which works on thin margins, those fees now add up to more than its rent. A few traders have quietly raised their prices to cover them.
None of this means we should march back to the days of coins in jam jars. But a town that calls itself modern should notice who it is leaving behind. Keeping one cash machine and requiring shops to accept notes would cost little. Losing the people who depend on them would cost a great deal more.
- 1
Decode the focus and fence off the counter-material. One strand: disadvantages of going cash-free. Two whole paragraphs earn nothing. Paragraph 2 ('Let me be fair to the machines first') is a concession listing advantages: speed, no counting, fewer break-ins. The final paragraph is the writer's recommendation (keep a cash machine), which is a solution, not a disadvantage. Put a line through both before you start, so that nothing from them can creep in.
- 2
List the passage points and decide which count.
- 'one adult in twelve … has no bank account' → people without bank accounts are shut out ✔
- 'lets them see exactly what they have left … control their spending' → people on tight budgets lose an easy way to manage money ✔
- 'depend on a phone signal … could take no payments' → payments fail when the signal does ✔
- 'no smartphone and struggle with the small screens' → older people find the technology hard ✔
- 'cannot be handed a few coins and sent to buy bread' → children lose small errands and independence ✔
- 'pocket money that once taught … the value of saving' → children no longer learn to save ✔
- 'Every tap leaves a record' → loss of privacy ✔
- 'companies whose business is selling insight' → that information is used for profit ✔
- 'collection is down by a third … nothing on them … depended on loose change' → casual giving to charity has fallen ✔ (one umbrella point, not three)
- 'costs the seller a small fee … more than its rent' → card fees hurt small traders ✔
- 'raised their prices' → customers end up paying more ✔
Leave out: the bank closure and the council's slogan (background), Margaret Hale's envelopes and her quotation (an anecdote illustrating the budgeting point), the wettest Saturday (an example of signal failure), 'one in twelve' and 'a third' (figures, not points), and the whole of paragraphs 2 and 8.
- 3
Compress anecdotes and figures into the point they prove. Margaret's envelopes take about forty words in the text and earn one point: cash helps people keep track of what they can afford. The church, the lifeboat collectors and 'loose change' are three illustrations of one idea: casual giving has collapsed. The fruit stall's rent becomes fees squeeze small traders. Every example you convert this way frees words for another point.
- 4
Own words means rebuilding the sentence, not swapping its words. Compare three versions of 'many more rely on cash because it lets them see exactly what they have left':
- Lifted: 'many rely on cash because it lets them see exactly what they have left'
- Synonym-swapped: 'many depend on cash because it permits them to view precisely what they have remaining' (the writer's sentence in a thin disguise: same structure, same order, each word replaced)
- Re-expressed: 'others depend on notes and coins to keep track of what they can afford' (the idea is rebuilt from the candidate's understanding)
Only the third shows understanding, and only the third earns the Table B credit for concise vocabulary that is the candidate's own.
- 5
Group for an overview, then draft. Five groups, in a logical order: who is excluded (no account, budgeting); reliability and usability (signal, older people); children (errands, saving); privacy (records, profit); money flows (charity, fees, higher prices). One sentence per group keeps the answer near 115 words with no introduction and no conclusion.
Model answer (top level)
116 words
Many residents are shut out, since some adults have no bank account and others depend on notes and coins to keep track of what they can afford. Card machines need a phone signal, so trading can halt in bad weather, and older people without smartphones find the technology hard to use. Children can no longer be trusted with small errands, and they lose the chance to learn saving by handling money of their own. Every payment also creates a record of people's movements and purchases that companies can exploit. Casual giving has collapsed, hurting charities, and the fees charged on each card transaction squeeze small traders, some of whom have passed the cost on to shoppers.
How it is marked
Reading: Table A, Level 5, 10 marks. All eleven relevant ideas are present and the focus never slips: nothing from the concession paragraph or the recommendation appears. The anecdotes are reduced to their points ('keep track of what they can afford', 'Casual giving has collapsed') and the figures are left out, which is the skilful selection and overview Level 5 describes.
Writing: Table B, Level 3, 5 marks. Expression is fluent and the ideas are organised into five clear groups rather than following the text paragraph by paragraph. Links show cause and consequence ('since', 'so', 'some of whom have passed the cost on'). The vocabulary is concise and the candidate's own ('shut out', 'halt', 'exploit', 'squeeze'): this is genuine re-expression, not synonym-swapping.
Near-miss answer (for comparison)
116 words
Some adults have no bank account and many more depend on cash because it permits them to view precisely what they have remaining. Margaret Hale, aged eighty-four, divided her pension into envelopes for gas, food and birthdays. Card readers rely on a phone signal, which vanishes in heavy rain, so on the wettest Saturday the market could accept no payments. Older inhabitants have no smartphone. Children cannot be given coins and sent to purchase bread. Every tap leaves a record of where people were. The church collection has fallen by a third. Each card payment costs the seller a small charge. Although queues move faster and break-ins have nearly stopped, the town is leaving people behind.
How it is marked
Reading: Table A, Level 4, 7 marks. A good range of disadvantages is identified (no account, budgeting, signal, older people, children's errands, privacy, charity, fees), but the selection is not yet skilful. About twenty words go on Margaret Hale's envelopes and another fifteen on the wettest Saturday, so the examples are kept instead of being converted. The final sentence imports a concession from paragraph 2 ('queues move faster and break-ins have nearly stopped'), which is off focus. Children's saving, the commercial use of personal data and the higher prices are missed, and the church collection is given as a figure without the point it proves.
Writing: Table B, Level 1, 1 mark. This is the trap of synonym-swapping. 'Permits them to view precisely what they have remaining', 'vanishes in heavy rain', 'inhabitants' and 'purchase bread' keep the writer's sentences intact and replace single words, so the response still 'includes lifted sections' in substance. The organisation follows the text, and the short, list-like sentences ('Older inhabitants have no smartphone.') lack the fluency of Level 3. Total: 8/15.
What separates it from the model: the model found eleven points by converting every example into an idea and rebuilt each idea from scratch. The near-miss spent its words on illustration and disguise.
What earns the marks
- Creditable points: people without bank accounts excluded; people on tight budgets lose an easy way to control spending; card payments depend on a signal and fail in bad weather; older people without smartphones struggle; children cannot run small errands; children no longer learn to save; every payment is recorded; that data is exploited commercially; casual charitable giving has fallen; card fees hurt small traders; some prices have risen.
- Not creditable: the speed, safety and convenience in paragraph 2 (a concession), the recommendation to keep a cash machine, and anecdotes or figures copied without their point.
- Continuous prose, own words rebuilt rather than synonym-swapped, no introduction or conclusion, within 120 words.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: replacing each word of a sentence with a synonym is not using your own words. If the sentence still has the writer's shape, the examiner can see the original through it, and it is treated as lifting. Close the text, say the idea to yourself in plain terms, then write that. And before you start, strike through any paragraph that opens with 'Let me be fair' or 'Admittedly': a concession about advantages can never answer a question about disadvantages.