Lift one word, then find two separate reasons
Read Text A, Masters of the night sky, in the insert and then answer the questions below.
1(a) Re-read paragraph 1. Give the other name for bats that the writer mentions. [1]
1(b) Re-read paragraph 2. Identify two reasons why bats were rarely seen clearly. [2]
Insert · Text A
Masters of the night sky
In this article from a wildlife magazine, the writer explains why bats deserve a better reputation.
1 Few animals have been as badly misunderstood as the bat. For centuries, these small, furry mammals, known in older country dialects as 'flittermice', were treated as omens of bad luck, and in many places they still are. Yet the more scientists learn about bats, the harder it becomes to see them as anything but remarkable.
2 Much of the old fear came from the way bats live. They sleep through the day hanging upside down in caves, attics and church towers, and appear only at dusk, when their sudden, jerky flight makes them hard to follow with the eye. Because they were rarely seen clearly, people filled the gaps with stories. The most stubborn of these is that bats are blind. In fact every species can see, and some see rather well; it is simply that sight is not their main tool for hunting.
3 That tool is sound. As it flies, a hunting bat sends out a stream of high-pitched calls, far too high for human ears, and listens for the echoes that bounce back. From these echoes it can judge the size, shape and distance of an object, and even which way an insect is moving, in a fraction of a second. A single pipistrelle, a bat small enough to fit in a matchbox, may snap up three thousand insects in one night.
4 That appetite makes bats valuable allies. Farmers who once drove them out of barns now put up bat boxes, because bats devour the moths and beetles that damage crops, reducing the need for chemical sprays. In warmer parts of the world, fruit-eating bats carry pollen from flower to flower and scatter seeds across cleared land, helping forests grow back.
5 Yet bats are in trouble. Old buildings where they roost are being converted or demolished, hedgerows that guide their flight have been grubbed up, and bright street lighting drives many species away from their feeding grounds. Because most bats raise only one pup a year, a population that falls takes a very long time to recover. It would be a sad irony if, just as we have finally learned to appreciate these creatures, we allowed them to quietly disappear.
- 1
Read the tariffs before the text. 1(a) is worth 1 mark, so it wants one word or phrase lifted from paragraph 1, with nothing added. 1(b) is worth 2 marks, so it wants two different ideas, both from paragraph 2. Neither item says 'in your own words', so the text's wording is acceptable here (R1, R5).
- 2
1(a): locate the naming phrase. Names are usually signalled: 'known in older country dialects as 'flittermice''. That word is the answer (1). A singular 'flittermouse' is also accepted, since spelling is not being tested and the meaning is unambiguous.
Not credited: 'small, furry mammals' (a description, not another name); 'omens of bad luck' (what bats were thought to be, not what they were called); 'flittermice or mammals' (covering two possibilities, which earns nothing).
- 3
1(b): box paragraph 2 and find the 'why'. The question asks why bats were rarely seen clearly, so look for what made them hard to see, not what people believed about them. Three creditable ideas are present:
- they spend the daylight hours asleep in dark, out-of-the-way places such as caves, attics and towers (1)
- they come out only at dusk, when the light is fading (1)
- their flight is sudden and jerky, so the eye cannot follow them (1)
Any two score the 2 marks.
- 4
Check the two answers are genuinely different. 'They hang upside down in caves' and 'they sleep in attics and church towers' are the same idea (where bats rest by day) in two examples, so they earn 1 mark, not 2. The mark scheme does not credit repetition of a point already rewarded.
Not credited: 'people thought bats were blind' (that is a belief that grew out of bats being rarely seen, and the text says it is false); 'they were omens of bad luck' (paragraph 1 — the wrong paragraph, and not a reason they were hard to see).
Answer
- 1(a): flittermice / flittermouse (1)
- 1(b): any two of: they are asleep and hidden away in dark places (caves, attics, church towers) during the day (1); they only appear at dusk when the light is poor (1); their flight is sudden and jerky, so it is hard to follow (1)
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: on a 1-mark 'give' item, write the word and stop. Extra material can only hurt you, because an answer that offers two possibilities is treated as covering all options and earns nothing. On a 'two reasons' item, test each answer by asking 'is this a different reason, or the same reason with a different example?' Two places where bats sleep are one reason. And stay inside the paragraph the question names: the right idea from the wrong paragraph is still the wrong answer.