Finding the points: number them in the margin, then test each one against the focus
Read Text B, Room 14 after the bell, in the insert and then answer Question 2(a).
(a) According to Text B, what are the benefits of the homework club at Ashgrove Academy?
Use continuous writing (not note form) and use your own words as far as possible.
Your summary should not be more than 120 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for reading and up to 5 marks for writing.
Insert · Text B
Room 14 after the bell
In this article for the Ashgrove Academy newsletter, Year 11 student Priya Nandakumar writes about the school's after-school homework club. This is a shortened practice text.
At ten past three on a Tuesday, most of Ashgrove Academy empties in minutes. Room 14 does not. By quarter past, around thirty students have their books out, and a maths teacher is walking between the tables with a mug of tea. This is Homework Club, and when it started last September I thought it was only for people who were behind. I was wrong.
The most obvious benefit is help. If you are stuck on a question at home, you can sit staring at it for an hour. In Room 14 there is always a teacher or a sixth-former nearby who can explain it in two minutes, so small problems do not turn into big ones.
The club also gives students somewhere quiet to work. Not everyone has a desk at home, or a room without younger brothers and sisters. My friend Tomasz shares a bedroom with two of them, and he says the club is the only place he can think. The library computers are available too, which matters for anyone without a laptop or reliable internet at home.
Then there is time. Homework done by half past four is homework that is not hanging over your evening. Parents have noticed: several told the head teacher that arguments about homework at home have almost stopped.
There are biscuits, which is no small thing at the end of a long day. More seriously, students say they have become more organised, because a teacher checks their planner every week, and teachers report that more homework is handed in on time — up from about seventy per cent to over ninety in one year.
Some students think the club is uncool, and it is true that it can get noisy on Fridays. But for most of us, Room 14 has become the most useful hour of the day.
- 1
Underline the focus before you read. The key word is benefits, and they must be benefits of the homework club. That is one strand. Anything that is not a benefit (a description of the room, the writer's first impression, the drawbacks at the end) will earn nothing in Table A, however interesting it is.
- 2
Read once for the gist, then read again with a pencil. On the second read, put a number in the margin each time you meet a new benefit. Do not stop to write sentences yet. For this text the margin numbers fall like this:
- (1) 'always a teacher or a sixth-former nearby who can explain it' → help is on hand
- (2) 'small problems do not turn into big ones' → difficulties are sorted out early
- (3) 'somewhere quiet to work' → a calm place to study
- (4) 'library computers are available' → access to technology
- (5) 'not hanging over your evening' → evenings are free
- (6) 'arguments about homework at home have almost stopped' → fewer family rows
- (7) 'a teacher checks their planner' → students become more organised
- (8) 'more homework is handed in on time' → better homework completion
- 3
Test every possible point with two questions. Is it a benefit of the club? and Is it a new idea, or an example of one I have already numbered?
- The empty school and the teacher's mug of tea: scene-setting, not a benefit ✘
- 'I thought it was only for people who were behind': the writer's story ✘
- Tomasz sharing a bedroom: an example of point (3), so it adds no new idea ✘
- 'up from about seventy per cent to over ninety': a figure that proves point (8); the point is the improvement, not the numbers ✘
- The biscuits: the writer moves on with 'More seriously', a sign she is joking, so it is not worth spending words on ✘
- 'uncool' and 'noisy on Fridays': drawbacks, the opposite of the focus ✘
- 4
Turn each numbered point into a short note in your own words. Do this before you draft, so you are not tempted to copy whole sentences: (1) quick explanations from staff or older students; (2) problems fixed before they grow; (3) calm study space for those without one at home; (4) computers for those without a device or internet; (5) work finished early, evenings free; (6) fewer rows at home; (7) weekly planner checks, better organisation; (8) more work submitted on time.
- 5
Write the notes up as continuous prose. Join related points with connectives ('also', 'because', 'and', 'in addition') so the summary reads as sentences, not a list. Start with the first point. Eight points in 120 words gives you about 15 words per point, which is plenty.
- 6
Where the marks come from. Table A (reading, 10 marks) rewards the range of relevant points you find and how well you keep to the focus (R1, R5). Table B (writing, 5 marks) rewards clear, fluent expression, sensible organisation and your own concise vocabulary (W1–W3). A list of copied phrases can collect some reading marks but almost nothing for writing, as the comparison below shows.
Weak answer (for comparison)
52 words
- always a teacher or a sixth-former nearby who can explain it in two minutes
- somewhere quiet to work
- library computers are available
- homework done by half past four
- arguments about homework at home have almost stopped
- more homework is handed in on time, up from about seventy per cent to over ninety
How it is marked
Reading: Table A, Level 3, 5 marks. Six relevant benefits are present, so the candidate has clearly found the right part of the text (R1, R5). But each one is copied, so the answer shows where the points are rather than showing that they have been understood, and the figure 'seventy per cent to over ninety' is evidence, not a point. Points (2) and (7) are missed.
Writing: Table B, Level 1, 1 mark. The question asks for continuous writing, not note form. Every line is lifted, and there is no organisation beyond the order of the text, which matches the Level 1 description of an answer that includes lifted sections.
Total: 6/15.
Sound answer (secure level)
80 words
Students who get stuck can ask a nearby teacher or older student, who explains the problem quickly. The club also provides a calm place to study for those who have no suitable space at home. Because work is completed straight after school, students have their evenings free, and parents say family rows about homework have almost disappeared. In addition, weekly checks of their planners have helped students become better organised, and far more work is now handed in on time.
How it is marked
Reading: Table A, Level 4, 7 marks. Six of the eight benefits are here and every sentence stays on the focus (R1, R5). Tomasz, the biscuits, the figures and the drawbacks have all been left out, which shows sound judgement about relevance.
Writing: Table B, Level 3, 4 marks. The answer starts with its first point, is written in fluent sentences, and links ideas with 'also', 'Because' and 'In addition' (W1, W2). The wording is mostly the candidate's own ('calm place to study', 'no suitable space', 'better organised'); 'handed in on time' stays close to the text, which keeps it at 4 rather than 5.
Total: 11/15.
How to climb: there are still about forty words to spare. Add the two missing points in your own words, for example 'so minor difficulties are sorted out before they grow' after the first sentence, and 'as well as computers for anyone without their own device or a good internet connection' after the second. That would lift Reading to Level 5.
What earns the marks
- Creditable points (benefits only): (1) quick help from staff or sixth-formers; (2) problems dealt with before they grow; (3) a quiet place to work for those without one at home; (4) computers for those without a device or reliable internet; (5) homework finished early, leaving evenings free; (6) fewer arguments about homework at home; (7) students become more organised through weekly planner checks; (8) more homework handed in on time.
- Not creditable: the scene in Room 14, the writer's first impression, Tomasz's bedroom (an example), the percentages (evidence), the biscuits, and the drawbacks ('uncool', 'noisy').
- Continuous prose, own words, no introduction, under 120 words.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: do the finding and the writing as two separate jobs. Numbering points in the margin first stops you missing ideas hidden in the middle of a paragraph (such as 'small problems do not turn into big ones'), and it stops you copying, because you write from your own short notes rather than from the text. If a line in your plan is an example or a number, ask what idea it proves and write that idea instead.