Question 3(a): finding the image that matches a plain idea
Read Text C, Four minutes on the stage, in the insert and then answer Question 3(a)(i).
(a) Identify a word or phrase from Text C which suggests the same idea as the words in bold:
(i) Before the concert, the narrator's hands had become cold and clumsy. [1]
(In the exam, 3(a) has two items worth 1 mark each. This example practises the first item on its own.)
Insert · Text C
Four minutes on the stage
In this account, the writer remembers playing a cello solo at her school's winter concert in the town of Brackwell.
1 For six weeks I had practised the solo in our cramped back bedroom, with the door shut and a towel pushed against the gap underneath it so that my brothers could not hear. I knew every note. I could play it with my eyes closed, and sometimes, late at night, I did. But on the evening of the winter concert, standing in the corridor behind the school hall, I discovered that knowing every note and being able to play them in front of three hundred people were two entirely different things.
2 The corridor smelled of floor polish and damp coats. Younger children in white shirts fidgeted in a line along the wall, and somewhere a trumpet player was warming up with the same three notes, over and over, like a car that would not start. Through the double doors I could hear the audience settling: a wave of coughs, the scrape of chairs, a baby that was hushed and then hushed again. My hands, which had been perfectly steady all week, had turned into two cold fish.
3 When Mr Pryce, the music teacher, finally waved me on, the stage seemed to stretch for a mile. The lights were fierce and white, and beyond them the hall was a dark sea of faces in which I could pick out nothing at all except, in the third row, my grandmother's red hat, glowing like a coal. I sat down, settled the cello between my knees and lifted the bow. For one terrible second the silence pressed down on me like a heavy blanket, and I was certain I had forgotten how to begin.
4 Then my fingers remembered what my head had lost. The first note came out thin and wavering, but the second was stronger, and by the fourth bar the music had begun to carry me instead of the other way round. I stopped seeing the faces. I stopped hearing the coughs. There was only the deep, warm voice of the cello rising into the rafters, and my heart, which had been hammering like a fist on a locked door, slowed to the beat of the tune.
5 I did not play it perfectly. I rushed one passage and fumbled a high note so badly that I heard Mr Pryce draw in his breath at the side of the stage. But when the last note faded, there was a pause, and then the applause broke over me like warm rain. My grandmother was on her feet. I bowed, too quickly, and nearly walked into the piano on my way off.
6 Afterwards, in the corridor, Mr Pryce handed me my case and said only, 'Next year, slow down in the middle.' It was the nicest thing he had ever said to me.
- 1
Understand what the question is asking. The bold words give you a plain, everyday idea: cold, clumsy hands. Somewhere in Text C the writer says the same thing in a more interesting way, usually through an image. You are looking for the writer's version, not for the same words. That is why this is a language question (R1, R2) and not a word-search.
- 2
Find the right part of the text. The item is about her hands before the concert, so look at the paragraphs set in the corridor before she goes on stage. Paragraph 2 ends with a sentence about her hands.
- 3
Test each possible answer against the bold words. 'My hands, which had been perfectly steady all week' describes her hands, but it gives the opposite idea (steady, not clumsy), so it cannot be right. 'had turned into two cold fish' is the image. Ask what fish are like: cold, wet, slippery and floppy, so hard to control. That covers both 'cold' and 'clumsy'. (1)
- 4
Spot the difference between a weak and a sound answer.
- Weak: 'My hands, which had been perfectly steady all week, had turned into two cold fish.' The whole sentence includes the 'steady' clause, which says the opposite, so the examiner cannot be sure which part you mean. This risks the mark.
- Weak: 'cold'. Only half the idea: it says nothing about clumsiness.
- Sound: 'two cold fish'. Short, exact, and it carries the whole idea.
- 5
Write the phrase and stop. A 1-mark item wants one word or phrase copied accurately. Do not explain it: an explanation earns nothing extra here and uses time you need for 3(d).
Answer
(i) 'two cold fish' (accept 'had turned into two cold fish') (1)
Not credited: 'perfectly steady' (the opposite idea); 'cold' on its own (only half the idea); a copied sentence that includes the opposite idea alongside the answer.
Total: 1 mark.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: in 3(a), the answer is nearly always the writer's figurative way of saying the plain idea in the bold words, so look for the picture, not matching vocabulary. Before you write, check your phrase covers every part of the bold words, and that it does not also contain something that contradicts them.