Paper 2 Q1(a): evaluating an ironic columnist's attitude to gap years
Read Text A and Text B in the insert and then answer Section A, Question 1(a) and 1(b).
(a) Reread Text B.
Use your own words to evaluate Gil Varney's attitude to gap years. Give details from the text to justify your answer. [5]
Insert · Text A
A Year Off the Conveyor Belt
This feature appeared in the weekend magazine of a national newspaper.
When Tamsin Okoro finished school, she had been a student for fourteen years without a break longer than a summer holiday. 'I had a place to study law,' she says, 'and I couldn't have told you why, except that everyone said I'd be good at arguing.' She deferred her place, and her parents, she admits, 'went very quiet'.
For six months she worked early shifts in a supermarket bakery, saving almost every penny. Then she spent three months with a reforestation charity in the hills above Valderra, planting saplings, measuring soil moisture and, in the evenings, learning enough of the local language to argue with the cook. She paid £2,400 for the placement, which covered food and a dormitory bed. The last three months she spent at home, working again and rewriting her university application. She is now in the second year of a degree in environmental science.
Tamsin is not unusual, according to the people who arrange such years. A survey by Horizon Year, one of the largest gap-year companies, found that nine in ten of its former travellers said the experience had made them more confident, and seven in ten said it had helped them choose a course. 'Students who arrive after a gap year are older, clearer about why they're here and, in my experience, less likely to drop out,' says Dr Alan Frew, an admissions tutor.
Not every gap year goes to plan. Tamsin's friend Corin booked a month of 'wildlife volunteering' online and spent it mainly cleaning cages for tourists' photographs. But Tamsin is clear. 'The bakery taught me as much as the forest did. I learned what it costs to earn £2,400, and I stopped treating education as a conveyor belt.'
Insert · Text B
Find Yourself: Terms and Conditions Apply
In this column for a magazine for parents, Gil Varney, a university lecturer, gives his view of gap years.
Every autumn, a fresh crop of nineteen-year-olds returns from the far side of the world to tell me they have found themselves. It is remarkable how often the self they found was waiting in the same three countries, at the same beach bars, in the same photographs.
I should declare an interest: I took a year off myself, long ago, and spent most of it washing dishes in a seaside hotel. Nobody called it a gap year then. Nobody charged me for it, either.
Today the gap year is an industry, and a clever one. For a few thousand pounds, an eighteen-year-old can spend a fortnight painting a village school, which has usually been painted by the previous group a fortnight earlier, while a local builder who could have done the job properly watches from the shade. The companies are understandably delighted with the results. One has surveyed its own customers and discovered, to nobody's surprise, that nine in ten think the money was well spent. I imagine most people who have bought an expensive holiday would say the same.
Then there is the question of who can afford to find themselves. Fewer than one school-leaver in ten takes a gap year, and most of those spend it working rather than travelling. The glossy brochure year belongs largely to families who can write a cheque.
Please do not mistake me for an enemy of the year off. Some of the best students I have taught arrived late: a young woman who had nursed her grandmother for a year, a young man who had worked on building sites and knew exactly why he wanted to study engineering. What they brought was not a suntan but a reason. A year away can give you one. You just do not need to buy it.
- 1
Separate what he mocks from what he values. A first reading suggests he is against gap years. Read again and the target narrows: he mocks the paid, packaged year (the same resorts, the repainted school, the self-congratulating survey) and the privilege behind it, but his last paragraph praises students who took time out and came back with a purpose. 'Evaluate' asks for a judgement, and Table A's top level needs one that fits the whole column, not just its first half.
- 2
Put the judgement in one clause, in your own words. For example: scornful of the commercial gap year, but warmly in favour of time out that gives a student a reason to study. 'Mixed feelings' is not a judgement; it describes almost any writer.
- 3
Show how the attitude is conveyed (R4). Question 1(a) assesses R4, so comment on method as well as meaning. His irony carries the scorn: the claim that people 'found themselves' in the same three countries, the school painted a fortnight earlier, the survey whose result surprised 'nobody'. The shift in tone at 'Please do not mistake me for an enemy of the year off' signals the sincere view that follows.
- 4
Choose details that carry the attitude, and keep it short. Three or four brief references, each with a clause on what it reveals, are enough for 5 marks. Facts that are neutral in themselves (fewer than one in ten take a gap year) only count if you say what he does with them: he uses that figure to argue that the brochure year belongs to the well-off.
Model answer (top level)
136 words
Varney is scornful of the commercial gap year but genuinely in favour of time out that gives a student a purpose. His irony exposes the industry: teenagers claim to have discovered themselves in the same few resorts, and paying volunteers repaint a school decorated a fortnight earlier while a local builder who needs the work looks on. He dismisses the company's survey of its own customers as proof of nothing, since buyers of any costly trip would praise it, and he resents that the brochure version is mostly for wealthy families. Yet his tone becomes sincere when he praises students who arrived late with a clear motive, after caring for a relative or labouring on building sites. His closing line makes the distinction clear: the value lies in finding a reason, not in paying for one.
How it is marked
Table A, Level 3: 5 marks. The judgement in the first sentence covers the whole column, separating what he scorns from what he values, and it is in the candidate's own words. Each strand is supported by a brief, re-expressed detail (the resorts, the repainted school, the survey, the cost, the late arrivals), and each detail is interpreted, not just reported. The answer also explains how the attitude is conveyed (irony for the scorn, a change to a sincere tone for the approval), which earns R4 credit. It evaluates rather than summarises.
Near-miss answer (for comparison)
93 words
Gil Varney is against gap years. He says young people come back saying they have found themselves but they all go to the same places. He says volunteers paint a school that was already painted and a local builder watches. He thinks the survey of nine in ten is not reliable because the company asked its own customers. He also says fewer than one in ten school-leavers take a gap year and most of them work. He says some of his best students arrived late. So overall he does not like gap years.
How it is marked
Table A, Level 2: 3 marks. The details are relevant and accurately understood, and the point about the survey shows some evaluation. But the overall judgement ('against gap years', 'does not like gap years') fits only the first half of the column, and the answer even includes the detail that undoes it (his best students arrived late) without noticing what it shows. Most sentences begin 'He says', so the answer reports rather than evaluates, and nothing is said about how the irony conveys his attitude, so R4 is barely touched.
What separates Level 3 from Level 2 here: a judgement precise enough to hold the whole text (scorn for the industry, approval of purposeful time out), and a comment on the method (irony, then a sincere turn) that shows how the attitude reaches the reader.
What earns the marks
Creditable points, in own words, each supported by a detail:
- Overall judgement: scornful of the commercial, paid-for gap year but in favour of time out that gives a student a purpose.
- Ironic about young people who claim to have 'found themselves' in identical holiday destinations.
- Critical of unskilled paid volunteering that takes work from local people (the twice-painted school, the builder in the shade).
- Dismissive of the company's survey of its own customers as self-serving.
- Resentful that the glossy version is mainly for families who can afford it (fewer than one in ten take a gap year; most work).
- Warmly approving of students who took time out and returned with a reason (the carer, the building-site worker).
- How it is conveyed: irony and mock-praise ('understandably delighted', 'to nobody's surprise'), then a sincere change of tone in the last paragraph. [5]
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: an ironic writer's first paragraphs are rarely the whole story. Before you write, read the last paragraph again and ask whether it changes the target of the criticism. Then name the attitude so that it fits both halves, and say how the irony carries it: Question 1(a) assesses R4, so method is now worth marks as well as meaning.