Paper 1 Q4 interview: set out the three questions and plan an answer to each
Question 4
Imagine you are Noor. Two months after the expedition, you are interviewed on Riverside Live, a regional radio programme. The presenter asks you these three questions:
- What were the main challenges you faced each day on the river?
- How did you feel about the way people along the river reacted to you?
- What do you think the expedition achieved?
Write the words of the interview.
Base your interview on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three questions.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (planning stage, not a full exam answer). You have about four minutes to plan. Write only your plan: who is speaking and to whom, how you will set out the interview, the details you will use for each of the three questions, and one note per question on how you will develop it. A plan earns no marks on its own; the commentary shows which parts of Table F and Table G a plan like this protects.
Insert · Text C
Forty Days on the Tavan
In this account, seventeen-year-old Noor Haddad describes paddling the length of a river with her uncle to collect water samples.
1 The Tavan rises in a bog on Mount Ceru and reaches the sea at Port Alder, nine hundred kilometres later. My uncle Teodor had wanted to paddle all of it since he was my age. What he had not done, until last summer, was find someone stubborn enough to go with him. I was seventeen, I had paddled a kayak exactly four times, and I had just been told by a university scientist, Dr Okonjo, that nobody had ever measured how much plastic the river carried along its whole length. She gave us forty sample bottles, a fine-mesh net and a waterproof notebook. 'One sample a day,' she said. 'Same time, same method. Don't be heroic.'
2 We were heroic by accident within a week. The upper river is shallow and full of stones, and we spent more time dragging the boats than sitting in them. My hands blistered on the second day, the blisters burst on the third, and by the fifth I had wrapped both palms in tape and stopped looking at them. Every morning at nine, however tired we were, I sat on the bank with the net and the notebook while Uncle Teodor packed the tent, because a sample taken at nine one morning had to be matched by one taken at nine the next, whatever the weather.
3 The weather did not co-operate. On day eleven a storm turned the river brown in an hour, and we sheltered under a road bridge while lorries thundered overhead. On day nineteen we reached the Grell Gorge, where the river drops through a series of rapids that Uncle Teodor had studied on maps for twenty years. We carried both kayaks around the worst of them, a climb of two kilometres along a goat path, and I cried quietly halfway up, where he could not see me.
4 People along the river did not know what to make of us. In Varnow a group of fishermen laughed when I explained the bottles, and one of them, a broad man with a cap pulled down to his eyebrows, asked whether we were going to count the fish as well. The next morning he was waiting on the jetty with a bag of bread rolls and a hand-drawn map of the sandbanks below the town. 'For the counting girl,' he said. In Lessa a schoolteacher brought her whole class to watch me take a sample, and the children argued over who would hold the net. Elsewhere, people simply stared. A woman hanging out washing in Orbin watched us paddle the entire length of her village without a word or a wave.
5 Below Orbin the river widens and slows, and the plastic began to show itself without the net: bottles caught in the reeds, a child's sandal turning in an eddy, a sheet of polythene draped over a branch like a flag. My samples from the lower river were cloudy with fragments. I wrote the numbers down and tried not to think about what they meant until I could give them to someone who would know.
6 We reached Port Alder on the fortieth day, an hour before dark. Nobody was waiting; we had not told anyone when we would arrive, because we had not known ourselves. Uncle Teodor shook my hand, very formally, and then hugged me so hard that my paddle fell in the water.
7 Dr Okonjo's results came in October. Our forty samples are now the first complete record of plastic along the Tavan, and the regional water board has asked to see them. I still have the tape marks on my palms, faint and white. When people ask me whether it was fun, I never quite know what to say.
- 1
Fix the speaker and the listener. You are Noor, the narrator of Text C, so her experiences and feelings are yours to use. The listener is a radio audience who have not read Text C, so every detail needs enough context to make sense when heard. The register is spoken: natural, clear, personal, but controlled. Table F asks for a consistent voice at Level 5 and says at Level 2 that the voice 'may be inappropriate', so this decision earns reading marks.
- 2
Decide the layout. An interview is a script of exchanges: the presenter's question on one line, labelled, then Noor's answer, labelled. Copy each set question once, briefly; the questions themselves earn nothing, so do not invent extra ones or write a long welcome. The first words that count are Noor's answer to question 1, and the interview ends when she has answered question 3.
- 3
See the ladder in the questions. Question 1 asks for recall and selection (the challenges of each day). Question 2 asks for feeling (her reaction to other people's reactions). Question 3 asks for judgement (what the expedition achieved). Table F Level 5 wants all three well covered; uneven coverage is a Level 3 feature, so give each answer roughly a third of the words.
- 4
Sort details by question, not by paragraph of the text. Question 1: the shallow upper river and dragging the boats, the blisters and tape, the daily nine o'clock sample in all weathers, the storm, the gorge (paragraphs 2–3). Question 2: the Varnow fishermen who mocked and then helped, the Lessa children, the silent woman in Orbin (paragraph 4), the empty quay at Port Alder (paragraph 6). Question 3: the first complete record of plastic, the water board, the plastic seen in the lower river, what Noor learned (paragraphs 5–7).
- 5
Add one development note per answer. 'Well-sustained development' is the Level 5 descriptor and ideas 'rarely developed' sit at Level 3. A note such as 'the routine was harder than any single drama' tells you to explain what the details mean, not just add more details.
Model plan (top level)
167 words
Speaker: Noor, 17, the narrator. Listener: radio audience who know nothing about the trip. Spoken, warm, honest, never chatty for the sake of it. Layout: Presenter: question as set / Noor: answer. Three exchanges. No welcome speech; first words are my answer to Q1.
Q1 Daily challenges: shallow, stony upper river, dragging boats (2); blisters, taped palms (2); sample at nine every morning whatever the weather (2); storm under the bridge (3); carrying kayaks round the gorge, crying out of sight (3). Develop: the routine was harder than any single drama.
Q2 People's reactions: Varnow fishermen laugh, then bread rolls and hand-drawn map (4); Lessa children fight over the net (4); Orbin woman silent (4); nobody at Port Alder (6). Develop: first reactions are not the last; silence hurt more than laughter.
Q3 Achievement: first complete record of plastic, water board wants it (7); plastic visible lower down (5); what I learned about keeping going (2, 3). Develop: a judgement, not a list. Worth it, not fun (7).
How it is marked
What this plan protects. Each question has its own section with details drawn from across Text C and a development note, which is the shape of a Table F, Level 5 answer: all three questions well covered with well-sustained development. The voice and listener are decided first, so Noor will speak to people who have not read the text, which feeds Table G (fitness for audience and purpose). The layout decision keeps words for the answers rather than for an invented introduction. The third note asks for a judgement, which is what the word 'achieved' requires.
Weak plan (for comparison)
55 words
Intro: Presenter welcomes everyone to Riverside Live and introduces Noor and her uncle. Part 1: The Tavan is 900 km, Dr Okonjo, forty bottles, don't be heroic. Part 2: blisters, storm, gorge, fishermen, bread rolls, children in Lessa. Part 3: Port Alder, the hug, the paddle fell in. Ending: Presenter says thank you and goodbye.
How it is marked
What this plan risks. It follows the order of the text instead of the three questions, so the challenges and the reactions are mixed together in Part 2, and question 3 (what the expedition achieved) has no section at all. That points towards Table F, Level 2–3, where coverage of the questions is limited or uneven. Nothing is planned for Noor's feelings, which question 2 asks for directly. The invented welcome and farewell use words that earn nothing, and there are no development notes, so the answers are likely to retell rather than explain.
What earns the marks
- Speaker and listener fixed first: Noor, the narrator, talking to a radio audience in a natural but controlled spoken voice.
- Layout: each set question copied once and labelled, each answer labelled with the speaker's name; no invented questions, no long introduction.
- One section per question: daily challenges (recall), reactions and her feelings about them (feeling), what was achieved (judgement), each with details from across Text C.
- One development note per question, so that every detail is explained rather than listed.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: the interview format can trick candidates into writing a script of a whole radio show, with a welcome, a long introduction of the guest and a goodbye. None of it is credited. The questions are given to you; your marks are in the three answers, so spend your planning time sorting details under them.