Paper 1 Q4 interview: copy the three questions exactly and plan one answer for each
Question 4
Imagine you are Elif. A month after the show, you are interviewed on Brackenbury Breakfast, a local radio programme. The presenter asks you these three questions:
- How did you prepare for the competition?
- How did you feel on the day of the show?
- What do you think you have gained from entering?
Write the words of the interview.
Base your interview on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three questions.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (planning stage, not a full exam answer). You have about four minutes to plan. Write only your plan: who is speaking, who is listening, how you will set out the page, two to four details from Text C for each question, and one note per question on how you will develop the answer. A plan earns no marks on its own; the commentary shows which parts of Table F and Table G a plan like this protects.
Insert · Text C
A Baker's Loaf
In this account, fifteen-year-old Elif Kaya describes entering the baking competition at her village show.
1 Every August, the village of Brackenbury holds a show on the cricket field: sheepdogs, giant marrows, a brass band, and a white tent full of cakes and bread with numbered cards beside them. For three years I had walked round that tent with my mum, reading the judges' comments and thinking I could do better. This year, at fifteen, I finally filled in the form for the under-sixteens' baking class. The task was printed on the schedule: 'A plaited loaf, made by the entrant alone, to be delivered by 9 a.m.'
2 I had baked plenty of cakes, but I had never made bread. My grandad, who ran a bakery for thirty years before he retired, laughed when I told him, then cleared the kitchen table and showed me how to knead: push away with the heel of the hand, fold, turn, again and again, for ten whole minutes. My first loaf came out of the oven as flat and hard as a roof tile. My second rose so much that the plait split down the middle. By the end of July I had made eleven loaves, and my family had eaten most of them, even the bad ones, without complaining. Well, my brother complained.
3 The real problem was time. Bread needs to rise twice, and the dough would not hurry however much I glared at it. To have a loaf ready by nine, I worked out that I would have to start at half past four in the morning. Grandad was not allowed to help, but he set his alarm anyway and sat in the corner of the kitchen with a cup of tea, saying nothing, which was somehow helpful.
4 On show day it was raining. I carried the loaf across the field in a cake tin wrapped in a bin bag, walking very slowly, as if it were a sleeping baby. When I put it on the table in the tent, I saw the others: nine plaited loaves, some glossy and golden, one with seeds in a pattern I had never even thought of. Mine suddenly looked small and pale. A boy next to me said his mum had a bread machine at home. I said nothing and went to stand outside in the rain.
5 The judge was a tall woman called Mrs Ferrante, who had been judging the show for twenty years. We were not allowed in the tent while she worked, so I watched through a gap in the canvas as she cut a slice from each loaf, held it up to the light and pressed it with her thumb. She spent longer on mine than on anyone else's. I could not decide whether that was good or bad.
6 At two o'clock the tent reopened. There was a red card beside my loaf: first prize. Underneath, Mrs Ferrante had written: 'Even bake, open crumb, plait held its shape. A baker's loaf.' I read it four times. Then I went to find Grandad, who was standing by the sheepdogs pretending he had not been waiting, and I showed him the card. He read it, folded it carefully and put it in his top pocket, as if it belonged to him. In a way it did.
7 The prize was a wooden spoon, a certificate and five pounds. The village shop has asked if I would bake two loaves for them every Saturday, and I am thinking about it. I still get up early sometimes, just to make bread before anyone is awake. The kitchen is very quiet at that time, and the dough does what it likes.
- 1
Read the task before you read Text C closely. Three things are fixed for you. Who am I? Elif, the person telling the story, so her experiences and feelings are yours and you write 'I'. Who is listening? A local radio audience who have not read Text C, so each detail must make sense when heard. When is it? A month after the show, so you look back: the show is in the past, but what you think now is in the present.
- 2
Copy the three questions exactly as they are given. Write each one once, labelled 'Presenter:', word for word, and label each answer 'Elif:'. Do not reword a question, join two together, add a question of your own or write a welcome and a goodbye. Rewording is risky: if 'How did you feel on the day of the show?' becomes 'Tell us about the show', you will probably retell events instead of giving feelings. The questions themselves earn no marks; your answers earn all twenty.
- 3
Name the job of each question. Question 1 is recall: what you did before the show to get ready. Question 2 is feeling: how you felt on the day, not just what happened. Question 3 is judgement: what you think you gained, with reasons. Write R, F and J beside them. Table F's top level needs all three questions well covered, so no question may be left thin.
- 4
Sort the details under the questions, not in story order. Use paragraph numbers so you can find them again. Question 1: paragraphs 2–3 (never made bread, Grandad teaching her to knead, the failed loaves, eleven loaves, the half-past-four start). Question 2: paragraphs 4–6 (the rain, the slow walk with the tin, the other loaves, standing outside, watching the judge, the red card). Question 3: paragraphs 6–7 (the judge's comment, the prize, the shop's offer, early-morning baking, Grandad's pocket). Paragraph 1 is mostly background: use one phrase of it at most.
- 5
Add one development note per answer. A development note says what the details show, which is the second sentence you will write after each detail. 'Well-sustained development' is what Table F's top level rewards; ideas that are 'rarely developed' sit lower. Examples: question 1, 'the bad loaves taught me most'; question 2, 'my feeling changed during the day'; question 3, 'confidence matters more than the prize'.
- 6
Set a word budget. About 250 to 300 words in total means roughly 85 to 95 words per answer. Write the budget beside each question. When an answer reaches it, finish that answer and move on, even if you have more to say.
Sound plan
180 words
Me: Elif, 15, the baker. Listening: local radio audience who have not read the text. Looking back a month later. Spoken, friendly, clear. Layout: Presenter: question copied exactly / Elif: answer. Three exchanges. No welcome, no goodbye.
Q1 Preparation (RECALL, about 90 words): never baked bread before (2); Grandad, a baker for thirty years, teaches kneading, ten minutes (2); flat loaf, split loaf, eleven by end of July (2); bread rises twice, so 4.30 a.m. start, Grandad there but not helping (3). Develop: the bad loaves taught me most.
Q2 Show day (FEELING, about 90 words): rain, carried tin slowly (4); other loaves looked better, mine small and pale, went outside (4); judge took longest on mine, could not tell if good or bad (5); red card, read comment four times (6). Develop: feeling changed: worried, then doubtful, then proud.
Q3 Gained (JUDGEMENT, about 90 words): judge called it a baker's loaf (6); shop wants loaves every Saturday (7); love quiet early baking (7); Grandad put card in his pocket (6). Develop: confidence matters more than the spoon and five pounds.
How it is marked
What this plan protects. Each question has its own section, a label saying what kind of answer it needs, details from the right paragraphs and a development note. That is the shape of a strong Table F answer: all three questions covered, with something to say about each detail. Deciding the listener and the voice first feeds Table G, which rewards writing that fits its audience and purpose. The questions are copied exactly, so the answers stay on what was asked, and the word budget stops question 1 from swallowing the time needed for question 3.
Weak plan (for comparison)
59 words
Start: Presenter says hello and welcome to Brackenbury Breakfast and asks Elif to tell us all about the show. Then: show every August, sheepdogs, marrows, brass band. Elif enters baking. Grandad teaches her. Show day, rain, nine other loaves. Judge Mrs Ferrante. Wins first prize. Extra question: What is your favourite cake? End: Presenter says thank you and goodbye.
How it is marked
What this plan risks. It replaces the three set questions with one invented question ('tell us all about the show') and adds another ('favourite cake') that Text C cannot answer. The details follow the story from start to finish, so the interview will retell events instead of answering. Nothing is planned for feelings (question 2) or for what Elif gained (question 3), and there are no development notes. An interview written from this plan would be likely to sit around Table F, Level 2, where focus on the questions is limited, and the welcome and goodbye would use words that earn nothing.
What earns the marks
- Speaker, listener and time fixed first: Elif, the narrator, speaking to a local radio audience a month after the show.
- The three questions copied once, word for word, each labelled 'Presenter:'; each answer labelled 'Elif:'; no invented questions, no welcome or goodbye.
- One section per question, with its job named: preparation (recall), feelings on the day (feeling), what she gained (judgement), each with details and paragraph numbers.
- One development note per answer and a budget of about 85 to 95 words each.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: the three questions are part of the task, not a suggestion. Candidates who reword them, merge them or add their own often end up answering something that was never asked. Copy each question exactly, then spend your four planning minutes sorting details under them, not following the story from the first paragraph to the last.