Paper 1 Q4 report: a headline and a five-Ws lead drawn from Text C
Question 4
You are a reporter for the Harrow Bay Gazette, and you spoke to people on the beach that afternoon. Write a news report about the rescue for the newspaper.
In your report you should:
- describe what happened on the sandbar and how the family was rescued
- explain how the people involved felt during and after the rescue
- consider what lessons the town should learn from the afternoon.
Base your report on what you have read in Text C, but be careful to use your own words. Address each of the three bullet points.
Write about 250 to 300 words.
Up to 10 marks are available for the content of your answer and up to 10 marks for the quality of your writing. [20]
Practice task (opening only, not a full exam answer). Write the headline and the first paragraph of your report, in no more than 60 words in total, counting the headline. An opening cannot be marked out of 20 on its own, so the commentary judges which level writing of this standard would support within a complete report.
Insert · Text C
The Sandbar
In this account, Jaya Mistry, a seventeen-year-old trainee lifeguard, describes an afternoon at Harrow Sands.
1 It was the last Sunday of the summer holidays, and Harrow Sands was as full as I had ever seen it. I was in my third week as a trainee with the volunteer lifeguard club, which meant I was allowed to sit in the high chair beside Dougie Marr, who has watched that beach for twenty-six summers, and do exactly what he told me. Mostly what he told me was to look at the water, not the people.
2 At about twenty past three I noticed that the long ridge of sand off the north end of the beach, the one children like to walk out to at low tide, had gone strangely quiet. Five figures were standing on it: two adults and three children, one small enough to be carried. Between them and the beach, the channel that had been ankle-deep at lunchtime was now a sheet of brown water moving sideways, fast. The tide at Harrow turns early, and when it comes, it comes round the back of the bar first. There is a sign about this in the car park. It has faded to the colour of weak tea.
3 I said, 'Dougie,' and he looked once and was on the radio before I had finished pointing. He told me to keep my eyes on the family and not to take them off for anything, so I did. I remember the father trying to wade back with the smallest child on his shoulders, getting waist-deep and turning round. I remember thinking how small they looked, and that the water did not look dangerous at all, which is exactly what makes it dangerous.
4 Dougie went out on the rescue board. He told me afterwards that the current in the channel was stronger than anything he had felt there in years. He reached the bar in under four minutes, by which time the water was over the adults' knees. He did not try to bring anyone back. He kept them together, held the youngest, and waited.
5 The inshore lifeboat from Penhallow arrived nine minutes after the call. I know because I wrote the times on the back of my hand, which Dougie had made me practise. The crew, all volunteers, lifted the family off one by one. The youngest, a girl of three called Bea, was crying because she had dropped her bucket. The crew went back for it. I do not think I will ever forget the sight of a grown man in a dry suit holding up a pink bucket to a cheering beach.
6 Back on the sand, the mother, Mrs Okafor, could not stop shaking. She told me they were visiting from Birmingham and had seen nothing to warn them. 'Everyone was walking out there,' she kept saying. 'Everyone.' She was right. In the hour before, I had watched perhaps forty people walk out to that bar and back.
7 Later, when the beach had emptied, Dougie sat on the step of the hut and ate a sandwich very slowly. He said that the club has twelve volunteers and that on a day like that it needs twenty. He said the council had promised new signs two summers ago. Then he said I had done well, and that the most important thing a lifeguard does is notice. I went home and slept for eleven hours.
- 1
Find the five Ws, which a first-person account scatters. Text C is told in the order Jaya lived it, so the facts a reporter needs are spread across the passage.
W Where it is in Text C What the reporter writes Who paras 2, 5, 6 a family of five from Birmingham, including a three-year-old; volunteer lifeguards; the Penhallow lifeboat crew What paras 2–5 cut off by the incoming tide on a sandbar and lifted off by lifeboat Where para 2 a sandbar off the north end of Harrow Sands When paras 1–2 Sunday afternoon, about 3.20pm Why para 2 the tide comes round the back of the bar first and filled the channel behind them - 2
Decide whose story it is. In Text C the narrator is the centre of the story. In a news report she becomes a source. The most newsworthy 'who' is the family, and especially the three-year-old, so the lead opens with them, not with 'On Sunday' and not with the lifeguard's feelings.
- 3
Write a headline that tells the news. Present tense, an active verb, the key facts and no full stop: who, what and where in under twelve words. A pun or a label ('Beach Drama') tells the reader nothing. On Paper 1 the headline earns no marks by itself, so spend a few seconds on it, not minutes; its value is that it sets the register of a newspaper at once, which helps Table G.
- 4
Compress the 'why' in the lead and save the rest. 'After the incoming tide cut them off' is enough for paragraph one. The deeper reasons (the tide turning early, the faded sign, the shortage of volunteers) belong lower down, where they answer the third bullet about lessons for the town.
- 5
Re-express, in the third person and past tense. 'A sheet of brown water moving sideways' is Jaya's phrasing; copying it borrows her voice and counts as lifting, which Table F notes at Level 2. Report it plainly: the channel had filled with a fast current.
Model opening (top level)
46 words
Family rescued from Harrow sandbar as tide cuts them off
A family of five, including a three-year-old girl, were lifted to safety by a volunteer lifeboat crew on Sunday afternoon after the incoming tide trapped them on a sandbar off the north end of Harrow Sands.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full report: an opening of this standard would support Table F, Level 5 and Table G, Level 5. All five Ws are in one sentence, and the most important fact (a young child rescued) comes first. Every detail is re-expressed: 'trapped', 'lifted to safety' and 'incoming tide' are the reporter's words, not Jaya's. The headline is short, factual and active, and the third-person past-tense register is fixed from the first line, which is the fitness for audience and purpose that Table G rewards.
Weak opening (for comparison)
42 words
SANDBAR DRAMA!!!
It was the last Sunday of the summer holidays and Harrow Sands was as full as I had ever seen it. I was sitting in the high chair with Dougie when I noticed that the sandbar had gone strangely quiet.
How it is marked
Marked as part of a full report: this opening points towards Table F, Level 2 and Table G, Level 2. It is in Jaya's first-person voice, not a reporter's, so the voice is inappropriate for the task, and most of it is lifted from paragraphs 1 and 2. After forty words the reader still does not know what happened, to whom, or why it matters. The headline is a label, and the capitals and exclamation marks belong to a poster, not a newspaper.
What earns the marks
- Headline: present tense, active verb, the key facts, no full stop (for example, 'Family rescued from Harrow sandbar as tide cuts them off').
- Lead: one sentence answering who (a family of five, with a three-year-old), what (rescued by lifeboat), where (sandbar off the north end of Harrow Sands), when (Sunday afternoon) and why (cut off by the incoming tide).
- Third person, past tense, the family first and the narrator demoted to a source; no lifted phrases.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: when Text C is a first-person story and the task makes you a reporter, the commonest mistake is to keep the narrator's 'I'. Before you write, underline the five Ws in the passage and decide whose story the news is. The narrator usually becomes a named source with an age and a role ('trainee lifeguard Jaya Mistry, 17'), quoted further down the report.