1(a): evaluate a stallholder's attitude to a council plan
Read Text A and Text B in the insert and then answer Section A, Question 1(a) and 1(b).
(a) Reread this extract from Text B:
Use your own words to evaluate Rosa's attitude to the council's plan. Give details from the text to justify your answer.
Insert · Extract from Text B
Stallholders Count the Cost
The question paper reprints this extract. Text A and the whole of Text B are printed with the next example, which uses the same insert.
'I've cooked on this pavement through three floods and one fire, and I've never once asked the council for anything,' says Rosa. 'Now they tell me a building will make my food "safe", as if my customers have been risking their lives for twenty-two years. They picked a meeting time when every one of us was at the wholesale market – I don't believe that was an accident. I'm not against clean water; I'd welcome it. But my corner is my business. People find me by the smoke. Put me in unit forty-seven behind a glass door, and my regulars will walk straight past.'
- 1
Decode the question. Evaluate means judge, so you are not retelling what Rosa says; you are deciding what she thinks and feels about the plan, and how strongly. Use your own words applies to your judgements (proud, resentful, suspicious); the short quotations are only there as proof. Five marks and about six lines: spend no more than eight to ten minutes, because the 35-mark 1(b) is waiting.
- 2
Annotate for attitudes, not events. Label each detail with an adjective:
- 'three floods and one fire', 'never once asked the council for anything': proud, self-reliant
- 'safe' in inverted commas, 'as if my customers have been risking their lives': insulted, resentful of being talked down to
- 'I don't believe that was an accident': distrustful of the council
- 'I'm not against clean water; I'd welcome it': reasonable, open to some improvement
- 'my regulars will walk straight past': anxious about her livelihood
- 3
Look at how she says it (R4). The inverted commas around 'safe' and the sarcastic 'as if…' show mockery, not just disagreement. 'My corner' against the council's 'unit forty-seven' contrasts a personal, named place with an anonymous number. A comment like this on wording is what helps an answer secure Level 3.
- 4
Make an overall judgement. Rosa is not simply against change: she objects to how the change is being done to her and fears what she will lose. Saying this ('Yet she is not simply stubborn…') shows you are weighing her attitude, which is what evaluate asks for.
- 5
Write it tightly. One sentence per attitude: judgement in your own words, then a two-to-five-word quotation, then a brief comment where it helps. No introduction and no conclusion are needed.
Model answer (top level)
107 words
Rosa is fiercely proud of her independence: she has kept cooking through 'three floods and one fire' without ever asking for help, so she treats the plan as an insult to her resilience. She resents being talked down to; putting 'safe' in inverted commas and the sarcastic 'as if my customers have been risking their lives' mock the idea that her food is dangerous. She distrusts the council, suspecting the meeting time was chosen deliberately. Yet she is not simply stubborn, since she would 'welcome' clean water. Above all she is anxious about her living, fearing that as an anonymous 'unit forty-seven' she will lose her 'regulars'.
How it is marked
Table A, Level 3: 5 marks. Clear understanding of Rosa's attitude with relevant support. Five distinct attitudes are named in the candidate's own words (proud and independent, resentful, distrustful, reasonable, anxious), and each is tied to a short, precise detail. The answer also shows how the wording creates the attitude (R4): the inverted commas and the sarcasm, and the anonymous 'unit forty-seven'. The phrase 'not simply stubborn' is genuine evaluation, weighing her attitude rather than listing it.
Mid-level answer (for comparison)
76 words
Rosa does not like the council's plan. She has cooked on the pavement through three floods and one fire and she has never asked the council for anything. She thinks the council picked a meeting time when all the stallholders were at the wholesale market. She says she is not against clean water. She thinks her regulars will walk straight past if she is put in unit forty-seven behind a glass door, so she is worried.
How it is marked
Table A, Level 2: 2 marks. Some understanding with some supporting detail. Only two attitudes are actually named ('does not like', 'worried'); the rest retells the extract in its own order, with the details copied as if they were explanations. The answer never says what the floods show about her (pride), misses the sarcasm of 'as if…' entirely, and does not notice that welcoming clean water makes her more reasonable than 'does not like the plan' suggests. To lift it: start each sentence with an attitude word, quote only a few words as proof, and add one comment on how her language shows her feeling.
What earns the marks
- Several different attitudes named in your own words: proud, resentful, distrustful, reasonable, anxious.
- Each judgement backed by a short detail from the extract, not a copied sentence.
- At least one comment on how her wording reveals the attitude (the sarcastic 'as if…', 'safe' in inverted commas).
- An overall evaluation (she accepts improvement but resents how the change is imposed), in about six lines.
Examiner tip
The commonest trap is retelling: working through the extract sentence by sentence and changing 'I' to 'she'. That shows you have read it, not that you have judged it. There is no examiner report for 1(a) yet, but the specimen mark scheme rewards attitude labels (such as 'competitive' or 'feels unfairly treated'), each followed by a short detail, so build your answer that way. If you sit in November 2026 (old syllabus): there is no separate 1(a); judging the writers' attitudes is part of your single 40-mark Question 1.