PEEL in miniature: why this word rather than that one
Read Text A, The return of the sleeper, in the insert and then answer the question below.
1(f)(i) Explain why the writer uses the word 'resurrected' rather than 'restarted' in paragraph 2. [2]
Insert · Text A
The return of the sleeper
In this article from a travel magazine, the writer explains why overnight sleeper trains are coming back into use across Europe.
1 For most of the last century, the overnight sleeper train was a European institution. Passengers boarded in one capital after dinner, folded themselves into narrow bunks, and woke to coffee and a different language on the platform. Then, from the 1990s onwards, the network quietly withered. Budget airlines could carry the same traveller in ninety minutes for the price of a sandwich, and one by one the night routes were cut, their carriages shunted into sidings to rust.
2 Today the sleeper is being resurrected. Over the past decade, operators have relaunched more than twenty overnight routes, and several now sell out weeks in advance. The reasons are partly environmental: a berth on a night train produces a fraction of the carbon of the same journey by air. But passengers also mention something harder to measure. 'You lose nothing,' says Lotte Varga, who travels from Vienna to the coast twice a year. 'You go to sleep, and the journey simply happens to you.'
3 Running a sleeper is not easy. A sleeping carriage carries perhaps thirty people where a daytime carriage carries eighty, so tickets cost more. Trains must cross borders at three in the morning, and every country has its own signalling, its own drivers and its own rules about who pays for the track. One operator compares planning a new route to 'conducting an orchestra in which every musician has brought different sheet music'.
4 Still, demand keeps rising. Engineers are designing carriages with small private pods, and several governments have begun to pay part of the cost of the track. Perhaps the night train was never really dead. It was simply waiting for travellers to remember that a journey can be part of the holiday rather than an obstacle to it.
- 1
Read the tariff as the shape of the answer. Two marks: one for what the chosen word means here, one for what it adds that the alternative would lose. That is PEEL shrunk to two sentences. The Evidence is already given in the question, so you do not need to quote again at length; the Point and the Explanation carry the marks (R2, R4).
- 2
Point: the meaning in context. 'Resurrected' means brought back to life after being dead, not simply started again after a pause. Say this in your own words. (1)
- 3
Evidence from the context, not just the word. Paragraph 1 has prepared for the word: the network 'withered', and the carriages were left 'to rust'. Those details describe something dying, which is why 'resurrected' fits.
- 4
Explanation and Link: what the choice adds over the alternative. 'Restarted' sounds routine, like switching a machine back on. 'Resurrected' makes the comeback seem almost miraculous, which stresses how complete the decline had been and how remarkable the revival is. (1) The comparison in the question is your hint: always say what the plainer word would have lost.
Full-mark answer (2 out of 2)
50 words
'Resurrected' means brought back to life after being dead, rather than simply started again after a break. Because paragraph 1 describes the network withering and the carriages rusting, the word makes the trains' return seem almost miraculous, stressing how surprising the comeback is, whereas 'restarted' would make it sound ordinary.
How it is marked
2 marks. The first sentence gives the meaning in context, in the candidate's own words (1). The second explains the effect and anchors it in the earlier details, then names what 'restarted' would lose (1). Point, Evidence, Explanation and Link are all present in two sentences.
Weaker answer (0 out of 2)
25 words
The writer uses 'resurrected' because it is a more powerful word than 'restarted' and it makes the reader interested. It shows the trains are back.
How it is marked
0 marks. 'More powerful' and 'makes the reader interested' could be said of almost any word, so they explain nothing. 'The trains are back' is true of 'restarted' as well: the answer never mentions the idea of life after death, which is the whole difference between the two words.
What earns the marks
- Meaning (1): brought back to life / revived after being dead or gone completely (not just begun again after a pause).
- Effect (1): makes the return seem dramatic or almost miraculous after the decline described in paragraph 1 ('withered', 'rust'); stresses how unlikely or remarkable the comeback is, whereas 'restarted' sounds routine.
Total: 2 marks.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: on a 'why X rather than Y' item, write one sentence for meaning and one for effect, and make the second sentence mention the other word. Phrases such as 'more powerful', 'more effective' or 'makes the reader want to read on' never earn the effect mark on their own, because they do not say what the word does.