Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/42 October/November 2025 (Paper 4 Law of Tort): Question-by-Question Guide
Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/42 is the October/November 2025 Paper 4 (Law of Tort), variant 2. It is an A Level component that lasts 1 hour 30 minutes and is worth 75 marks. You answer three questions: one of two problem questions in Section A and two of three essays in Section B, each worth 25 marks. Every question uses the same 12/5/8 split across knowledge, analysis and evaluation. This guide goes through the paper question by question and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.
For the newest series of the same paper, see 9084 Paper 42 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.
For an overview of all four 9084 papers from this series, see A Level Law 9084 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes.
9084/42 at a glance
Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9084/42/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9084_w25_qp_42 and the mark scheme file is 9084_w25_ms_42.
Rubric: answer one question from Section A and two questions from Section B, three questions in total.
| Question | Section | Type | Topic | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A (either) | Problem | Amy threatens and pushes a store security guard, then is held in a staff room: assault, battery and false imprisonment | 25 |
| 2 | A (or) | Problem | Matt’s guests use a balcony overlooking Sally’s garden; Sally hammers on the walls at night: private nuisance | 25 |
| 3 | B (choose two) | Essay | Evaluate the calculation of damages for personal injuries caused by negligence | 25 |
| 4 | B (choose two) | Essay | Is volenti non fit injuria no longer essential, given other ways to apportion blame? | 25 |
| 5 | B (choose two) | Essay | Is the special relationship in negligent misstatement defined precisely enough to avoid injustice? | 25 |
| Total answered (one from Section A + two from Section B) | 75 |
Question-by-question walkthrough
How every question is marked
Each assessment objective is marked separately on its own grid, and the three marks are added:
- AO1 Knowledge and understanding, out of 12. Level 4 (10–12) is accurate and detailed in most relevant areas, with thorough knowledge of the most appropriate rules, key cases or statutes and legal terminology. Level 3 (7–9) is mostly accurate but thin in places, Level 2 (4–6) has some accuracy but lacks detail, and Level 1 (1–3) is limited.
- AO2 Analysis and application, out of 5. The top level (4–5) needs mostly focused, reasoned application (problems) or analysis (essays) throughout, supported by well-developed use of rules and cases; 2–3 is some reasoned application or analysis; 1 is limited.
- AO3 Evaluation, out of 8. The top level (6–8) needs mostly focused, reasoned evaluation of all the relevant issues, effectively supported by relevant material, with a coherent argument; 3–5 is some evaluation, reasoned at times; 1–2 is limited.
This mark scheme lists the issues to cover rather than specific cases, and credits all valid responses. The AO1 descriptors still reward key cases and legal terminology, so support each element with the authorities you have learned.
Section A: the problem questions
Question 1: Amy, Will and Daniel (25 marks)
Amy refused to tell Will, a security guard, whether she had paid for the items in her bag and shouted that she would hit him if he asked again. When he asked again, she pushed past him, and he fell and broke his wrist. Daniel, the manager, stood in front of her, told her the police were coming and told her to wait in the staff room. After an hour she found the door unlocked and left.
The mark scheme splits the answer into two parts:
- Trespass to the person (Amy and Will). AO1: identify trespass to the person; explain assault (apprehension of the infliction of immediate and unlawful force), the particular rules on assault by words, battery (the intentional application of force), the requirement that the interference is direct, and any relevant defences. AO2 and AO3: analyse whether Amy’s words are an assault, whether pushing past Will is a battery, any defences and the possible remedies.
- False imprisonment (Amy and Daniel). AO1: identify false imprisonment, explain its requirements (direct, intentional, total restraint) and the rules on lawful restraint or justification. AO2 and AO3: analyse whether Daniel falsely imprisoned Amy, whether there was total restraint and whether there was a lawful justification.
Key facts to use: Amy’s threat was conditional (“if he asks her again”), Will did ask again, the injury followed directly from her push, and the staff room door was not locked for the hour she waited. Each of these is a point the analysis turns on, so make a decision on each.
Question 2: Matt, Sally and Tony (25 marks)
Matt rents his house to short-term guests and built a large balcony, with outdoor cooking and a heater, overlooking his neighbour Sally’s garden. Sally complained about being overlooked, constant use, noise and cooking smells; Matt replied that paying guests could do what they wanted. Later, a guest, Tony, could not sleep all weekend because of constant hammering on the walls at night, and Sally told Matt she could do what she wanted in her house.
- Private nuisance (Sally against Matt). AO1: identify private nuisance; explain its elements (an indirect interference which is unreasonable and results in damage); who can sue and be sued; the factors for unreasonableness (locality, duration, sensitivity and malice); defences; and remedies. AO2 and AO3: analyse whether Matt can be sued, whether guests looking into the garden is an unreasonable interference, whether the smell and noise are, any defences and the appropriate remedies.
- Private nuisance (Matt or Tony against Sally). AO1: identify nuisance in Sally’s actions, explain malice, defences and the possible remedy. AO2 and AO3: analyse whether the hammering is an unreasonable interference, whether Matt or Tony can sue Sally, any defences and the remedy.
Two claims run in opposite directions, and the mark scheme expects both, plus the question of who has standing to sue: Matt as owner, or Tony as a short-term guest.
Section B: the essays (choose two)
Question 3: the calculation of damages for personal injury (25 marks)
- AO1: the purpose of damages in negligence; the types of compensatory damages, pecuniary and non-pecuniary; the general rule that damages are a lump sum; and the rules on fatal accidents.
- AO2 and AO3: the policy issues, such as the availability of insurance; the difficulties in calculating the quantum of damages for personal injury; the problems with a lump sum; issues with loss of amenity and pain and suffering; and any proposals for reform.
- Watch out: a brief outline of the elements of negligence may earn some credit, but a detailed account of duty of care is not required and is not credited.
Question 4: is volenti non fit injuria still essential? (25 marks)
- AO1: the elements of volenti (it must be voluntary, an agreement, with full knowledge and understanding of the nature and extent of the risk); the effect of a successful defence; its use in settings such as medical treatment and sport; and how contributory negligence works as a partial defence.
- AO2 and AO3: how far contributory negligence can be used instead of volenti; how far contributory negligence can operate as a full defence; and how far volenti is still needed in torts where contributory negligence is not available. That last point is your strongest argument against the statement.
Question 5: the special relationship in negligent misstatement (25 marks)
- AO1: the key elements of the duty of care for negligent misstatement (special relationship, voluntary assumption of responsibility and reliance); what a special relationship means, through examples and case law; and how the duty applies to social relationships.
- AO2 and AO3: how the definition of a special relationship has developed; the issues with social relationships; the role of policy, such as floodgates and the overlap with contract; and whether the current rules are imprecise enough to cause unjust outcomes.
Where the marks are on 9084/42
By assessment objective, across the three questions you answer:
| Assessment objective | Per question | Across three questions |
|---|---|---|
| AO1 Knowledge and understanding | 12 | 36 |
| AO2 Analysis and application | 5 | 15 |
| AO3 Evaluation | 8 | 24 |
| Total | 25 | 75 |
- Knowledge is almost half the paper. 36 of the 75 marks are AO1, so define each tort and defence precisely: the elements of assault, battery, false imprisonment and private nuisance are the knowledge marks in Section A.
- Evaluation outweighs analysis. AO3 is worth 8 per question against 5 for AO2. In the problems, that means a reasoned conclusion on liability and remedy for each party; in the essays, a judgement on the statement.
- Both problems have more than one claim. Question 1 has three torts and Question 2 has two nuisance claims in opposite directions. Covering only one limits every AO.
How to self-mark 9084/42 with the mark scheme
- List the issues you covered against the mark scheme’s bullet points. In Question 1, that is assault, battery, defences, remedies, false imprisonment, total restraint and lawful justification.
- Give AO1 a mark out of 12. Accurate, detailed coverage of most issues with correct terminology and supporting cases is Level 4 (10–12). Missing a whole claim holds you lower.
- Give AO2 a mark out of 5. Check each element is tied to a fact: the conditional threat, the broken wrist, the unlocked door, the locality and duration of the balcony use.
- Give AO3 a mark out of 8. In a problem, check for a conclusion on each claim and a remedy. In an essay, check you weighed both sides and answered the statement.
- Strike out off-question material before you level it, such as a detailed duty of care section in Question 3.
Sit 9084/42 as a timed mock
You have 90 minutes for three 25-mark answers, about 26 minutes each with time to plan and check.
| Block | Marks | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Read the paper, choose and plan your three questions | – | 6 minutes |
| Section A problem | 25 | 26 minutes |
| First Section B essay | 25 | 26 minutes |
| Second Section B essay | 25 | 26 minutes |
| Check conclusions and remedies | – | 6 minutes |
Plan the problem by party pairs (Amy and Will, Amy and Daniel; Sally against Matt, Matt or Tony against Sally), with one line each for the tort, the key fact and the likely outcome.
9084/42 in other series
May/June 2026 kept the same shape and the same 12/5/8 grid, and its mark scheme also listed issues rather than cases. Volenti non fit injuria was the Question 4 essay in both series (whether it is still essential here, whether it should fail against employees in 2026), and damages came up in both (personal injury damages here, non-pecuniary damages in 2026). Trespass to the person was a problem question here and an essay on intention in 2026.
Other October/November 2025 9084 papers
Practise and download
- Download 9084/42 and its mark scheme on the Learning Portal →
- All 9084 October/November 2025 papers: overview and marking patterns
- All 9084 May/June 2026 papers: overview and marking patterns
- Try a free A Level Law quiz
Need help with a 9084 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Law tutor →
Frequently asked questions
What came up on 9084 Paper 42 October/November 2025? +
Section A offered a trespass to the person problem (Amy, a security guard and a store manager) and a private nuisance problem (Matt's balcony and holiday guests, and Sally's hammering). Section B essays covered damages for personal injury, whether volenti non fit injuria is still essential, and the special relationship in negligent misstatement.
How many marks is 9084/42 and how many questions do you answer? +
It is out of 75 marks and lasts 1 hour 30 minutes. You answer one of the two Section A problem questions and two of the three Section B essays, each worth 25 marks.
Which torts did the 9084/42 mark scheme expect in Question 1? +
Assault (Amy's threat to hit Will), battery (pushing past Will so he fell and broke his wrist) and false imprisonment (Daniel keeping Amy in an unlocked staff room for an hour), with defences, lawful justification and remedies.
How is each 9084/42 question marked? +
Every question is 25 marks: AO1 knowledge out of 12, AO2 analysis and application out of 5 and AO3 evaluation out of 8, each on its own level grid. The top AO3 level, 6 to 8, needs mostly focused, reasoned evaluation of all the relevant issues and a coherent argument.
Should you describe the elements of negligence in 9084/42 Question 3? +
Only briefly. The mark scheme said some credit may be given for an outline of the elements of negligence, but a detailed account of elements such as duty of care is not required and should not be credited. The question is about how damages are calculated.
Where can I download 9084/42 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +
Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 past papers page.
What is 9084_w25_qp_42? +
9084_w25_qp_42 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 Paper 42 (Paper 4 Law of Tort, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9084_w25_ms_42, and the code printed on the cover is 9084/42/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.
Ready to Excel in Your Studies?
Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.
Book Your Free TrialWritten by
Mahira Kitchil
Connect on LinkedIn →Project Head, Tutopiya
Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.
Related Articles
A Level Biology 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes
Free 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Paper 1 and Paper 3 with mark schemes: the topics tested, the practical tasks and how examiners awarded marks on each.
A Level Computer Science 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Marking
Free 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 papers and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of Papers 1 to 4 and how examiners gave marks for code and theory.
A Level Geography 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme
Free 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 papers, inserts and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of the data questions, options and essays and how they were levelled.
