Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/22 October/November 2025 (Paper 2 Criminal Law): Question-by-Question Guide
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/22 October/November 2025 (Paper 2 Criminal Law): Question-by-Question Guide

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 10 min read
Updated

Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/22 is the October/November 2025 Paper 2 (Criminal Law), variant 2. It is an AS Level component that lasts 1 hour 30 minutes, is worth 60 marks and is sat by every 9084 candidate. You answer two questions: the compulsory 30-mark source-based Question 1 on the Fraud Act 2006, and one of two 30-mark Section B questions. The biggest single part is the 25-mark Section B evaluation essay, marked separately for knowledge, analysis and evaluation. This guide goes through the paper question by question and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

For the newest series of the same paper, see 9084 Paper 22 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.

For an overview of all four 9084 papers from this series, see A Level Law 9084 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes.

9084/22 at a glance

Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9084/22/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9084_w25_qp_22 and the mark scheme file is 9084_w25_ms_22.

Rubric: answer Question 1 in Section A, using only the source material, and one question from Section B, without the source material.

QuestionSectionTopicMarks
1(a)A (compulsory)Peter climbs through a fence to watch a tennis match without a ticket10
1(b)A (compulsory)Celeste underpays farm workers and spends the difference; Anton is her brother and co-owner10
1(c)A (compulsory)Helen, her mother’s carer, uses her mother’s card for a streaming subscription10
2(a)B (either)The aggravated offence under s1(2) Criminal Damage Act 19715
2(b)B (either)Evaluate the fairness of using causation to create criminal liability25
3(a)B (or)Two custodial sentences for young offenders5
3(b)B (or)Evaluate the effectiveness of the law of blackmail25
Total answered (Question 1 + Question 2 or 3)60

Question-by-question walkthrough

Section A, Question 1: Fraud Act 2006 (30 marks)

The source material gave two sections of the Fraud Act 2006:

  • s4, fraud by abuse of position: a person who occupies a position where they are expected to safeguard, or not act against, another’s financial interests, dishonestly abuses it, and intends to make a gain or cause a loss (or risk of loss). Under s4(2) the abuse can be an omission.
  • s11, obtaining services dishonestly: obtaining services by a dishonest act, where the services are made available on the basis that payment will be made, they are obtained without paying in full, and the person knows payment is required (or might be) but intends not to pay in full.

It also summarised three cases: R v Marshall (2009) (a care home manager took money from a resident’s account, guilty under s4), R v Kapitene (2010) (an illegal immigrant’s gain was the wages paid and the employer’s loss was the wages paid out) and R v Barton and Booth (2020) (dishonesty is judged by the Ivey v Genting Casinos test: would an ordinary, honest person with the defendant’s knowledge and beliefs see the conduct as dishonest?).

How each part is marked: every part is 10 marks, 2 for AO1 and 8 for AO2. AO1 is 2 marks for identifying and accurately citing most of the relevant law (1 mark for some of it). AO2 has three levels: 1–2 for basic application and a basic conclusion without reasoning, 3–5 for partially developed application with a conclusion that may not be entirely appropriate, and 6–8 for fully developed application and analysis leading to a developed, logical conclusion.

1(a) Peter (10 marks)

  • Law: s11 is the likely offence, with R v Barton and Booth for dishonesty.
  • Application: Peter commits a dishonest act by getting in through a hole in the fence, and he obtains a service because he watches the match without paying. An ordinary person would see climbing through the fence as dishonest (Barton and Booth). He also planned in advance how to avoid paying and lied to the security guard about his brother having the ticket. He knew tickets cost £100, and his lie shows he never intended to pay.
  • Conclusion: Peter is guilty under s11.

1(b) Anton and Celeste (10 marks)

  • Law: s4 is the likely offence, with Marshall, Kapitene and Barton and Booth.
  • Anton: as the employer he is expected to protect his workers’ financial interests under s4(1)(a), and he could be liable by omission, but he is not dishonest under s4(1)(b) and Barton and Booth. Anton is not guilty.
  • Celeste: running the farm’s accounts gives her a position where she must safeguard the money owed to the workers (Marshall). An ordinary person would see taking the money as dishonest (Barton and Booth). She gains a car and the workers each lose £2,000, the difference between the £5,000 agreed and the £3,000 paid (Kapitene). Celeste is guilty under s4.
  • Watch out: the mark scheme says that to reach maximum marks you must apply the law to both Anton and Celeste.

1(c) Helen (10 marks) The mark scheme accepted two routes, each with its own AO1 and AO2 content.

  • Route 1, s11: Helen creates a streaming account (the act) and obtains a service, the TV series. She pays the streaming service in full, but not her mother, who has been paid back only £15 of the £30. An ordinary person would see using her mother’s card without permission as dishonest (Barton and Booth). Helen is guilty under s11.
  • Route 2, s4: as her mother’s carer, Helen is expected to safeguard her mother’s finances (Marshall). She dishonestly abuses that position by using a card meant for her mother’s bills for her own subscription. She intends a gain for herself and causes her mother a loss, since she repays only £15 (Kapitene). This is a positive act rather than an omission under s4(2). Helen is guilty under s4.

Either route is credited. Pick one and apply every element of it to the facts.

Section B: choose Question 2 or Question 3 (30 marks)

Both questions have a 5-mark part (a) and a 25-mark part (b).

  • Part (a), 5 marks, AO1: one mark per point, up to 5.
  • Part (b), 25 marks: AO1 out of 10, AO2 out of 6, AO3 out of 9, each on its own level grid. The top levels need accurate, detailed knowledge of the most appropriate law with key cases and statutes (AO1, 9–10), mostly focused and reasoned analysis supported by well-developed use of cases (AO2, 5–6), and mostly focused, reasoned evaluation of most of the relevant issues with a coherent argument (AO3, 7–9).

Question 2: criminal damage and causation

  • 2(a) The aggravated offence under s1(2) Criminal Damage Act 1971 (5): the actus reus is destroying or damaging property, which can be another’s or the defendant’s own; it must be without lawful excuse; there must be intention or recklessness to endanger life, but there is no need to prove a life was actually endangered; it is indictable, with a maximum of life imprisonment.
  • 2(b) Evaluate the fairness of using causation to create criminal liability (25):
    • AO1: causation links the defendant’s act to the unlawful consequence, and the same act can lead to different offences depending on the consequence and mens rea. Factual causation is the “but for” test (R v White (1910), R v Pagett (1983)). Legal causation needs the act to be the operative and substantial cause (R v Smith (1959), R v Cheshire (1991), R v Jordan (1956)). The thin skull rule means the defendant takes the victim as they find them (R v Blaue (1975)). The chain can be broken by a third party’s act (often poor medical treatment), by the victim’s own act (R v Roberts (1971), R v Williams (1992)) or by a natural but unpredictable event.
    • AO2: without causation there is no actus reus; it supports fair labelling and influences sentencing; it helps in hard areas such as poor medical treatment; but it can sometimes seem too easy to prove, leading to unfair or inconsistent verdicts.
    • AO3: factual causation is a natural basis for liability but may be too easy to prove; legal causation links to personal responsibility, but policy towards medical staff, police and emergency workers can seem unfair; whether an intervening act is “sufficiently independent and serious” is hard for juries; the thin skull rule can unfairly increase liability for a condition the defendant could not know about; and vagueness in the chain of causation could lead to conviction for a more serious offence than the defendant ever contemplated.

Question 3: youth custody and blackmail

  • 3(a) Two custodial sentences for young offenders (5): the mark scheme credited the older framework (detention at Her Majesty’s Pleasure for murder with a 12-year minimum term, detention for serious crimes, young offender institutions for ages 15–20 with a 21-day minimum, and detention and training orders of 4–24 months, half in custody) or the Sentencing Act 2020 framework (detention and training orders for ages 12–17, detention for life or an extended sentence for dangerous offenders, and detention during His Majesty’s Pleasure). One mark per point, but you must describe two sentences to reach 5.
  • 3(b) Evaluate the effectiveness of the law of blackmail (25):
    • AO1: blackmail is in s21 Theft Act 1968. There must be a demand (R v Collister and Warhurst (1955), Treacy v DPP (1971), R v Lambert (2009), R v Pogmore (2017)) that is unwarranted (R v Harvey (1981)) and made with menaces (R v Lawrence and Pomroy (1971), R v Harry (1974)). The mens rea is intention to make an unwarranted demand with menaces, with a view to gain or intent to cause loss (R v Bevans (1988)), with gain and loss defined in s34. Dishonesty is not needed. Whether the defendant believed there were reasonable grounds for the demand, and that menaces were a proper means, are questions of fact. It is indictable with a maximum of 14 years.
    • AO2: blackmail usefully extends the property offences by punishing pressure on victims; statute is meant to give clarity, but the cases show the law is still complex; it is a “hidden offence”, which makes charging and conviction hard; and it has many elements to prove.
    • AO3: juries know blackmail at a popular level, so they must grasp the legal requirements; an implied demand is enough, which can make proof hard; coincidence of actus reus and mens rea around the demand can cause problems; the maker of the demand need not be the one able to carry out the menaces, which may make conviction too easy; menaces may be read differently for victims below “average firmness”; the reasonable grounds defence turns on belief, and entitlement to the money is irrelevant; s34 limits gain and loss to money or property; and victims in relationships of dominance may be too frightened to report.

Where the marks are on 9084/22

By assessment objective, for a candidate answering Question 1 and either Section B question:

Assessment objectiveQuestion 1Section B questionTotal
AO1 Knowledge and understanding615 (part (a) 5 + part (b) 10)21
AO2 Analysis and application24630
AO3 Evaluation099
Total303060
  • Half the paper is application. 24 of the 30 Section A marks are AO2, so most of your Question 1 time should go on applying each element of s4 or s11 to the facts.
  • Dishonesty comes up in every scenario. Barton and Booth is the one case cited in all three parts of the mark scheme, so state the Ivey test and apply it each time.
  • All 9 AO3 marks are in one essay. In part (b), each paragraph needs a judgement about fairness or effectiveness, not just a case.

How to self-mark 9084/22 with the mark scheme

  1. Check the offence you chose. s11 for Peter, s4 for Anton and Celeste, and either for Helen. Accurate citation of the section and the relevant source cases earns the 2 AO1 marks.
  2. Tick off each element. For s4: position, dishonest abuse, intention to gain or cause loss. For s11: dishonest act, services that need payment, not paying in full, knowledge and intent.
  3. Check you dealt with every person. In 1(b), an answer that covers only Celeste cannot reach full marks.
  4. Test your conclusion. The top AO2 level needs a developed, logical conclusion: “Anton is not guilty because, although he is in a position of trust, he is not dishonest under Barton and Booth” rather than just “Anton is not guilty”.
  5. Mark part (a) by counting points, up to 5. For 3(a), check you described two sentences.
  6. Give part (b) three separate marks: AO1 out of 10, AO2 out of 6 and AO3 out of 9.

Sit 9084/22 as a timed mock

You have 90 minutes for 60 marks, so give each half of the paper about 45 minutes.

BlockMarksTime
Read the source material and plan Question 1–5 minutes
Question 1(a)1013 minutes
Question 1(b)1013 minutes
Question 1(c)1013 minutes
Section B part (a)55 minutes
Section B part (b)2536 minutes
Check conclusions and case citations–5 minutes

Before each Question 1 part, write the offence and the elements in a column, then tick each one against the facts. The missing element is usually what decides the conclusion.

9084/22 in other series

May/June 2026 kept the same shape: a 30-mark source-based Question 1 in three 10-mark parts, then a choice of two 5 + 25 mark Section B questions. The source moved from the Fraud Act to handling stolen goods, and causation was the Question 2(b) essay in both series. This paper’s mark scheme credited factual causation (White, Pagett), while the 2026 question was on legal causation only and gave no credit for it.

Other October/November 2025 9084 papers

Practise and download

Need help with a 9084 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Law tutor →

Frequently asked questions

What was the source material on 9084 Paper 22 October/November 2025? +

Sections 4 (fraud by abuse of position) and 11 (obtaining services dishonestly) of the Fraud Act 2006, with summaries of R v Marshall (2009), R v Kapitene (2010) and R v Barton and Booth (2020). You apply only that material to three scenarios in Question 1.

Were Peter, Anton, Celeste and Helen guilty in 9084/22 Question 1? +

The mark scheme concluded that Peter is guilty under s11 for watching the tennis match without paying, Celeste is guilty under s4 for taking the workers' wages, and Anton is not guilty because he was not dishonest. Helen could be guilty under s11 or s4; both routes were credited.

How many marks is 9084/22 and how many questions do you answer? +

It is out of 60 marks and lasts 1 hour 30 minutes. You answer the compulsory 30-mark source-based Question 1 and one of the two 30-mark Section B questions.

What could you choose in Section B of 9084/22? +

Question 2 had 5 marks describing the aggravated offence under s1(2) Criminal Damage Act 1971 and 25 marks evaluating the fairness of causation. Question 3 had 5 marks on two custodial sentences for young offenders and 25 marks evaluating the effectiveness of the law of blackmail.

How are the 25-mark essays on 9084/22 marked? +

Each part (b) is marked on three separate grids: AO1 knowledge out of 10, AO2 analysis out of 6 and AO3 evaluation out of 9. The top AO3 level, 7 to 9, needs focused, reasoned evaluation of most of the relevant issues and a coherent argument.

Where can I download 9084/22 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +

Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 past papers page.

What is 9084_w25_qp_22? +

9084_w25_qp_22 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 Paper 22 (Paper 2 Criminal Law, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9084_w25_ms_22, and the code printed on the cover is 9084/22/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level Law with free topic quizzes