Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 October/November 2025 Past Papers: What Came Up and How It Was Marked
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 October/November 2025 Past Papers: What Came Up and How It Was Marked

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 9 min read
Updated

The Cambridge AS & A Level Law (9084) October/November 2025 papers and mark schemes are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal. There are four papers, all variant 2: Paper 1 English Legal System (9084/12), Paper 2 Criminal Law (9084/22), Paper 3 Law of Contract (9084/32) and Paper 4 Law of Tort (9084/42). This post summarises what each paper set, how the mark schemes split marks between the three assessment objectives, and how to use the series as a mock.

Key points from the October/November 2025 9084 papers

  • The Fraud Act 2006 carried Paper 2. Section A was built on s4 (fraud by abuse of position) and s11 (obtaining services dishonestly), and dishonesty under Barton and Booth came up in all three scenarios.
  • Every problem had more than one claim or party. Paper 3 Question 1 had four issues to decide, Paper 4 Question 2 had two nuisance claims running in opposite directions, and Paper 2 Question 1(b) needed both Anton and Celeste.
  • Statute mattered on Paper 3. The cinema problem turned on the Consumer Rights Act 2015, especially s62 and s65, as well as the common law on exclusion clauses.
  • The essays tested statements. “Need modernising”, “guarantee justice”, “justified”, “no longer essential” and “precisely enough” all needed an argument on both sides and a judgement.
  • Long answers are marked separately for each AO. You get one mark for knowledge (AO1), one for analysis and application (AO2) and one for evaluation (AO3), then they are added.

All October/November 2025 9084 papers

PaperNameDurationMarksFile codes (QP and MS)Guide
12Paper 1 English Legal System1 hour 30 minutes759084_w25_qp_12 / 9084_w25_ms_12Paper 12 guide
22Paper 2 Criminal Law1 hour 30 minutes609084_w25_qp_22 / 9084_w25_ms_22Paper 22 guide
32Paper 3 Law of Contract1 hour 30 minutes759084_w25_qp_32 / 9084_w25_ms_32Paper 32 guide
42Paper 4 Law of Tort1 hour 30 minutes759084_w25_qp_42 / 9084_w25_ms_42Paper 42 guide

The codes printed on the covers are 9084/12/O/N/25, 9084/22/O/N/25, 9084/32/O/N/25 and 9084/42/O/N/25. In the file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp the question paper and ms the mark scheme.

Which variant is this? Cambridge sets different versions of each paper (variants) for different time zones. The papers here are variant 2: 9084/12, /22, /32 and /42. All variants cover the same syllabus in the same format, so variant 2 is just as good for practice as the one your school sat.

Download the 9084 October/November 2025 papers →

Paper-by-paper guides

For a question-by-question walkthrough of each paper, with the marks and what the mark scheme credited:

You answer all five questions in Section A (25 marks) and two of the three questions in Section B (25 marks each).

QuestionTopicMarks
1One qualification to become a Supreme Court judge1
2Two types of delegated legislation2
3Two aspects of parliamentary supremacy6
4Two stages in the qualification and training of solicitors6
5Advantages of using a jury in criminal cases10
6(a) Pre-trial processes for summary, either way and indictable offences (10); (b) factors in choosing the trial venue for an either way offence (15)25
7(a) Types of ADR available to claimants (10); (b) which types suit a consumer complaint (15)25
8(a) Techniques inferior courts use to avoid a binding precedent (10); (b) whether precedent limits the courts in developing the law (15)25

Watch for: Question 6(a) needs all three types of offence, and Question 7(b) asks you to apply each form of ADR to a consumer rather than describe ADR again. Question 8(b) rewards cases: the mark scheme listed more than twenty, from Young v Bristol Aeroplane to the 1966 Practice Statement. Full detail is in the Paper 12 guide.

What came up in 9084 Paper 2 (Criminal Law)?

Paper 2 had Question 1 in Section A (30 marks) and one of two Section B questions (30 marks).

Section A gave source material on s4 and s11 of the Fraud Act 2006 and three cases: R v Marshall (2009), R v Kapitene (2010) and R v Barton and Booth (2020). You apply only that material.

PartScenarioMark scheme conclusionMarks
1(a)Peter climbs through a fence to watch a tennis match without a ticketGuilty under s1110
1(b)Celeste underpays farm workers and spends the difference; Anton is her brother and co-ownerCeleste guilty under s4; Anton not guilty, as he was not dishonest10
1(c)Helen, her mother’s carer, uses her mother’s card for a streaming subscriptionGuilty under s11 or s4; both routes credited10

Section B (choose one):

  • Question 2: (a) the aggravated offence under s1(2) Criminal Damage Act 1971 (5); (b) evaluate the fairness of using causation to create criminal liability (25).
  • Question 3: (a) two custodial sentences for young offenders (5); (b) evaluate the effectiveness of the law of blackmail under s21 Theft Act 1968 (25).

What made it hard: in 1(b), the mark scheme said full marks needed the law applied to both Anton and Celeste. Anton held a position of trust but was not dishonest, so one element decided his case. See the Paper 22 guide for the elements of each offence applied to the facts.

What came up in 9084 Paper 3 (Law of Contract)?

You answer one problem from Section A and two essays from Section B, 25 marks each.

QuestionTopicMarks
1 (or 2)Jada’s cinema membership: a tick-box contract, a lost coat under an “owner’s risk” notice, a broken arm from an uncleaned spilt drink, and a no-cancellation term (exclusion clauses and the Consumer Rights Act 2015)25
2 (or 1)Adam’s written agreement to live in his parents’ house, and a pizza firm’s free dessert promotion (intention to create legal relations)25
3To what extent the rules for communicating acceptance need modernising25
4Whether specific performance and injunctions guarantee justice is served25
5Whether the restrictions on minors entering contracts are justified25

Watch for: the mark scheme reached a separate outcome on each Question 1 issue. Jada is bound by the terms she ticked, the firm can rely on the clear cloakroom notice, it cannot exclude liability for the negligent injury under s65, and any sensible conclusion on cancellation was credited. In Question 2, the dessert was a commercial agreement with the presumption not rebutted, while a conclusion either way was accepted on the house. See the Paper 32 guide.

What came up in 9084 Paper 4 (Law of Tort)?

Paper 4 has the same layout as Paper 3: one problem and two essays, 25 marks each.

QuestionTopicMarks
1 (or 2)Amy threatens and pushes past a security guard, who breaks his wrist, then the manager keeps her in an unlocked staff room for an hour: assault, battery and false imprisonment25
2 (or 1)Matt’s holiday guests use a balcony overlooking Sally’s garden; Sally hammers on the walls at night: private nuisance in both directions25
3Evaluate the calculation of damages for personal injuries caused by negligence25
4Whether volenti non fit injuria is no longer essential, given other ways to apportion blame25
5Whether the special relationship in negligent misstatement is defined precisely enough to avoid injustice25

Watch for: the key facts in Question 1 are the conditional threat, the injury that followed directly from the push and the unlocked door, which goes to total restraint. Question 2 also asks who has standing to sue Sally: Matt as owner or Tony as a short-term guest. In Question 3, a detailed account of duty of care was not credited. See the Paper 42 guide.

How the 9084 October/November 2025 mark scheme gives marks

Every 9084 mark scheme uses three assessment objectives: AO1 is knowledge and understanding, AO2 is analysis and application, and AO3 is evaluation. Here is how the series used them.

1. Short questions are point-marked. Paper 1 Questions 1 and 2 are one mark per correct answer. Questions 3 and 4 give 1 mark for naming each aspect or stage and up to 2 for describing it. Paper 2 parts (a) give 1 mark per point, up to 5, and 3(a) needed two sentences described to reach 5.

2. Paper 1 Section B splits each question by AO. Part (a) is 10 marks of AO1 on a four-level grid, with 9–10 for accurate, detailed knowledge with key cases or statutes. Part (b) is 15 marks: 8 for AO2 and 7 for AO3, each on its own grid. Question 5 is the only levelled Section A question, with 6 for AO2 and 4 for AO3.

3. Paper 2 Section A is mostly application. Each 10-mark part gives 2 marks for AO1 (identifying and citing the relevant law) and 8 for AO2. The top AO2 level (6–8) needs fully developed application leading to a developed, logical conclusion. That means saying why, for example that Anton is not guilty because he is not dishonest under Barton and Booth.

4. The Paper 2 essays split 10, 6 and 9. AO3 carries 9 of the 25 marks, so each paragraph needs a judgement about fairness or effectiveness, not just a case.

5. Papers 3 and 4 use a 12, 5, 8 split. Every 25-mark question gives up to 12 for AO1, 5 for AO2 and 8 for AO3, so knowledge is 36 of the 75 marks on each paper. The Paper 4 scheme listed issues rather than specific cases, but its AO1 descriptors still reward key cases and terminology.

6. Conclusions earn the evaluation marks in problems. On Papers 3 and 4, AO2 and AO3 are earned together in the problems by applying the law to each fact and reaching a conclusion on each issue. An answer that discusses the law in general without deciding each claim cannot reach the top AO3 level.

7. Answer the exact question. Off-question material is not credited. On Paper 4 Question 3, a brief outline of negligence could earn some credit, but a detailed duty of care section earned nothing.

8. Levels are best fit. Examiners give the top mark in a level if you meet it convincingly, a middle mark if adequately and the bottom mark if you only just meet it.

Which papers should you sit?

  • AS Level: Paper 1 and Paper 2.
  • Full A Level: Papers 1, 2, 3 and 4.

Each paper has a choice. On Paper 1 you pick two of three Section B questions; on Paper 2 one of two Section B questions; on Papers 3 and 4 one of two problems and two of three essays. Read all of them before you choose, and pick Paper 1 Section B questions by part (b), which carries 15 of the 25 marks.

How to use the October/November 2025 papers as a mock

  1. Use the real timing. Every paper is 90 minutes. On Papers 3 and 4 that is about 26 minutes per 25-mark answer, with time to plan and check.
  2. List the elements before you apply them. For Paper 2 Question 1, write the elements of s4 or s11 in a column and tick each against the facts. The missing element usually decides the outcome.
  3. Plan problems by party. One line per pair or issue: the rule, the key fact, the outcome.
  4. Decide your essay answer first. Then build the evaluation towards it, with cases on both sides.
  5. Mark each AO separately. Give yourself an AO1, AO2 and AO3 mark from the grids, add them up and note which AO cost you most.

9084 in other series

The May/June 2026 papers kept the same layout and AO splits, with some topics, such as causation and volenti, set in both series. See May/June 2026 9084 papers: overview.

More A Level Law resources

🔍 Looking for a specific past paper? Use our free Past Paper Finder to search by subject, year and exam board.

Need help with a 9084 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Law tutor →

Frequently asked questions

Are the 9084 October/November 2025 past papers free? +

Yes. All four question papers (9084/12, 9084/22, 9084/32 and 9084/42) and their official mark schemes are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

What came up in 9084 Paper 2 October/November 2025? +

Section A gave source material on ss4 and 11 of the Fraud Act 2006 with R v Marshall, R v Kapitene and R v Barton and Booth, applied to Peter at a tennis match, Celeste and Anton on a farm, and Helen as her mother's carer. Section B offered aggravated criminal damage and causation, or custodial sentences for young offenders and blackmail.

What were the 9084 Paper 3 and Paper 4 questions in October/November 2025? +

Paper 3 (Contract) offered an exclusion clause problem on a cinema membership or an intention to create legal relations problem, then essays on communicating acceptance, specific performance and injunctions, and minors' contracts. Paper 4 (Tort) offered a trespass to the person problem or a private nuisance problem, then essays on personal injury damages, volenti non fit injuria and negligent misstatement.

How are the 25-mark questions in 9084 marked? +

Each assessment objective is marked separately on its own level grid. On Papers 3 and 4, every question gives up to 12 marks for AO1 (knowledge), 5 for AO2 (analysis and application) and 8 for AO3 (evaluation). On Paper 2 the 25-mark essay splits 10, 6 and 9, and on Paper 1 each 15-mark part (b) splits 8 for AO2 and 7 for AO3.

Why can't I find 9084/21 or 9084/23 for October/November 2025? +

The Tutopiya Learning Portal has variant 2 of each October/November 2025 paper: 9084/12, 9084/22, 9084/32 and 9084/42. Cambridge sets different variants for different time zones, and they test the same syllabus in the same format, so variant 2 prepares you just as well.

When will the October/November 2026 9084 papers be available? +

Usually around January 2027, after Cambridge releases them. We add them to the Learning Portal once they are published.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level Law with free topic quizzes