Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 English Legal System): Question-by-Question Guide
Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/12 is the October/November 2025 Paper 1 (English Legal System), variant 2. It is an AS Level component that lasts 1 hour 30 minutes, is worth 75 marks and is sat by every 9084 candidate. You answer seven questions: all five short questions in Section A (25 marks) and two of the three two-part questions in Section B (25 marks each). The biggest single parts are the 15-mark part (b) discussions, marked separately for analysis and evaluation. This guide goes through the paper question by question and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.
For the newest series of the same paper, see 9084 Paper 12 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.
For an overview of all four 9084 papers from this series, see A Level Law 9084 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes.
9084/12 at a glance
Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9084/12/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9084_w25_qp_12 and the mark scheme file is 9084_w25_ms_12.
Rubric: answer all questions in Section A and two questions from Section B, seven questions in total.
| Question | Section | Topic | Command word | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A (compulsory) | One qualification to become a Supreme Court judge | Identify | 1 |
| 2 | A (compulsory) | Two types of delegated legislation | Identify | 2 |
| 3 | A (compulsory) | Two aspects of parliamentary supremacy | Describe | 6 |
| 4 | A (compulsory) | Two stages in the qualification and training of solicitors | Describe | 6 |
| 5 | A (compulsory) | Advantages of using a jury in criminal cases | Discuss | 10 |
| 6 | B (choose two of 6–8) | (a) Pre-trial processes for summary, either way and indictable offences (10); (b) factors in choosing the trial venue for an either way offence (15) | Describe; discuss | 25 |
| 7 | B (choose two of 6–8) | (a) Types of ADR available to claimants (10); (b) which types suit a consumer complaint (15) | Describe; discuss | 25 |
| 8 | B (choose two of 6–8) | (a) Techniques inferior courts use to avoid a binding precedent (10); (b) whether precedent limits the courts in developing the law (15) | Describe; assess | 25 |
| Total answered (Section A + two from Section B) | 75 |
Question-by-question walkthrough
Section A: five compulsory questions (25 marks)
Question 1: one qualification for the Supreme Court (1 mark) Any one of: the 15-year Supreme Court qualification, holding high judicial office (for example as a Court of Appeal judge or former Law Lord), or being a barrister or solicitor.
Question 2: two types of delegated legislation (2 marks) One mark each for any two of Orders in Council, statutory instruments and bylaws. This is two marks of pure recall; don’t spend time describing them.
Question 3: two aspects of parliamentary supremacy (6 marks) All AO1. Each aspect earns 1 mark for naming it and up to 2 for describing it, so 3 marks per aspect. The mark scheme’s aspects:
- Parliament can make any law it wishes;
- Acts of Parliament cannot be challenged by the courts;
- no Parliament is bound by a previous Parliament, and no Parliament can pass an Act that binds a later one;
- Parliament can change its own powers;
- the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949.
Question 4: two stages in training solicitors (6 marks) Same structure: 1 mark for naming a stage and up to 2 for describing it. The stages listed were a law degree, or a non-law degree plus the Graduate Diploma in Law (GDL), the Legal Practice Course (LPC), the training contract, the Professional Skills Course and continuing professional development. The mark scheme also credited the newer route: a degree, the two-stage Solicitors Qualifying Examination (SQE), qualifying work experience and the Solicitors Regulation Authority’s character and suitability requirements. Pick two stages you can describe properly rather than listing six.
Question 5: advantages of juries (10 marks) The only levels-marked question in Section A: 6 marks for AO2 (analysis and application) and 4 for AO3 (evaluation), each on its own grid. The top AO2 level (5–6) needs clearly reasoned analysis with effective use of relevant examples. The full 4 for AO3 needs clearly focused evaluation developed with relevant evidence.
Advantages in the mark scheme: public confidence, a democratic element, jury equity (with R v Ponting 1985, R v Kronlid 1996 and R v Randle and Pottle), open justice, secret discussion, impartiality and a representative panel. Jury equity is where the cases come in, so use at least one acquittal to show what it means in practice. “Discuss” also lets you weigh how strong each advantage really is.
Section B: two from three (50 marks)
All three questions share the same marking:
- Part (a), 10 marks, all AO1: a four-level grid. Level 4 (9–10) is accurate and detailed in most relevant areas, with thorough knowledge of key examples, cases or statutes and correct legal terminology. Level 3 (6–8) is mostly accurate but thin in places, Level 2 (3–5) has some accuracy but lacks detail, and Level 1 (1–2) is limited.
- Part (b), 15 marks: AO2 out of 8 and AO3 out of 7, each on a three-level grid. The top AO2 level (6–8) needs mostly focused, reasoned analysis throughout, supported by well-developed use of legal rules, cases or statutes. The top AO3 level (6–7) needs reasoned evaluation of most of the relevant issues, supported by relevant material, and a coherent argument.
Question 6: pre-trial processes and trial venue (25 marks)
- (a) Pre-trial processes for the three types of offence (10): for summary offences, the magistrates’ court checks name and address and takes the plea; a guilty plea leads to an outline of the case, previous convictions, background information and reports, a speech in mitigation and sentence, and a not guilty plea goes to trial. For triable either way offences: plea before venue, then (on a not guilty plea) the mode of trial hearing, where magistrates consider jurisdiction and the defendant may elect; magistrates can try the case and commit for sentence if needed. For indictable offences: an initial hearing in the magistrates’ court, transfer for trial, the Plea and Trial Preparation Hearing and disclosure. Cover all three types; an answer that only does one is held down by the level descriptors.
- (b) Factors in choosing the trial venue (15): the mark scheme sets out both courts. Magistrates’ court advantages: local, less publicity, heard more quickly, shorter trial, lower sentencing powers, a better chance of bail and an automatic right of appeal. Its disadvantages: less likelihood of legal representation, harder to challenge witnesses and a greater chance of being found guilty. Crown Court advantages: a greater chance of acquittal, the chance to get the prosecution to reduce the charge, defences can be fully argued and more chance of legal aid. Its disadvantages: a longer wait, publicity, it may not be local, higher potential sentences, the need for legal advice, longer and more expensive trials and a lower chance of bail. The question is from the defendant’s point of view, so weigh the trade-off between acquittal rates and sentencing risk.
Question 7: ADR (25 marks)
- (a) Types of ADR available to claimants (10): the mark scheme covers four. Negotiation is face to face, with or without lawyers, and not binding. Conciliation uses a neutral trained person to help reach a compromise, and is not binding. Mediation uses a neutral third party as a facilitator who can express opinions, and includes formalised settlement conferences, mini-trials and online dispute resolution, with examples such as the Centre for Dispute Resolution and West Kent Mediation. Arbitration is governed by the Arbitration Act 1996 (with Scott v Avery), needs a written arbitration agreement, has the parties submit to a decision by someone other than a judge, can use any number of arbitrators, can be on paper or in person, and the award is binding.
- (b) Which types suit a consumer complaint? (15): negotiation is the least formal, possibly cheaper, quicker and completely private. Conciliation is private, allows compromise, may not give a strictly legal outcome and avoids the adversarial courtroom. Mediation only works if there is some hope of co-operation, is most suited to businesses, takes many forms and leaves the parties in control. Arbitration must be agreed in advance in writing, is common in commercial and some consumer contracts, and for a low-value consumer claim the consumer can insist on the small claims track; it offers flexibility of time and place, expert arbitrators and speed. The question is about a consumer, so apply each method to that situation rather than describing ADR in general again.
Question 8: judicial precedent (25 marks)
- (a) Techniques to avoid a binding precedent (10): the mark scheme covers overruling (a later, higher court decides an earlier precedent was wrong, as in Davis v Johnson 1979 and Pepper v Hart 1993), reversing (a higher court on appeal overturns the lower court’s decision in the same case, for example the High Court reversing the County Court) and distinguishing (the material facts are different enough to draw a distinction, as with Rylands v Fletcher 1868 and Read v Lyons 1947, or Balfour v Balfour 1919 and Merritt v Merritt 1970). Point out that distinguishing can be done by any court.
- (b) Does precedent limit the courts in developing the law? (15): the mark scheme looks at the two senior courts. For the Court of Appeal: the Young v Bristol Aeroplane (1944) exceptions (conflicting Court of Appeal decisions, decisions overruled by the Supreme Court, decisions made per incuriam), Williams v Fawcett 1986, Lord Denning’s “self-imposed limitation” view in Gallie v Lee 1969, rare use in Rickards v Rickards 1989, a recent extension in R v Cooper 2011, and the Criminal Division’s extra leeway where the law was “misapplied or misunderstood” (R v Taylor 1950, R v Spencer 1985, R v Simpson 2003, R v Magro 2010). For the Supreme Court: the 1966 Practice Statement, first used in Conway v Rimmer 1968, slow to update the law (Addie v Dumbreck 1929 to BRB v Herrington 1972), reluctance in Re Dowling 1967, Jones v Secretary of State for Social Services 1972 and Knuller v DPP 1973, later use in Anns v Merton LBC 1977 and Murphy v Brentwood DC 1990, and less use in criminal law because of the need for certainty (R v Caldwell 1982 and R v R and G 2003).
Where the marks are on 9084/12
By assessment objective, for a candidate answering Section A and any two Section B questions:
| Assessment objective | Section A | Section B (two questions) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| AO1 Knowledge and understanding | 15 (Questions 1–4) | 20 (two part (a)s) | 35 |
| AO2 Analysis and application | 6 (Question 5) | 16 (two part (b)s) | 22 |
| AO3 Evaluation | 4 (Question 5) | 14 (two part (b)s) | 18 |
| Total | 25 | 50 | 75 |
- Questions 1 and 2 are 3 marks of one-line recall. Learn the short lists: Supreme Court qualifications and the three types of delegated legislation.
- Questions 3 and 4 reward description, not lists. Each is 2 aspects × 3 marks, so a named point with no explanation earns only a third of its marks.
- The two part (b)s carry 30 marks, and they are marked for analysis and evaluation. Question 8(b) in particular rewards cases: the mark scheme lists more than twenty.
How to self-mark 9084/12 with the mark scheme
- Mark Questions 1 and 2 point by point. One mark per correct answer, and stop at the maximum.
- For Questions 3 and 4, check each point has a name and a description. Give 1 for the name and up to 2 for a developed description of what it means.
- Give Question 5 two separate marks. First an AO2 mark out of 6 for how well you analysed the advantages with examples, then an AO3 mark out of 4 for how far you weighed them. Add them.
- Level part (a) as a whole. Compare your answer with the indicative content and ask whether it is accurate and detailed in most relevant areas (9–10) or thin in places (6–8). For 6(a), missing one of the three offence types usually holds you below Level 4.
- Give part (b) an AO2 mark out of 8 and an AO3 mark out of 7. For AO3, check you reached a judgement, such as which venue a defendant should choose or which form of ADR suits a consumer best.
- Count your cases in 8(a) and 8(b). The top levels ask for key cases; an answer on precedent with none will not get there.
Sit 9084/12 as a timed mock
You have 90 minutes for 75 marks, a little over a minute per mark.
| Block | Marks | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Read the paper and choose two Section B questions | – | 3 minutes |
| Questions 1 and 2 | 3 | 2 minutes |
| Question 3 | 6 | 6 minutes |
| Question 4 | 6 | 6 minutes |
| Question 5 | 10 | 12 minutes |
| First Section B question: (a) 11 min, (b) 17 min | 25 | 28 minutes |
| Second Section B question: (a) 11 min, (b) 17 min | 25 | 28 minutes |
| Check, especially part (b) conclusions | – | 5 minutes |
Choose your Section B questions by part (b): it is worth 15 of the 25 marks, so pick the debates you can argue with cases or examples.
9084/12 in other series
May/June 2026 kept exactly the same shape: five Section A questions worth 1, 2, 6, 6 and 10 marks, then two from three 25-mark Section B questions. ADR appeared in both series (types of ADR and a consumer complaint here, mediation and conciliation in 2026), and delegated legislation moved from a 2-mark recall question here to the 10-mark Question 5 in 2026.
Other October/November 2025 9084 papers
Practise and download
- Download 9084/12 and its mark scheme on the Learning Portal →
- All 9084 October/November 2025 papers: overview and marking patterns
- All 9084 May/June 2026 papers: overview and marking patterns
- Try a free A Level Law quiz
Need help with a 9084 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Law tutor →
Frequently asked questions
What came up on 9084 Paper 12 October/November 2025? +
Section A asked about a Supreme Court judge's qualifications, types of delegated legislation, parliamentary supremacy, how solicitors qualify and the advantages of juries. Section B offered pre-trial processes and trial venue, types of ADR and a consumer complaint, and avoiding precedent and whether precedent limits the courts.
How many marks is 9084/12 and how many questions do you answer? +
It is out of 75 marks and lasts 1 hour 30 minutes. You answer all five Section A questions (25 marks) and two of the three Section B questions (25 marks each), seven questions in total.
What were the three types of delegated legislation in 9084/12 Question 2? +
The mark scheme credited Orders in Council, statutory instruments and bylaws. Any two earned the 2 marks.
Which cases did the 9084/12 mark scheme list for jury equity? +
For Question 5 it listed R v Ponting (1985), R v Kronlid (1996) and R v Randle and Pottle, alongside advantages such as public confidence, open justice, secret discussion, impartiality and a representative panel.
How are the Section B questions on 9084/12 marked? +
Part (a) is 10 marks of AO1 knowledge on a four-level grid, with 9 to 10 for accurate, detailed answers using key cases, statutes or examples. Part (b) is 15 marks, 8 for AO2 analysis and 7 for AO3 evaluation, each on its own three-level grid.
Where can I download 9084/12 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +
Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 past papers page.
What is 9084_w25_qp_12? +
9084_w25_qp_12 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 Paper 12 (Paper 1 English Legal System, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9084_w25_ms_12, and the code printed on the cover is 9084/12/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.
Ready to Excel in Your Studies?
Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.
Book Your Free TrialWritten by
Mahira Kitchil
Connect on LinkedIn →Project Head, Tutopiya
Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.
Related Articles
A Level Biology 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes
Free 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Paper 1 and Paper 3 with mark schemes: the topics tested, the practical tasks and how examiners awarded marks on each.
A Level Computer Science 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Marking
Free 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 papers and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of Papers 1 to 4 and how examiners gave marks for code and theory.
A Level Geography 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme
Free 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 papers, inserts and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of the data questions, options and essays and how they were levelled.
