Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/32 October/November 2025 (Paper 3 Law of Contract): Question-by-Question Guide
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/32 October/November 2025 (Paper 3 Law of Contract): Question-by-Question Guide

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 9 min read
Updated

Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084/32 is the October/November 2025 Paper 3 (Law of Contract), variant 2. It is an A Level component that lasts 1 hour 30 minutes and is worth 75 marks. You answer three questions: one of two problem questions in Section A and two of three essays in Section B, each worth 25 marks. Every question is marked on the same grid, with knowledge (AO1) worth almost half of each answer. This guide goes through the paper question by question and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

For the newest series of the same paper, see 9084 Paper 32 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.

For an overview of all four 9084 papers from this series, see A Level Law 9084 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes.

9084/32 at a glance

Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9084/32/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9084_w25_qp_32 and the mark scheme file is 9084_w25_ms_32.

Rubric: answer one question from Section A and two questions from Section B, three questions in total.

QuestionSectionTypeTopicMarks
1A (either)ProblemJada’s cinema membership, lost coat and broken arm: exclusion clauses and cancellation25
2A (or)ProblemAdam’s agreement with his parents and a pizza firm’s free dessert: intention to create legal relations25
3B (choose two)EssayTo what extent do the rules for communicating acceptance need modernising?25
4B (choose two)EssayDo specific performance and injunctions guarantee justice is served?25
5B (choose two)EssayAre the restrictions on minors entering contracts justified?25
Total answered (one from Section A + two from Section B)75

Question-by-question walkthrough

How every question is marked

All five questions are marked out of 25, with each assessment objective marked separately and then added:

  • AO1 Knowledge and understanding, out of 12 (four levels). Level 4 (10–12) is accurate and detailed in most relevant areas, with thorough knowledge of the most appropriate cases or statutes and correct terminology. Level 3 (7–9) is mostly accurate but thin in places, Level 2 (4–6) has some accuracy but lacks detail, and Level 1 (1–3) is limited.
  • AO2 Analysis and application, out of 5. The top level (4–5) needs mostly focused and reasoned application (Section A) or analysis (Section B) throughout, supported by well-developed use of rules and cases; 2–3 is some reasoned application or analysis; 1 is limited.
  • AO3 Evaluation, out of 8. The top level (6–8) needs mostly focused and reasoned evaluation of all the relevant issues, effectively supported by relevant material, with a coherent argument; 3–5 is some evaluation, reasoned at times; 1–2 is limited.

In the problems, the mark scheme groups AO2 and AO3 together: you earn them by applying the law to each fact and reaching a conclusion on each issue.

Section A: the problem questions

Question 1: Jada and AB Ltd (25 marks)

Jada bought an annual cinema membership online, ticking a box to accept terms she did not read. The terms excluded liability for injuries and said membership could not be cancelled. Her coat went missing from a cloakroom with a large “owner’s risk” notice, she slipped on an uncleaned spilt drink and broke her arm, and two months later she wanted to cancel because of a job abroad.

  • AO1, common law control of exclusion clauses: whether the agreement is in writing (L’Estrange v Graucob, Curtis v Chemical Cleaning and Dyeing Co), reasonable notice (Olley v Marlborough Court Hotel, Chapelton v Barry UDC) and a previous course of dealing (McCutcheon v David MacBrayne).
  • AO1, the Consumer Rights Act 2015: s61 (consumer contracts), s62 (terms must be fair; a term is unfair if it causes a significant imbalance to the consumer’s detriment), Schedule 2 (terms that may be unfair), s65 (no exclusion of liability for death or personal injury from negligence) and s68 (written terms must be transparent: plain, intelligible language and legible).
  • The tick box: the terms were set out clearly when Jada contracted, it does not matter that she did not read them, so she is bound by them.
  • The coat: ABL must show the notice was clear and brought to customers’ attention. It was a large notice and Jada left her coat anyway, so ABL can rely on the sign.
  • The broken arm: not cleaning up a spilt drink would be negligent, and ABL cannot exclude liability for personal injury caused by negligence (s65).
  • Cancelling the membership: the term must be fair under s62 and not contrary to good faith, and it is transparent and legible. The mark scheme credits any sensible conclusion on whether ABL can rely on it.

Four separate issues means four separate conclusions. An answer that discusses exclusion clauses in general without deciding each one cannot reach the top AO3 level.

Question 2: Adam (25 marks)

Adam’s parents let him live in their house under a written agreement, until he could afford his own and on condition he kept it tidy; finding it untidy, they told him to leave immediately. Later he ordered a pizza under a “free dessert with every pizza” promotion and got no dessert because the company had run out.

  • AO1, domestic agreements: a rebuttable presumption of no intention between family members (Jones v Padavatton, Balfour v Balfour). It can be rebutted where the parties no longer act out of love and affection (Merritt v Merritt), where they acted in reliance (Parker v Clark), where financial security is at risk (Simpkins v Pays, Wilson v Burnett) or by the seriousness of the situation (Darke v Strout).
  • AO1, commercial agreements: a very strong rebuttable presumption of intention (Esso Petroleum v Commissioners of Customs and Excise, Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co, McGowan v Radio Buxton). It can be rebutted by clear words (Jones v Vernon Pools, Confetti Records v Warner Music), an honour pledge clause (Rose and Frank v JR Crompton), words not clear enough to be a specific promise (Kleinwort Benson v Malaysia Mining), or a statement denying previous liability that may simply explain the offer (Edwards v Skyways).
  • Adam and the house: a family arrangement like Jones v Padavatton, so no intention is presumed. The written document and any reliance by Adam may be enough to rebut it. The mark scheme accepts a conclusion either way.
  • Adam and the dessert: a pizza company offering a free dessert to promote its business is a commercial agreement, so the strong presumption applies and has not been rebutted.

Section B: the essays (choose two)

Question 3: do the rules for communicating acceptance need modernising? (25 marks)

  • AO1: acceptance is a positive, unqualified agreement to all the terms (the mirror image rule). It must be communicated, in any form (Yates v Pulleyn), and is effective when received (Entores v Miles Far East). Silence is not acceptance (Felthouse v Bindley, IRC v Fry), and communication may be waived in unilateral offers (Carlill). The postal rule makes acceptance effective on posting (Adams v Lindsell); instantaneous methods follow Entores, reaffirmed in Brinkibon v Stahag; business hours matter (The Brimnes, Thomas v BPE Solicitors); and the battle of the forms follows the last shot (Butler Machine Tool v Ex-Cell-O, TRW v Panasonic).
  • Evaluation points: the silence rule is confusing (in Felthouse the nephew was not really silent) but treating silence as acceptance could trap people in contracts; the rule is not absolute (Vitol SA v Norelf, The Hannah Blumenthal). Some modernisation has happened: unsolicited goods legislation and the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 let consumers treat unsolicited goods as a gift. The postal rule made sense when there were few alternatives, applies only to Royal Mail, and leaves an offeror uncertain if a letter is lost, when few people now use the post. Brexit raises questions about the Electronic Commerce (EC Directive) Regulations, Thomas and Gander v BPE Solicitors shows the rules struggle with modern methods, case-by-case decisions make advice hard, and the Law Commission’s electronic execution of documents report proposes change.

Question 4: do specific performance and injunctions guarantee justice? (25 marks)

  • AO1: specific performance orders a party to perform, and may be granted where the subject matter is unique and damages are inadequate. It is refused where constant supervision is needed (Ryan v Mutual Tontine), for personal service (Page One Records v Britton), for an unfair contract (Walters v Morgan), for hardship to the defendant (Patel v Ali) and without mutuality (Price v Strange). An injunction is prohibitory or mandatory, permanent or interim, and is not granted to make someone complete a personal service (Page One Records).
  • Evaluation points: specific performance serves justice where the subject matter is unique and damages are no substitute (Falcke v Gray); it is generally unavailable for employment contracts, though supervising such an order would be very hard; delay defeats equity, but “how long is too long” is unclear, while the maxim protects defendants; refusing it for undue hardship, without mutuality or where the claimant acted unconscionably protects defendants; mandatory injunctions are rarely granted because they are hard to enforce; interim injunctions prevent irreparable harm while the main action waits; and against all this, the claimant carries a heavy burden to show damages are insufficient.

Question 5: are the restrictions on minors’ contracts justified? (25 marks)

  • AO1: contracts binding on a minor are those for necessaries (s3 Sale of Goods Act 1979; Nash v Inman, Chapple v Cooper, Fawcett v Smethurst) and beneficial contracts of service (Clements v London and North Western Railway, De Francesco v Barnum, Doyle v White City Stadium, Proform Sports Management v Proactive Sports Management). Voidable contracts (leases, shares, partnerships, marriage settlements) can be avoided before 18 and for a reasonable time after (Edwards v Carter, Steinberg v Scala, Corpe v Overton). All others are unenforceable against the minor but bind the other party. Under the Minors’ Contracts Act 1987, a guarantee can be enforced (s2) and restitution is available (s3).
  • Evaluation points: the necessaries rules protect minors, who are bound only for goods suited to their station in life and actual requirements, pay only a reasonable price and pay only for goods actually supplied; contracts with terms prejudicial to the minor are unenforceable, so the law is protective rather than restrictive; beneficial service contracts let minors support themselves while any detrimental term invalidates them; the voidable rules stop minors being tied into long-term, onerous obligations; and s2 lets a minor contract with a guarantor’s backing.

Where the marks are on 9084/32

By assessment objective, across the three questions you answer:

Assessment objectivePer questionAcross three questions
AO1 Knowledge and understanding1236
AO2 Analysis and application515
AO3 Evaluation824
Total2575
  • Knowledge is almost half the paper. 36 of the 75 marks are AO1. In Question 1 that means naming the Consumer Rights Act sections (s62, s65, s68) as well as the common law cases.
  • Evaluation outweighs analysis. AO3 is worth 8 per question against 5 for AO2, so each essay needs an argument that answers the question’s “to what extent” or “assess the validity”, and each problem needs a conclusion per issue.
  • The essays reward both sides. Questions 4 and 5 are statements to test; the indicative content gives points for and against, so a one-sided essay misses half the evaluation.

How to self-mark 9084/32 with the mark scheme

  1. List the law you used. Compare your cases and sections with the indicative content. Accurate, detailed coverage of most relevant areas is Level 4 (10–12); missing a whole area, such as the statutory controls in Question 1 or the commercial presumption in Question 2, holds you lower.
  2. Give AO2 a mark out of 5. In a problem, check every rule is tied to a specific fact (the large notice, the uncleaned drink, the written agreement). In an essay, check you explain how the cases work.
  3. Give AO3 a mark out of 8. In the problems, count your conclusions: Question 1 needs four, Question 2 needs two. In the essays, ask whether you reached a judgement on the statement.
  4. Place each mark within its level: top if you meet the level convincingly, middle if adequately, bottom if only just.
  5. Add the three marks and note which AO cost you most.

Sit 9084/32 as a timed mock

You have 90 minutes for three 25-mark answers, about 26 minutes each with time to plan and check.

BlockMarksTime
Read the paper, choose and plan your three questions–6 minutes
Section A problem2526 minutes
First Section B essay2526 minutes
Second Section B essay2526 minutes
Check conclusions and case names–6 minutes

For Question 1, plan one line for each of the four issues (terms, coat, arm, cancellation): the rule, the fact, the outcome. For an essay, decide your overall answer before you start so the evaluation builds towards it.

9084/32 in other series

May/June 2026 kept the same shape: one of two 25-mark problems, then two of three 25-mark essays, all on the 12/5/8 AO grid. Intention to create legal relations was Question 2 in both series, and minors’ contracts were an essay in both (whether the restrictions are justified here, whether the rules are fair to both parties in 2026).

Other October/November 2025 9084 papers

Practise and download

Need help with a 9084 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Law tutor →

Frequently asked questions

What came up on 9084 Paper 32 October/November 2025? +

Section A offered a problem on exclusion clauses in a cinema membership (Jada and AB Ltd) and a problem on intention to create legal relations (Adam, his parents and a pizza promotion). Section B essays asked about modernising the rules on communicating acceptance, whether specific performance and injunctions guarantee justice, and whether the restrictions on minors' contracts are justified.

How many marks is 9084/32 and how many questions do you answer? +

It is out of 75 marks and lasts 1 hour 30 minutes. You answer one of the two Section A problem questions and two of the three Section B essays, each worth 25 marks.

Could AB Ltd exclude liability for Jada's broken arm in 9084/32 Question 1? +

No. The mark scheme said that under s65 Consumer Rights Act 2015 a trader cannot exclude liability for personal injury caused by negligence, and leaving a spilt drink uncleaned would be negligent. AB Ltd could, however, rely on the clear cloakroom notice for the missing coat.

Was there intention to create legal relations in 9084/32 Question 2? +

For the free dessert, the mark scheme concluded the commercial presumption applied and was not rebutted. For Adam's house, a family arrangement, the written agreement and any reliance might rebut the presumption of no intention, and either reasoned conclusion was credited.

How is each 9084/32 question marked? +

Every question is 25 marks: AO1 knowledge out of 12, AO2 analysis and application out of 5 and AO3 evaluation out of 8, each on its own level grid. The top AO1 level, 10 to 12, needs accurate, detailed knowledge with key cases and statutes.

Where can I download 9084/32 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +

Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 past papers page.

What is 9084_w25_qp_32? +

9084_w25_qp_32 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level Law 9084 Paper 32 (Paper 3 Law of Contract, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9084_w25_ms_32, and the code printed on the cover is 9084/32/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level Law with free topic quizzes