Case supporting the view. For many firms, operations is primarily about executing what strategy has already decided — producing the products marketing and finance have chosen, at the cost finance has budgeted. The strategic choices (what to make, who to serve, what prices to charge) are made elsewhere; operations' job is to deliver. On this reading, operations is a cost centre whose success is measured by cost per unit, quality against spec and on-time delivery — important measures but not strategic.
Case against the view. Operations capability determines what strategies are credibly available to the firm. A firm with world-class operations can pursue strategies competitors cannot — low-cost mass production AND premium customisation (Toyota), ultra-fast fulfilment (Amazon), scalable platform operations (Uber, Airbnb). A firm with weak operations is restricted to strategies its operations can deliver, which is often a narrower set. The firms that have redefined their industries over the last 50 years almost all have operations excellence at the centre of their strategy — operations is not a support cost but a competitive weapon. Treating it as a cost centre leads to under-investment, which constrains strategic options over the long run.
Case for a middle view. The view holds for some firms and not for others. For firms competing primarily on brand, R&D or market position (consumer-goods brands, pharmaceuticals, media), operations may indeed be more of an execution function; the strategic value is elsewhere. For firms competing primarily on cost, delivery speed, quality or process capability (retailers, airlines, logistics, platforms), operations IS the strategy; treating it as a cost centre destroys the business. The right description depends on where the firm's competitive advantage sits.
Reasoned judgement. I partly disagree with the view. For firms where competitive advantage comes from operations (retail, logistics, platforms, process-based manufacturing), operations is unambiguously strategic. For firms where competitive advantage comes from brand, R&D or market position, operations is more of a support function but still enables (or constrains) what the firm can do. The strongest statement is: operations is strategic for some firms and a support function for others, depending on where competitive advantage sits. Treating operations as 'just a cost centre' is wrong for firms whose advantage depends on operations capability and right only for firms where strategy sits elsewhere. For most firms, under-investing in operations capability constrains strategic options even where operations is not the leading source of advantage.