Case supporting the view. Firms that cannot self-fund their operations and investments are dependent on external parties (banks, bond markets, investors) whose terms, timing and willingness to lend may change. A self-funded business controls its own destiny; an externally-funded one is subject to the whims of the capital markets. During the 2008 financial crisis, firms with no debt sailed through; firms dependent on bank lending often struggled. On this reading, self-funding is a mark of financial strength and reliance on external finance is a vulnerability.
Case against the view. External finance is a tool for growth and efficiency, not a sign of weakness. Many of the most successful firms in history have raised significant external finance — venture-capital-backed technology companies, debt-funded industrial acquisitions, equity-funded expansions. Self-funding limits growth to the pace of retained profit, which is often too slow in competitive markets. Debt also lowers the firm's cost of capital (after-tax interest is cheaper than equity returns), raising returns to equity holders. A firm that insists on self-funding often misses opportunities competitors capture with external finance; the 'strength' of debt-free is often a conservatism that leaves money on the table. Modern finance theory views optimal capital structure as a mix of debt and equity, not debt-free.
Case for a middle view. The right level of external finance depends on the firm's situation. For stable mature firms with strong cash flow, modest debt is often optimal — it levers the firm without undue risk. For growth firms, external finance is often necessary — the alternative is slower growth than the market allows. For firms in volatile industries or with uncertain cash flow, less debt is prudent — reliability matters more than cost efficiency. 'Reliance on external finance = weakness' is wrong as a universal rule; the right question is whether the firm uses external finance well.
Reasoned judgement. I disagree with the view. External finance is a tool that can be used wisely or badly; using it is not inherently a sign of weakness. The strongest statement is: the right level of external finance depends on the firm's industry, growth stage and cash flow stability. For stable mature firms, modest debt is often optimal; for growth firms, external finance is often necessary; for volatile firms, less is prudent. 'Reliance on external finance is weakness' misreads capital structure as a measure of operational health — in reality, the firms that use external finance well often grow faster and earn higher returns than those that insist on self-funding.