Case supporting the view. Standardised work design — same job for everyone in a role, same reward, same hours — is cheaper to administer and avoids the complexity of running many parallel arrangements. It is also fair in a specific sense: everyone in the same role is treated the same, which reduces the scope for grievance about who got what. For large workforces (manufacturing, retail, call centres) with highly standardised jobs, the standard approach often works well and the exceptions can be handled through formal policies.
Case against the view. Individuals differ substantially in what motivates them, what flexibility they need, and what kind of recognition lands with them. A one-size-fits-all approach systematically mis-fits the extremes: the employee who thrives on autonomy is frustrated by rigid procedures; the parent who needs flexibility leaves because the firm cannot accommodate school-run hours; the ambitious high-performer leaves because the standard progression is too slow. The 'average' employee the standard design serves may not exist as a majority — a workforce is often a distribution of very different people. Flexibility also pays commercial dividends: firms that can accommodate individuals attract and retain a wider pool, including the carers, older workers and non-traditional candidates that rigid firms cannot employ. 'Unfair to those not consulted' is also back-to-front: a standard arrangement that fits the average is unfair to those at the edges of the distribution who were never designed for.
Case for a middle view. The right practice is standardised defaults with individual accommodation. Most elements of the job (role, pay band, standard hours, holiday) are standard, so administration remains manageable. Specific elements (schedule, location, work format) are available for customisation on request, within rules that preserve fairness. This gives most employees the simplicity of a standard arrangement while allowing the minority who need flexibility to get it. 'Fairness' is preserved by the rules being the same (anyone can request flex), not by the arrangements being identical.
Reasoned judgement. I disagree with the view. Pure standardisation underserves the real diversity of a workforce and loses the firm the people whose needs do not fit the average; pure customisation is unmanageable and often does raise fairness concerns. The right answer is standardised defaults with explicit accommodation routes. The strongest statement is: design the job around a standard default for simplicity, but make flexibility routinely available to employees whose needs differ. 'Design around the average' is wrong because the average rarely describes a majority; 'design for every individual separately' is wrong because it is unmanageable. The honest answer is a flexible standard — fair in rule, varied in application.