Introduction (3-4): Cost information includes fixed, variable, direct, indirect and marginal costs; cost-based pricing adds a markup to this cost to arrive at a selling price. Alternative methods include market/competitor pricing, value-based pricing, penetration/skimming pricing, dynamic pricing. The question is whether cost alone is enough.
Case for cost information being sufficient (6-7):
(1) Guarantees margin. Any price above cost + minimum markup is profitable per unit — cost-based pricing never produces a loss on paper.
(2) Simple and transparent. Easy to apply; auditable; justifiable to customers who ask why the price is what it is.
(3) Protects against inflation. Automatic price rises when input costs rise — margin preserved without active decision.
(4) Works in low-information markets. Where competitor prices and demand curves are unknown, cost-plus is a reasonable starting point.
(5) Suits long-term supply contracts. Many B2B contracts are 'cost + fixed margin' — cost information is literally the entire basis.
Case against — other factors matter (6-7):
(1) Demand elasticity. A price-elastic product may need a lower price to sell at all; a price-inelastic product can bear a higher price than cost + markup suggests. Luxury handbags are priced far above cost because demand is inelastic.
(2) Competitor pricing. In commoditised markets (basic food, components), the market price is set by competitors — cost-plus leaves the firm uncompetitive if its cost is above average.
(3) Perceived value. Apple's iPhone is priced on perceived value, not cost — the markup is 60-70%, not 30%. Starbucks coffee at $5 is value, not cost.
(4) Strategic positioning. Penetration pricing (low to win share) or skimming (high to maximise early margin) are strategic choices unrelated to cost.
(5) Customer willingness-to-pay. B2B software firms price on customer value (saved time, labour, risk) not on cost — a product costing $500k to develop may sell for $50 000 per customer.
(6) Dynamic pricing. Airlines and Uber adjust prices by demand real-time — cost information is almost irrelevant.
Evaluation (4-5): Cost information is a floor but not a price:
(1) It is sufficient in commodity, B2B long-term contract and low-information settings where margin preservation is the main concern.
(2) It is insufficient in differentiated consumer markets, value-sensitive B2B markets, luxury segments, and dynamic markets.
(3) The sophisticated approach uses cost as the floor (never sell below variable cost; prefer never below full cost) and demand/competitor data as the ceiling.
(4) The best firms triangulate: cost + competitor + value.
Final judgement: cost information alone is sufficient only in a narrow set of commodity/contract settings; in modern consumer markets, pricing requires demand curves, competitor benchmarks, perceived value and strategic intent — cost sets the floor, but the actual price is a strategic choice. Apple, Starbucks, Rolex, Uber, Netflix — none price primarily on cost. [20]