Introduction (3-4): The traditional view saw operations as implementation of strategy — the 'how' after strategy's 'what'. The modern view, driven by Toyota, Zara, Amazon, considers operations as strategic in itself. The question is which view is correct.
Case for operations as strategic (6-7):
(1) Operational excellence is a competitive moat. Toyota's lean production, Amazon's logistics, Zara's fast fashion, Apple's supply chain — all strategic advantages derived from operations.
(2) Hard to copy. Operational capabilities take years of investment; copying competitor product / marketing is faster than copying operations.
(3) Operations enable or block strategy. A firm with weak operations can't execute cost leadership or quality differentiation regardless of marketing.
(4) Operations shape customer experience. Customers interact with operations (delivery, service, product reliability) more than with strategy or marketing.
(5) Operations is where cost / margin lives. Operational decisions determine most of the firm's cost structure.
(6) Modern operations strategy frameworks (Slack, Hayes, Skinner, Hill) all treat operations as strategic.
(7) The 'operations capability' concept. Firms with strong operational capability (Zara, Toyota, Apple, Amazon) consistently outperform those without.
Case against — operations as tactical / supporting (6-7):
(1) Strategy sets direction; operations executes. Strategy decides what to compete on; operations figures out how.
(2) Operations is often reactive. It responds to strategic choices (new products, new markets) rather than driving them.
(3) Senior leadership focus. CEO / board typically focus on strategy, marketing, finance — operations is handled below.
(4) Operations complexity. Operational decisions are tactical by volume — many day-to-day choices, few strategic ones.
(5) Strategic consultancies. McKinsey, BCG focus on strategy; separate operations consultancies suggest a split.
(6) Many firms outsource significant operations (Apple-Foxconn) and still win on strategy / brand.
(7) Operations can be commoditised. ERP systems, 3PL providers, cloud computing — many operations are now bought as commodity services.
Evaluation (4-5): Operations is both strategic and tactical, in different dimensions:
(1) At the macro level (operations strategy) — strategic. Choices about scale, location, make-vs-buy, process type, quality architecture shape competitive position.
(2) At the micro level (daily operations) — tactical. How to schedule next week, which supplier to call, how to run today's shift.
(3) Operational capability is strategic — the aggregate of operations choices creates (or doesn't) a competitive moat.
(4) The right senior investment is in operations strategy, not operations implementation.
(5) The best firms treat operations as strategic — CEO engages, operations have senior leadership (COO at the top table), investment is substantial.
(6) Weaker firms treat operations as support — CFO / COO roles are seen as back-office; operations under-funded relative to strategic ambition.
Final judgement: operations is genuinely strategic in modern business, though many firms still treat it as tactical:
(1) Operational excellence is a competitive moat.
(2) Operations decisions (scale, location, outsourcing, quality) have strategic consequences.
(3) Firms that treat operations as strategic (Toyota, Zara, Amazon, Apple) outperform.
(4) Firms that treat operations as tactical often struggle to execute strategic ambitions.
(5) The modern CEO / board must engage with operations — not just leave it to the COO.
'Operations is where strategy becomes reality. Firms that treat it as tactical pay the price in execution failures; firms that treat it as strategic build durable competitive advantage. The strategic view is empirically supported by the winners of the last 50 years.' [20]