Case supporting the view. Low utilisation reflects a mismatch between capacity and demand; the quickest way to fix the ratio is to cut capacity to match demand. Attempting to raise demand through marketing and pricing is uncertain — the marketing may not work, pricing cuts erode margin, and the firm may spend significant resources on recovery that does not come. Cutting capacity is painful but definite — the utilisation ratio improves immediately, fixed costs fall, unit cost comes down. For firms whose demand is structurally lower than the capacity was built for, cutting is the honest response.
Case against the view. Cutting capacity is permanent or near-permanent; the firm loses the ability to serve demand surges or recovery. If demand is cyclical and will return (recession, temporary disruption, product-specific issue), cutting capacity now means being short of capacity later when competitors who held on can serve the recovered demand. The marketing-and-pricing route — while uncertain — preserves the firm's capacity for future opportunities. Cutting capacity also damages the firm's relationships with staff, local community and (sometimes) retained customers who worry about ongoing viability. 'Always cut' overweights the current ratio and underweights the future.
Case for a middle view. The right response depends on whether the demand gap is temporary or structural. For temporary gaps (cyclical downturn, specific disruption, short-term customer loss), holding capacity while working on demand is often right — the cost of running under-utilised for 1-2 years is less than the cost of cutting and later rebuilding. For structural gaps (permanent market shift, product obsolescence, competitor permanent gain), cutting is often right — the capacity will not be used again. The intermediate approach — MOTHBALL (temporarily idle, with the option to restart) — captures some of the fixed-cost saving while preserving the option to resume if demand recovers.
Reasoned judgement. I partly disagree with the view. For structural demand loss, cutting is often right. For temporary demand loss, raising demand is often right. For genuine uncertainty, mothballing is often right. 'Always cut' overgeneralises; the right response depends on the cause and expected duration of the low utilisation. The strongest statement is: the right response to low utilisation depends on whether the demand gap is temporary or structural, which the firm should analyse before deciding. For structural gaps, cut; for temporary gaps, raise demand; for uncertain gaps, mothball to preserve the option. 'Always cut' is wrong because it treats all low-utilisation situations as if they were the same, which they are not.