Case supporting the view. Much of what HRM does is operational: processing payroll, administering contracts, running recruitment, handling grievances, ensuring legal compliance. These are necessary services that the business needs to function, but they are not strategic — they do not decide what the business will do, which markets to enter, which products to launch. Strategic decisions are made by the CEO, CFO and the board; HRM supports those decisions by delivering the people who execute them. On this reading, HRM sits alongside finance, legal and IT as a support function — essential but not the engine of strategy.
Case against the view. In many industries, people ARE the strategy. For professional-services firms (law, consulting, advertising), the quality of the workforce is the product being sold — a weak HRM function means a weak firm. For technology firms, the ability to attract and retain scarce engineers is often the binding constraint on growth, so HRM strategy and corporate strategy become inseparable. For firms whose service depends on front-line employees (hospitality, retail, healthcare), the employee experience directly produces the customer experience. In each case, HRM makes decisions that shape what the business can do — talent acquisition, culture, reward design, succession planning — that are indistinguishable from strategic decisions. Treating HRM as merely support in these businesses underestimates the function and leads to under-investment that constrains the firm's growth.
Case for a middle view. HRM is both. The operational half (payroll, compliance, process) is support work that should be done efficiently and discreetly. The strategic half (workforce planning, culture, reward strategy, succession, acquiring scarce skills) is a strategic activity on par with marketing or finance strategy. The split varies by industry and by firm — a 10-employee low-margin manufacturer has mostly operational HRM; a 10 000-employee technology or professional-services firm has mostly strategic HRM. The error is to apply one description to every HRM function regardless of context.
Reasoned judgement. The view is partly right: much of HRM's work is support activity, done quietly and consistently. It is wrong as a general description of the function: in people-intensive industries, HRM is a strategic function on par with product and marketing. The strongest statement is therefore: HRM is both a support function and a strategic function; the balance depends on how much the firm's competitive position depends on its people. For firms where people are the product or the binding constraint on growth, HRM is strategic and should sit at the top table; for firms where people are a cost of standardised production, HRM is largely support. The view is right about some firms and wrong about others, and treating it as universal misdirects investment in the HRM function.