Case supporting the view. Working capital is cash tied up in operations — inventory, receivables, cash balance — none of which earn direct return. Minimising working capital frees cash for investment in things that DO earn return (new products, equipment, acquisitions, debt reduction). Modern inventory-management (JIT, lean) and receivable-management (electronic payments, strict credit control) have made significantly lower working-capital levels achievable than firms held historically. Amazon famously operates with NEGATIVE working capital (customers pay before Amazon pays suppliers), using the float as a free source of financing. Minimising working capital is a legitimate commercial objective that strengthens the balance sheet.
Case against the view. Minimum working capital eliminates the buffers that absorb variability. Low inventory means stock-out risk when supply or demand surges; tight receivables risk customer relationships; minimum cash leaves no cushion for unexpected costs. The 2020-22 supply-chain crisis hit lean firms harder than buffer-heavy firms. Firms that chase minimum working capital for cash efficiency can end up fragile — fine in stable conditions, catastrophic in disruption. The optimum level of working capital is NOT the minimum; it is the level that balances cash efficiency against operational resilience.
Case for a middle view. The right working-capital level depends on the firm's context — stable supply chain supports lower working capital; volatile supply demands more; firms in growth phase often need more working capital than mature firms; firms with strong customer-payment discipline can run tighter than firms with chronic late payers. 'Always minimise' is too simple; 'optimise for the firm's context' is the right rule.
Reasoned judgement. I partly disagree with the view. Working-capital efficiency matters and tight management is good practice — but 'always minimise' eliminates buffers that are strategically valuable, particularly in volatile supply or demand environments. The strongest statement is: working-capital management should target the OPTIMUM level for the firm's context — enough buffer to absorb variability and shocks, not so much that cash is tied up unnecessarily. 'Minimise' is wrong because it ignores the operational resilience function of working capital; 'optimise for the specific firm and environment' is right. The 2020-22 supply-chain crisis has pushed many firms to accept higher working-capital levels for resilience; this is a reasonable response, not a failure of cash discipline.