Case supporting the view. SMART provides the discipline most objective-setting fails on: it forces objectives to be specific (not vague), measurable (not aspirational), achievable (not fantasy), relevant (not peripheral), and time-bound (not open-ended). Each of the five criteria blocks a common failure mode of objective-setting. An objective that passes all five tests can actually be used — managers can plan against it, progress can be measured, success can be judged. In this sense, SMART is a necessary minimum standard for a workable corporate objective.
Case against the view. SMART is necessary but not sufficient. First, SMART says nothing about whether the objective is the right one — a SMART objective to maximise short-run profit by cutting R&D and training is still a bad objective. Second, SMART can create goal-displacement: once a measurable target exists, managers optimise the number rather than the underlying purpose (schools teach to the test; call centres hit the call-time target by ending calls badly; sales teams book the quarter-end deal that will unwind next quarter). This is sometimes called 'what gets measured gets managed' — and it can mean the measurable objective displaces the unmeasured but important ones (quality, relationships, long-run reputation). Third, SMART does not address alignment with mission, ethics or stakeholder interests — those have to come from somewhere else (mission statement, corporate values, stakeholder analysis). Fourth, SMART favours short-term measurable things over long-term unmeasurable ones, which can bias decisions toward quick wins and against patient investment.
Case for a middle view. Modern practice often supplements SMART with additional frameworks: objectives-and-key-results (OKRs) pair ambitious qualitative objectives with measurable key results; balanced scorecard forces objectives across financial, customer, process and learning dimensions; triple bottom line adds social and environmental dimensions. The common thread is: SMART at the detailed level, something broader at the strategic level. SMART is a tool for writing good objectives; it does not tell you which objectives to write.
Reasoned judgement. The view is substantially overstated. SMART is the right test for any individual objective, but it is not enough on its own: businesses also need a mission or purpose to decide which objectives are worth setting, a stakeholder/ethics check to constrain the pursuit, and a mechanism to prevent goal-displacement where measurable targets crowd out unmeasured but important goals. The strongest statement is therefore: SMART is the right quality standard for individual objectives, but modern business objective-setting also needs a broader framework (mission, OKRs, balanced scorecard, stakeholder review) to decide what to measure and to guard against the firm optimising the wrong thing. SMART is a tool, not a complete system.