Case for internal recruitment. Internal candidates are a known quantity — their performance, strengths, weaknesses, and fit with the culture have been observable for months or years. This reduces hiring risk significantly, saves the cost of a failed appointment, and shortens time-to-productivity (an internal hire already knows the business). Promoting from within also motivates the rest of the workforce by signalling that the firm offers career progression; the reverse — always hiring senior roles externally — tells ambitious employees that staying leads nowhere, and they leave for firms that will promote them.
Case against — external recruitment brings things internal cannot. External hires bring fresh perspectives the current team does not have: new ways of thinking, new techniques learned at other firms, new networks. In fast-changing industries, the biggest cost of exclusively internal hiring is intellectual stagnation — the firm keeps hiring people who think like the people already there. External hires also fill specific skill gaps the internal pool cannot: a firm entering a new country typically needs leadership with that country's experience; a firm adopting new technology typically needs people with hands-on experience of it elsewhere. In both cases, waiting to develop these skills internally takes years the firm does not have. Finally, external hires break internal politics — a new leader with no history can make unpopular changes an insider could not.
Case for a middle view. The right practice is mostly internal, selectively external. Firms that promote internally wherever possible build loyal, committed senior teams; firms that hire externally selectively bring in the fresh perspectives and specific skills internal pipelines cannot produce. The split varies by firm and role: perhaps 70-80% internal across most senior roles, with specific external hires where new skills, new markets or culture change require them. A pure internal policy risks stagnation; a pure external policy destroys internal motivation and loses firm-specific knowledge.
Reasoned judgement. I partly disagree with the view. 'Always' is too strong — some roles genuinely benefit from external perspective, and firms that commit to internal-only often find themselves unable to adapt to major change. But the view is right in direction: internal should be the DEFAULT, with external the exception when the specific role or circumstance calls for it. The strongest statement is: prefer internal recruitment for most senior roles, but preserve the ability to hire externally where new skills, new markets or culture change require it. 'Always' overstates the case; 'preferably' is right.