Introduction (3-4): In a multi-product firm, full costing allocates all costs — direct and apportioned indirect — to each product line, producing a full cost per unit. Multi-product manufacturers face the challenge that most overhead (rent, utilities, management, equipment depreciation) is shared across lines and must be apportioned by some rule (output volume, machine hours, labour hours, floor area).
Strengths (6-7):
(1) Mandatory for financial reporting. IFRS and GAAP require inventory valued at full cost — the firm cannot avoid it.
(2) Long-run strategic discipline. Each product must cover its full cost — forces management to review product lines that are chronically below full-cost.
(3) Cost-plus pricing basis. Many B2B contracts (defence, utilities, government procurement) require pricing at full cost + markup — ambulance, hospital, military contracts.
(4) Transfer pricing fairness. Full-cost transfers between divisions prevent one division from passing low-margin work to another and understating its own profit.
(5) Comparable benchmark. Full cost per unit is the number that competitors publish and analysts compare.
(6) Prevents strategic drift. Avoids 'everything is contributing but nothing is making a long-run profit' — a particular risk in service businesses.
Weaknesses (6-7):
(1) Arbitrary apportionment of indirect costs. Different allocation bases (floor area, output, machine hours) give different product-level costs — the method itself drives apparent profitability.
(2) Hides contribution and leads to wrong tactical decisions. Products that are contributing to overhead look 'loss-making' and are wrongly discontinued (death spiral).
(3) Full cost changes with volume. FC/unit falls as output rises; a product's apparent cost is sensitive to the chosen volume assumption.
(4) Discourages positive-contribution special orders. Any price below full cost looks loss-making; opportunities are missed.
(5) Encourages 'cost shifting'. Clever managers manipulate apportionment to shift overhead onto other products — political games distort real cost picture.
(6) Activity-based costing (ABC) partly fixes it but is expensive to implement and still requires judgement on cost drivers.
Evaluation (4-5): Full costing is unavoidable (financial reporting) and useful for long-run strategic and contract-pricing decisions — but dangerous when used for short-run tactical decisions (special orders, discontinuation, make-vs-buy):
(1) In a multi-product firm with heterogeneous products and heavy overheads, apportionment problems are especially acute — different bases will favour different products.
(2) Activity-based costing is the modern response — assign overhead by actual cost driver (not arbitrary volume), giving more accurate product cost.
(3) The best practice is to use full costing for annual accounts and long-run product review, contribution costing for all short-run tactical decisions, and ABC for strategic reviews where overhead apportionment is material.
Final judgement: full costing is a necessary tool with real strengths for strategic and reporting purposes, but has dangerous weaknesses when applied uncritically to tactical decisions. The sophisticated multi-product firm uses full costing and contribution costing and ABC — each in its proper domain. Treating full costing as the single truth, or dropping it entirely, both lead to poor decisions. [20]