Case supporting the view. Employment law in developed economies has grown significantly over 30 years — unfair-dismissal rights, redundancy consultation requirements, discrimination law, maternity rights, flexible-working rights, auto-enrolment pensions. Each requirement imposes administrative burden and procedural steps. The cost of a wrong-foot — a flawed dismissal, a missed consultation, a discrimination finding — runs into tens or hundreds of thousands and generates reputational damage. In some countries, labour law makes it so expensive to end an employment relationship that firms hesitate to hire in the first place, substituting contractors or temporary staff; the policy intended to protect employees instead moves work out of standard employment altogether. For a growing business trying to adjust its workforce as it experiments with new products and markets, this friction is real.
Case against the view. The alternative — easy dismissal, low protection — produces worse outcomes for both sides. Employees in low-protection systems invest less in firm-specific skills (why learn things that make you harder to replace if you can be dismissed at will?), accept lower wages (because the risk of job loss is higher), and are more likely to leave at the first better offer. Firms get a less committed, less skilled workforce in exchange for easier dismissal. The law also protects against GENUINE abuses — discrimination, retaliatory dismissal, dismissal for raising safety concerns — which are not hypothetical and would be routine in the absence of protection. Procedural requirements (investigation, warning, right of appeal) often improve the dismissal decision itself, catching misunderstandings before they become legal problems. Many well-run firms welcome the discipline the law imposes on their managers.
Case for a middle view. The right balance differs by country and by time. Protection levels in some European countries are high and may indeed discourage hiring at the margin; protection levels in some others are very low and leave employees vulnerable to arbitrary dismissal. The empirical research on 'does employment law reduce employment' is genuinely mixed — the strongest findings suggest protection effects are second-order to broader economic forces (demand, growth, education) rather than the dominant factor the view implies. Firms adapt: those operating in high-protection systems invest more in getting hiring right first time and in managing performance proactively, which is often better practice than the fire-at-will alternative.
Reasoned judgement. I partly disagree with the view. Employment law adds real procedural cost and can at the margin discourage hiring, so the view is not without foundation. But the alternative — minimal protection — produces outcomes that are usually worse for both sides, and most well-run modern businesses operate successfully within the current legal framework by investing in good hiring and proactive performance management. The claim that employment law makes it 'difficult to run a modern business' is overstated — difficult to run a BADLY-managed business, perhaps; well-run firms adapt without major cost. The strongest statement is: modern employment law imposes real procedural burden, which is a legitimate concern at the extremes of protection, but it also produces more considered management decisions and a more committed workforce. The claim that it is a serious obstacle to running a modern business is defensible only in the most heavily-protected jurisdictions and only for firms unwilling to invest in proper hiring and performance management.