Case supporting the view. As automation homogenises production in many categories (same automated process, same product, same price), the human-made alternative becomes rarer and more differentiated. Customers increasingly value authenticity, craft, personal attention and the specific skill of a human maker; small premium brands that preserve labour-intensive production often command meaningful price premiums over mass-produced alternatives. The 'crafts' category in food, drink, clothing, cosmetics and even technology (hand-assembled audio equipment, bespoke software) has grown precisely because automation has made mass production ubiquitous, which raises the scarcity value of the hand-made. Deliberately maintaining labour-intensive production is a positioning strategy — not a failure to automate, but a choice that creates distinctive value.
Case against the view. Labour-intensive production carries real cost disadvantages — higher unit cost, lower volume, higher wage-inflation exposure. The firm defending a labour-intensive position must earn a sufficient price premium to cover these costs; many categories do not support the premium at the volumes the firm needs. Automated competitors can match product quality in many categories (though not all), and the price gap sometimes exceeds the premium customers will pay for 'hand-made'. The labour-intensive position is defensible only in categories where the human element has unique value AND customers are willing to pay for it; in categories where automated production meets customer needs at lower cost, labour-intensive is a losing position regardless of positioning.
Case for a middle view. Labour-intensive is a defensible competitive position in SOME categories and SOME segments — specifically where the human element adds value customers can perceive and pay for, and where the firm can earn a premium large enough to cover the cost disadvantage. In other categories, labour-intensive is a legacy position that automated competitors will eventually erode regardless of how it is positioned. The claim is right about specific contexts and wrong as a general proposition.
Reasoned judgement. I partly agree with the view. In the right categories (craft, premium food/drink, personal services, hand-made goods), labour-intensive production is a defensible and often premium position worth maintaining. In the wrong categories (standardised commodity production, services where human and machine deliver equivalent outcomes), labour-intensive is a legacy position that will erode. The strongest statement is: labour-intensive is a defensible competitive position where the human element adds perceivable value and customers pay a premium that covers the cost disadvantage. Firms in these categories should defend the position actively — invest in the craft, the brand, the story. Firms in categories where human and machine produce equivalent outcomes face eroding margins and should automate while preserving what human element remains valuable. 'Worth defending' is right for the first group and wrong for the second.