Introduction (3-4): Internal finance (retained profit, sale of assets, working-capital tightening) is often cited as the first-choice source because it has no interest, no dilution and no external control. External finance (bank loans, debentures, share issues) comes with interest, gearing or dilution. The 'pecking-order theory' says firms should use internal first, then debt, then equity last.
Case for internal being preferable (6-7):
(1) No interest or principal repayment — pure cost advantage over debt; nothing goes out the door.
(2) No dilution of ownership — no new shareholders, no loss of voting control.
(3) Signal of financial strength — using retained profit signals the firm is profitable; using lots of external finance signals it is not.
(4) Flexibility — no covenants, no loan maturity date, no VC exit horizon.
(5) Faster — a board decision to retain profit is immediate; a loan application or share issue takes weeks or months.
Case against — external has merits (6-7):
(1) Scale limitation: retained profit is bounded by last year's profits. A $50m factory investment cannot be funded by a firm that retains $5m p.a. — external finance is the only route for discontinuous growth.
(2) Opportunity cost: using retained profit means not paying dividends or not investing in a different project — the money isn't 'free', it has an opportunity cost.
(3) Debt is tax-deductible: in profitable firms, debt interest reduces the tax bill and so the effective cost of debt can be lower than the opportunity cost of equity.
(4) Timing: opportunities don't wait for retained profit to accumulate — a competitor's distressed sale, a market opening, a technology shift often requires lumpy external finance now.
(5) Shareholder preference: if the firm has excess cash, shareholders may actually prefer dividends (returning cash) over retaining profit for marginal projects — tying up cash internally destroys value when the project IRR is below the cost of capital.
Evaluation (4-5): Internal finance is preferable in the sense of a default (pecking order) but is not always optimal. The right source depends on three factors:
(1) Size of finance needed vs. internal availability: if the project is beyond retained profit, external finance is unavoidable.
(2) Cost of capital: if debt is cheap and tax-deductible, it may beat the opportunity cost of retained profit.
(3) Timing and strategic opportunity: fast-moving opportunities force external finance regardless of pecking order.
Final judgement: internal finance is preferable as a first port of call for small, planned expansion in a profitable firm, but is often insufficient and sometimes value-destroying for larger, strategic investments. The best firms use a mix — retained profit for routine, external finance for large or urgent projects — rather than treating either as universally preferable. [20]