Introduction (3-4): The cheapest source of finance is the one with the lowest interest rate (debt) or the lowest required return (equity) after tax. The question is whether cost should dominate the selection — and if not, what else should.
Case for 'yes, cheapest is best' (6-7):
(1) Direct impact on profit. Interest and dividends are real cash outflows that reduce retained profit — a 1-pp lower rate on $10m is $100k p.a. of extra profit.
(2) Investment appraisal pivots on cost of capital. Projects that are NPV-negative at 10% can become NPV-positive at 7% — cheap finance expands the feasible investment set.
(3) Compound effect. Even small rate differences compound to large absolute amounts over 10-20 year horizons.
(4) Discipline. Expensive sources signal higher risk; sticking to cheap sources is a form of risk management.
(5) Theoretically consistent. Finance theory (Modigliani-Miller with taxes) says firms maximise value by minimising the weighted cost of capital.
Case against — cheapest is not always best (6-7):
(1) Hidden costs — covenants, inflexibility, repayment pressure. A cheap loan may ban dividends, further borrowing, or require asset-sale restrictions — these indirect costs can dwarf the interest saving.
(2) Short vs. long term. A cheap overdraft used to fund a long-term asset creates refinancing risk — the apparent saving is wiped out when the facility is withdrawn mid-project.
(3) Hidden strings. VC may be 'cheaper' in nominal interest terms but comes with veto rights and exit pressure that constrain strategy.
(4) Control and dilution. A cheap share issue dilutes founders' upside permanently — a slightly more expensive loan may be worth paying for.
(5) Fit with risk profile. A cheap variable-rate loan is a false economy for a firm with volatile cash flows — the firm needs the predictability of a fixed-rate alternative.
(6) Access. The cheapest-advertised source may not be available to the firm anyway; chasing it wastes management time.
Evaluation (4-5): The right answer depends on what the firm actually values:
(1) For a cash-rich, mature firm comparing two accessible debt options, cheapest-is-best is usually correct.
(2) For a founder-led firm valuing control, the cheapest source (equity) is often not best — debt may be worth paying more for.
(3) For a firm with volatile cash flows, fixed-rate (more expensive) debt is worth the premium.
(4) For a firm facing a strategic opportunity window, speed-to-close may dominate cost.
Final judgement: cost should be weighted with other criteria — availability, control, flexibility, timing, risk — not treated as the single criterion. The firms that have failed most dramatically (Carillion, Lehman, Thomas Cook) all chose the cheapest-looking source and ignored the fit with their asset and cash-flow profile. The sophisticated answer: cheapest is a starting point for comparison, not the end of it. [20]