Students who did well at IGCSE Literature often arrive at A Level doing exactly what earned them the grade, and find it earns less.

The reason is a fifth assessment objective that does not exist at IGCSE, is worth nothing in your first year, and then carries a fifth of the final grade.

Four objectives become five

Cambridge publishes both, and the comparison is unusually clean.

IGCSE Literature in English 0475 has four assessment objectives, each worth 25%:

• AO1 — show detailed knowledge of the content of literary texts, supported by reference to the text.
• AO2 — understand meanings of literary texts and their contexts, and explore texts beyond surface meanings.
• AO3 — recognise and appreciate ways in which writers use language, structure and form to create and shape meanings and effects.
• AO4 — communicate a sensitive and informed personal response.

A Level Literature in English 9695 has five, each worth 20% at A Level:

• AO1 Knowledge and understanding.
• AO2 Analysis — ways writers’ choices of language, form and structure shape meanings and effects.
• AO3 Personal response — produce informed independent opinions and interpretations.
• AO4 Communication — a relevant, structured and supported response.
• AO5 Evaluation of opinion — discuss and evaluate varying opinions and interpretations of literary texts.

The first four map onto what you already did. AO5 has no IGCSE equivalent at all.

What AO5 actually asks for

At IGCSE, the personal response objective asks you to respond to the text. Your reading, supported by evidence.

AO5 asks you to respond to readings of the text. Somebody argues this play is about ambition; somebody else argues it is about legitimacy. Which reading is better supported, where does each one strain, and what does the text do that neither fully accounts for?

That is a different intellectual move. It requires holding two interpretations at once and judging between them, rather than building and defending your own.

And it arrives late. AO5 is worth 0% at AS Level and 20% at A Level, so if your school runs a staged route, the skill carrying a fifth of your final grade is not assessed in the year you are being assessed. A comfortable AS result tells you how you handle four objectives out of five.

The entry condition nobody mentions

The 9695 syllabus recommends a course in English equivalent to IGCSE or O Level, and adds a second condition: a level of English equivalent to first language English at IGCSE.

That is a specific bar. A student who took English as a Second Language is starting below the standard the course is written for, and it is not something anyone raises in September.

It is not a barrier so much as a piece of information. If that describes you, the reading and writing load is the thing to build deliberately over the summer rather than assume.

The unseen problem

One more structural difference. Paper 2 in 9695 is Prose and Unseen, so part of the assessment is literary material you have never read.

You cannot revise for that in the ordinary sense. There is no text to know. What is being tested is whether you can do to an unfamiliar passage what you have learned to do to a familiar one: notice how language, form and structure are working, and say something defensible about the effect.

Which means preparation is practice rather than coverage. Reading more set texts does not help. Reading unfamiliar things closely does.

Personal response changes meaning too

AO3 exists at both levels under similar names, which disguises a real shift in what it asks.

At IGCSE, AO4 asks you to communicate a sensitive and informed personal response. The emphasis falls on sensitivity: showing you have understood and felt the text, supported by reference to it.

At A Level, AO3 asks you to produce informed independent opinions and interpretations. The word doing the work is independent. It is not enough to respond appropriately; the reading has to be recognisably yours, and defensible as one interpretation among several possible ones.

That is a step toward AO5 rather than a separate thing. First you form a reading you can defend, then you evaluate it against other people’s. Students who write beautifully but always agree with the obvious interpretation tend to score well at IGCSE and plateau at A Level.

What to do before September

Four things, and only one of them involves reading a novel.

Read criticism, not more fiction. Find two critics who disagree about a text you already know. Work out where the disagreement actually is, and which reading the text supports better. That is AO5 practice and it is the only objective you cannot build any other way.

Practise on unseen passages. Take a poem or a page of prose you have never read. Twenty minutes: what is the writer doing with language, form and structure, and to what effect. Write it as a paragraph, not notes.

Write to a length. A Level answers are longer than IGCSE ones and the argument has to hold across the distance. Practise sustaining one line of reasoning for eight hundred words without repeating yourself.

Read the command words table in the syllabus, so you know what Discuss, Comment on and Evaluate each require in Cambridge’s own terms.

The AS year hides the change

Here is the detail that makes this transition genuinely deceptive, and it is worth knowing in September rather than a year later.

At AS Level, 9695 weights AO1 to AO4 at 25% each and AO5 at 0%.

Compare that with IGCSE 0475: four objectives, 25% each.

The AS year is weighted identically to the IGCSE you just finished. Same four objectives, same equal split, no evaluation of opinion anywhere in it.

So a student who does well in Year 12 receives a genuine, accurate signal about four fifths of the A Level and no signal at all about the fifth. Then in Year 13 the weightings redistribute to 20% each and a completely new objective arrives carrying as much as any other.

That is why “I was fine at AS” is a weaker predictor in Literature than in most subjects, and why building the AO5 habit early is worth doing even though nothing in your first year examines it.

What carries over, and what does not

Your IGCSE work is not wasted. Close reading, quotation selection, writing about form and structure: AO1 to AO4 at A Level are recognisably the same family of skills, done at greater length and to a higher standard.

What does not carry over is the habit of treating your own reading as the destination. At IGCSE that was the top of the mark scheme. At A Level it is four fifths of it, and the last fifth asks what you make of everyone else’s.

Students who struggle in the first term are usually doing excellent IGCSE work. The problem is not quality. It is that one whole objective is missing from it.

Where to start

Open the 9695 syllabus, read the five assessment objectives and their weightings, and notice which one you have never been asked for. Then go and find two people arguing about a book.

For how Literature compares with other subjects in this transition, which A Level subjects have the biggest jump sets its five-objective spread against the sciences and Economics. The gap between IGCSE and A Levels covers why the window before September exists at all, and Tutopiya’s A Level Preparation programme is built for that window.

Frequently asked questions

What does A Level English Literature assume you can already do? +

Cambridge Literature in English 9695 recommends a course in English equivalent to IGCSE or O Level, and separately a level of English equivalent to first language English at IGCSE. That second condition is a real bar for students who took English as a Second Language.

What is the difference between IGCSE and A Level English Literature? +

IGCSE Literature in English 0475 has four assessment objectives at 25% each. A Level 9695 has five at 20% each, and the extra one is evaluation of opinion: discussing and evaluating varying interpretations of a text. It does not exist at IGCSE and is worth nothing at AS Level.

What is AO5 in A Level English Literature? +

Evaluation of opinion — discussing and evaluating varying opinions and interpretations of literary texts. It is worth 0% at AS Level and 20% at A Level, so a fifth of the final grade rests on a skill that is not assessed at all in your first year.

How do I prepare for A Level English Literature over the summer? +

Read criticism rather than more novels. Find two critics who disagree about a text you know and work out which reading is better supported and why. That is the shape of AO5, and it is the one objective with no equivalent anywhere in your IGCSE course.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial