Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/42 October/November 2025 (Paper 4 Depth Study): Question-by-Question Guide
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/42 October/November 2025 (Paper 4 Depth Study): Question-by-Question Guide

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 12 min read
Updated

Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/42 is the October/November 2025 Paper 4 (Depth Study), variant 2. It is an A Level component that lasts 1 hour 45 minutes and is worth 60 marks. You answer two of twelve 30-mark essays, both from one section: European history in the interwar years, the USA 1944–92, or international history 1945–92. Each essay is marked twice, for knowledge (AO1) and for analysis and judgement (AO2). This guide goes through the paper question by question and shows what the official mark scheme expected. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

For the newest series of the same paper, see 9489 Paper 42 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.

For an overview of all four 9489 papers from this series, see A Level History 9489 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme.

9489/42 at a glance

Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9489/42/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9489_w25_qp_42 and the mark scheme file is 9489_w25_ms_42.

Rubric: answer two questions from one section only.

QuestionSectionTopicMarks
1A: European history in the interwar years, 1919–41Did Mussolini’s foreign policy, 1922–41, have little chance of achieving its aims?30
2AThe reasons for Stalin’s industrialisation programme30
3AHow far German society changed, 1933–4130
4AReasons for the change in British living standards in the 1920s and 1930s30
5B: The USA, 1944–92Why the Democrats failed to defeat Eisenhower in the 1950s30
6BReasons for opposition to the counter-culture in the 1960s and 1970s30
7BHow far US living standards changed in the 1980s and early 1990s30
8BWas the Marshall Plan “a generous and idealistic response to the needs of Europe”?30
9C: International history, 1945–92The impact of the Korean War on US-Soviet relations30
10CWas humiliation of the US the main outcome of the Vietnam War?30
11CHow far social divisions challenged newly independent African nations, 1950–9230
12CThe impact of Soviet policies in the Middle East during the Cold War30
Total answered (two questions)60

Question-by-question walkthrough

How every essay is marked

Every question uses the same two grids, each out of 15, and the two marks are added.

AO2, analysis and judgement (15 marks):

  • Level 1 (1–3): addresses the topic but not the question, with no analysis, argument or relevant judgement.
  • Level 2 (4–6): some understanding but descriptive; criteria may be implicit; an assertion rather than a judgement.
  • Level 3 (7–9): some analysis and attempts at criteria, but the argument lacks balance, coherence and precision, and the judgement is weakly substantiated.
  • Level 4 (10–12): valid criteria, mostly analytical though uneven, an attempt at balance, and a supported judgement with some evaluations only partly substantiated.
  • Level 5 (13–15): valid, wide-ranging criteria, consistent analysis, a focused, balanced argument with a sustained line of reasoning, and a clear, sustained judgement.

AO1, supporting knowledge (15 marks): five levels, from limited, vague knowledge (1–3), through narrative not linked to the argument (4–6) and adequate detail over a narrow range (7–9), to a good range that is mostly precise though uneven in depth (10–12) and a high level of carefully selected, wide-ranging, precise detail fully focused on the argument (13–15).

“Criteria” are the yardsticks you use to answer the question, for example what Mussolini’s aims were before you judge whether they were achievable.

Section A: European history in the interwar years, 1919–41

Question 1: Mussolini’s foreign policy, 1922–41 (30 marks) Set out the aims first: making Italy a great power, dominating the Mediterranean, expanding the African empire, a Balkan sphere of influence, and using foreign success for propaganda at home. Evidence of success: Corfu, Fiume and Albania, the conquest of Abyssinia, support for the Nationalists in Spain, and more attention from Britain and France in the 1930s, including Munich. Evidence of limits: a very small role at Locarno, the Kellogg-Briand Pact, and dependence on Germany through the Rome-Berlin Axis (1936) and the Anti-Comintern Pact. The mark scheme’s suggested conclusion is that some aims were achievable, but dominating the Mediterranean and Balkans, expanding the empire and holding the balance between Britain, France and Germany were too ambitious. Italy could dominate smaller nations, not larger ones or the League.

Question 2: reasons for Stalin’s industrialisation (30 marks)

  • Military: fear of attack and an industrial base too weak to supply a war against an industrialised enemy; the war scare of the late 1920s; and self-sufficiency, so the USSR did not rely on potential enemies.
  • Economic: improving living standards through consumer goods and modern cities.
  • Political: a larger, stronger proletariat moving towards socialism; with collectivisation, a way to strike at class enemies such as Nepmen and kulaks; and Stalin’s wish to present himself as Lenin’s worthy successor and equal. Conclude on the relative significance of each reason.

Question 3: how far German society changed, 1933–41 (30 marks)

  • Change: limited opposition suggesting support; propaganda and the Hitler cult; indoctrination of the young through schools and youth groups; church co-operation; Beauty of Labour and Strength through Joy; contributions to Winterhilfe and the Eintopf scheme; and the persecution of those deemed outside society.
  • Limits: the impact of schemes is hard to assess; lack of opposition may have been passive or forced by the police state; youth and church opposition; religion stayed important to millions; the class structure was not disturbed; and charity was often a matter of pressure to conform.
  • Judgement: acceptance varied by class, age, gender, religion and place, which itself could show Hitler’s aims failed, and transforming society in a short period is very hard.

Question 4: British living standards in the 1920s and 1930s (30 marks) Most people’s living standards rose because prices, especially food, fell faster than wages: the real cost of living fell by more than a third between 1920 and 1938, and a 1936 study found the average diet better than before 1914, though it varied widely by class (evacuation in the Second World War exposed poor working-class diets). Infant mortality had halved from 1900 levels by 1922, and tuberculosis and typhoid killed far fewer. Regions dependent on shipbuilding, coal, steel and textiles (Clydeside, Northumberland, Durham, Lancashire, South Wales) fared worse than London and the West Midlands with newer industries, and the Depression brought mass unemployment. Housing Acts led to four million new homes, though many still lived in slums. Reasons could relate to government policy, external economic factors or the First World War; the suggested conclusion is real improvement that depended heavily on region.

Section B: The history of the USA, 1944–92

Question 5: why the Democrats failed to beat Eisenhower (30 marks) The focus should be on Democrat failures (divisions, weak campaigning, ideas that seemed too radical) set against Eisenhower’s appeal and prosperity. In 1952: Truman was unpopular over firing MacArthur and the Korean stalemate; Stevenson was able but uninspiring and seemed aloof; Eisenhower stood above party with his war record; Nixon was known for anti-communism and the Hiss case; the Democrats were slow to use TV against “I like Ike”; Truman attacked Eisenhower personally; and Eisenhower campaigned on K1C2 (Korea, Communism, Corruption), winning 55% of the popular vote. In 1956: the election was fought on his record of peace and prosperity; Truman pushed Harriman over Stevenson; Stevenson’s test ban proposal, once endorsed by the USSR, looked “soft on Communism”; Suez and Hungary were hard to criticise; more African Americans voted Republican; and Eisenhower rose to 58%.

Question 6: opposition to the counter-culture (30 marks) The counter-culture was a mainly youth, non-violent movement against establishment values, protesting about racial discrimination, poverty, environmental damage and discrimination against minorities. Opposition came from its freer sexual attitudes clashing with religious and moral beliefs, its challenge to suburban consumerism, its link to civil rights (alienating segregationists), its challenge to family discipline and its link with anti-Vietnam protest, which looked anti-American. The wider context produced a threatened “silent majority”. Lifestyle itself (hippy culture, communes, rock music, drugs, long hair as a rejection of authority) was a challenge to norms.

Question 7: US living standards in the 1980s and early 1990s (30 marks) After the recessions of 1980 and 1981–82, family income grew through most of the 1980s, but unevenly: the rich got richer and the poor poorer, and the young, unemployed and less educated were left behind. Reagan’s tax reforms favoured the better off, and lower earners saw wage stagnation as union power declined. Consumption changed most: credit cards, home electronics and computing, better cars and more holidays, along with rising consumer debt and cheaper borrowing in the later 1980s. Globalisation and outsourcing hit manufacturing jobs, technology brought gains and losses, urban–rural gaps widened, housing costs rose, and many families needed two earners.

Question 8: the Marshall Plan (30 marks)

  • For the view: it was presented as generous, helping neighbours rebuild a Europe of destroyed infrastructure, homelessness, food shortages and low production, and the $13 billion of aid had real humanitarian results.
  • Against: it served strategic aims, filling a power vacuum, stopping hardship leading to communism, and putting economic power behind containment (aid was offered to the East knowing Stalin would refuse) and possibly US hegemony; and it served economic aims, boosting European markets for US goods and preventing a return to pre-war protectionism. Soviet propaganda called it “dollar diplomacy”.

Section C: International history, 1945–92

Question 9: the Korean War and US-Soviet relations (30 marks) The key impact could be the spread of the Cold War to Asia and new alliances (a bilateral treaty with South Korea, the 1951 peace treaty with Japan, ANZUS 1951, SEATO 1954 and the Baghdad Pact 1955), which deepened Soviet fears of encirclement. Other impacts: NATO and the Sino-Soviet alliance were strengthened, West Germany joined NATO in 1955 and the Warsaw Pact followed; containment hardened into total opposition to communism and the domino theory shaped policy for 20 years; the US backed dictators such as Syngman Rhee while the USSR aided Egypt and Syria; a pattern of limited proxy wars and mutual restraint was set; and NSC-68 drove US remilitarisation, later modified by Eisenhower’s “New Look”.

Question 10: was humiliation the main outcome of the Vietnam War? (30 marks)

  • Humiliation: the US failed to contain communism, at great human and financial cost, with domestic strife, a tarnished image and a misjudged Vietnamese will for self-determination. The draft was replaced by a volunteer force, the voting age was lowered to 18, the War Powers Act limited presidents, the economy and morale suffered, Americans grew suspicious of government and veterans faced hostility and the effects of Agent Orange.
  • Other outcomes: US superpower status survived and communism did not spread across south-east Asia; the communist victory and reunification after the fall of Saigon in 1975; and Vietnam’s own recovery, with the exodus of 1975 and the “boat people” of 1978, ravaged land, up to two million civilian and 1.3 million military deaths, free-market reform in 1986 and restored relations with the US in the 1990s.

Question 11: social divisions in newly independent African nations (30 marks) New states kept European-drawn borders containing many ethnic groups (Nigeria had 160), with divisions of language and religion worsened by colonial policies that favoured some groups, so leaders had to build national identity. Other challenges: the rich urban and poor rural divide; youth unemployment and slums; rapid population growth and unplanned migration to cities such as Lagos, Accra, Abidjan, Freetown and Dakar; low education rates; undeveloped infrastructure and economies that were not viable; diseases such as malaria and yellow fever; drought in the Sahel from the late 1960s; and inexperienced governments, coups and civil wars such as Mozambique’s.

Question 12: Soviet policies in the Middle East (30 marks)

  • Success, to the early 1970s: the USSR used anti-American and anti-Israeli feeling, focusing on Egypt and Syria; it gave Nasser military support in the 1956 Suez Crisis; it gained naval and air bases giving access to the Mediterranean; and it increased military aid after the Six-Day War.
  • Limits and failure: arms for influence was its only method; communism had no real ideological appeal; Sadat expelled 20,000 Soviet advisers in 1972; the USSR supplied weapons for the Yom Kippur War reluctantly; Egypt broke the 1971 friendship treaty in 1976, ending Soviet naval access; the US, as Israel’s sole guarantor, became the Arab world’s arbiter after Camp David; the invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 damaged Soviet credibility; and the Iran-Iraq War created conflicting interests.

Where the marks are on 9489/42

Assessment objectivePer essayAcross two essays
AO2 Analysis and judgement1530
AO1 Supporting knowledge1530
Total3060
  • Judgement and knowledge carry equal weight. A detailed narrative with no argument is held at AO2 Level 2, however much it knows.
  • Balance is the gate to Level 4 for AO2. An argument that “lacks balance” is a Level 3 feature, so every essay needs the other side.
  • “Main” and “how far” questions need a ranked answer. Questions 2, 4 and 5 ask for reasons, and the mark scheme asks you to weigh their relative significance.

How to self-mark 9489/42 with the mark scheme

  1. Find your criteria. Did your opening set out how you would judge the question, such as Mussolini’s aims or what “living standards” covers? Implicit criteria are Level 2; valid, wide-ranging criteria are Level 5.
  2. Label each paragraph as analysis or description, and as supporting or challenging the view. Mostly description, or one side only, keeps AO2 at Level 3 or below.
  3. Check your judgement. Level 5 needs it stated and sustained throughout, not added only in the last line.
  4. Mark AO1 separately. Highlight each piece of evidence and ask whether it is precise (dates, figures, names such as K1C2 or NSC-68) and whether it supports a point.
  5. Add the two marks and compare your evidence with the indicative content.

Sit 9489/42 as a timed mock

You have 105 minutes for two 30-mark essays.

BlockMarksTime
Read your section and choose two questions–4 minutes
Plan the first essay: criteria, both sides, judgement–6 minutes
Write the first essay3042 minutes
Plan the second essay–6 minutes
Write the second essay3042 minutes
Check both conclusions–5 minutes

Write your one-sentence judgement in the plan, then make every paragraph test it.

9489/42 in other series

May/June 2026 kept the same twelve-question shape and the same AO1 and AO2 grids. Several areas recurred with different angles: Mussolini (foreign policy here, keeping control in 2026), Stalin’s economy (reasons for industrialisation here, the Five-Year Plans in 2026), the inter-war British economy, US presidential elections (Eisenhower here, 1948 in 2026) and the Middle East (Soviet policy here, the Iran-Iraq War in 2026).

Other October/November 2025 9489 papers

Practise and download

Need help with a 9489 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level History tutor →

Frequently asked questions

What came up on 9489 Paper 42 October/November 2025? +

Section A asked about Mussolini's foreign policy, Stalin's industrialisation, change in German society 1933–41 and British living standards between the wars. Section B covered Eisenhower's election wins, opposition to the counter-culture, US living standards in the 1980s and the Marshall Plan. Section C covered the Korean War, the Vietnam War, social divisions in independent Africa and Soviet policy in the Middle East.

How many marks is 9489/42 and how many questions do you answer? +

It is out of 60 marks and lasts 1 hour 45 minutes. You answer two 30-mark essays from one section, and each essay is marked out of 15 for AO1 knowledge and 15 for AO2 analysis and judgement.

What do you need for Level 5 in 9489/42? +

For AO2, 13 to 15 marks, you need valid, wide-ranging criteria for judging the question, consistent analysis, a balanced argument with a sustained line of reasoning and a clear, sustained judgement. For AO1, you need carefully selected, wide-ranging and consistently precise detail fully focused on the argument.

What were the Eisenhower vote shares in the 9489/42 mark scheme? +

For Question 5, the mark scheme said Eisenhower won 55% of the popular vote in 1952 and increased it to 58% in 1956. It credited the K1C2 campaign (Korea, Communism, Corruption), the I like Ike slogan and Democrat divisions and weaknesses.

How much Marshall Aid did the 9489/42 mark scheme mention? +

It gave the figure of $13 billion, and set the humanitarian view against the arguments that aid served US strategic aims (containment and hegemony) and economic aims (open European markets for US goods).

Where can I download 9489/42 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +

Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489 past papers page.

What is 9489_w25_qp_42? +

9489_w25_qp_42 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489 Paper 42 (Paper 4 Depth Study, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9489_w25_ms_42, and the code printed on the cover is 9489/42/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level History with free topic quizzes