Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/32 October/November 2025 (Paper 3 Interpretations Question): Question-by-Question Guide
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/32 October/November 2025 (Paper 3 Interpretations Question): Question-by-Question Guide

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 8 min read
Updated

Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/32 is the October/November 2025 Paper 3 (Interpretations Question), variant 2. It is an A Level component that lasts 1 hour 15 minutes and is worth 40 marks. You answer one question, on the topic you studied: the origins of the First World War, the Holocaust, or the origins and development of the Cold War. Each topic gives you one extract by a historian and the same 40-mark question: what can you learn from it about the historian’s interpretation and approach? This guide goes through each extract and shows the interpretation the official mark scheme identified and how the two grids work. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

For the newest series of the same paper, see 9489 Paper 32 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.

For an overview of all four 9489 papers from this series, see A Level History 9489 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme.

9489/32 at a glance

Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9489/32/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9489_w25_qp_32 and the mark scheme file is 9489_w25_ms_32.

Rubric: answer one question from one section only.

QuestionSection and topicThe extractMarks
1A: The origins of the First World WarGerman leaders and war plans in the July Crisis of 191440
2B: The HolocaustNazi intentions before the war: emigration, Madagascar, Zionism and Hitler’s 1939 prophecy40
3C: The origins and development of the Cold WarByrnes and Molotov at the 1945 London Foreign Ministers’ Conference40
Total answered (one question)40

Question-by-question walkthrough

How every question is marked

Your answer is marked against two grids of six levels each, and the marks are added.

AO4, interpretation and approach (20 marks):

  • Level 1 (1–4): you refer to some aspects of the extract.
  • Level 2 (5–8): you summarise the main points, but explanations of the extract as an interpretation lack validity.
  • Level 3 (9–11): you see that the extract contains interpretations but explain only sub-messages, argue from part of the extract for a view the whole does not support, or offer a different interpretation in each paragraph.
  • Level 4 (12–14): you identify elements of the main interpretation without explaining them adequately, often treating less important messages as equally or more important.
  • Level 5 (15–17): a sound, accurate understanding of the interpretation and approach, engaging with its elements but not explaining it as a whole.
  • Level 6 (18–20): detailed, accurate use of the extract and a complete understanding, explaining all elements of the interpretation and the approach.

AO1, own knowledge (20 marks): six levels, from limited knowledge (1–4) to detailed, accurate and entirely relevant knowledge (18–20).

The mark scheme tells examiners to mark AO4 first, and the AO1 mark will generally be in the same level. Answers that focus on contextual knowledge without reference to the interpretation cannot be rewarded. For every extract, the main interpretation has two numbered elements, and complete understanding means discussing both.

Section A: The origins of the First World War

Question 1 (40 marks)

The extract: most of it is removed from the published paper for copyright reasons. It opens by saying that, while there were dangerous forces inside Germany in 1914, the Kaiser and Bethmann Hollweg were not ruthless militarists eager to claim world power. It closes by saying that the urgent need of both France and Germany for rapid mobilisation and early offensive action by their eastern allies sped up the whole crisis of July 1914.

Main interpretation in the mark scheme: Germany is culpable (i) for choosing to go to war in 1914 simply because its international position was deteriorating, and (ii) for the Schlieffen Plan, which in a crisis would force nations rapidly to war.

  • Approach: the historian argues against Fischer: Germany went to war with no expectation of winning, but because waiting would only make its position worse. Its war plan was bound to make any serious crisis worse, because the Schlieffen Plan required everyone to mobilise quickly.
  • Schools of thought in the glossary: early post-war views blaming Germany; a revisionist reaction blaming other nations; Fischer’s work of the early 1960s returning the blame to Germany (anti-revisionism); and since then a wide variety of interpretations based on culture, individuals and contingent factors, with no clear consensus, though most historians still place significant responsibility on Germany.
  • Practising from the published paper: because the middle of the extract is missing, you can practise identifying the interpretation only partly from the public version. Use the opening and closing sentences to see how the historian distances German leaders from Fischer’s militarists while still tying the speed of the crisis to war plans.

Section B: The Holocaust

Question 2 (40 marks)

The extract: the historian argues that once the Nazis were in power, the rest followed from their ideology and victories in the east, with no need to find a specific moment of decision or to make it depend on Hitler. Forced emigration was official policy until 1938, but the regime knew no nation would take so many impoverished Jews. The Madagascar plan was dropped when the invasion of Britain was postponed, and there is no reason to think the SS would have behaved differently there; Rosenberg said in February 1939 that the only exit from the island would be death. Nazi encouragement of Zionists is overstated, since Hitler never wanted a Jewish state. Hitler’s moves to war and his Jewish policy were closely linked, as his public prophecy of 30 January 1939 of the “annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe” showed, and the decision was made long before summer 1941.

Main interpretation in the mark scheme: Hitler and the Nazis were responsible for the Holocaust because (i) genocide was implicit in Nazi policies towards the Jews, (ii) but became explicit in early 1939 as war approached.

  • Approach: even before the war the Nazis intended to murder the Jews, and war would provide the opportunity. They were never serious about emigration as a solution, but could not make their intentions explicit until war loomed.
  • How labels were levelled: arguing that the Nazis always intended genocide and were waiting for the chance is clearly intentionalist, the only label acceptable in Levels 5 and 6.
  • Glossary terms: intentionalism (Hitler and the Nazis planned extermination from the start), structuralism (the chaotic competition for Hitler’s approval within the Nazi state produced genocide), functionalism (an unplanned, ad hoc response to wartime conquest of areas with large Jewish populations) and synthesis interpretations. What counts is how appropriate the label is and how well you support it from the extract.
  • Watch the trap: the extract’s opening line says there is no need to write as if the Holocaust “depended on Hitler”, and it mentions emigration and Madagascar. Reading those parts alone could suggest a structuralist or functionalist view, which is the Level 3 pattern of arguing from part of the extract against the whole.

Section C: The origins and development of the Cold War

Question 3 (40 marks)

The extract: the London Conference of 1945 showed the atom bomb would not make the Soviets more manageable. Byrnes, against most of his delegation, kept withholding recognition and peace treaties from the Balkan states until Moscow allowed “representative” regimes, to satisfy unrealistic American public expectations, though by signing the armistices the US had arguably already accepted Soviet domination there. In a private meeting he pleaded with Molotov and hinted at a Polish-style solution that would merely appear to meet Yalta. Molotov was unmoved, compared the Soviet position to how the US would react to a hostile Mexico, and accused Byrnes of abandoning Roosevelt’s policy of friendship. Truman privately wondered if the US was demobilising too fast, while publicly insisting the two countries’ interests did not clash, on the same day Soviet troops reinforced the Turkish border.

Main interpretation in the mark scheme: both the US and the USSR were to blame for the Cold War because (i) the US tried to manipulate and pressure the USSR to achieve its own aims, and (ii) the USSR continued to be inflexible and aggressive.

  • Approach: Molotov is portrayed as difficult and resistant to all of Byrnes’s attempts to get along, so the Soviets carry clear blame. But the Americans are not exonerated: they play to the domestic audience and do not keep to their agreements. The US is shown at fault, perhaps less than the USSR, since it makes some attempt to reach agreement.
  • How labels were levelled: post-revisionist is the most appropriate label for Level 6. A traditional reading, argued properly, could be placed in Level 5, depending on the support.
  • Glossary terms: traditional or orthodox (blames Stalin’s expansionism), revisionist (shifts the focus to the US, often through its economic aims in Europe), post-revisionist (blame on both sides) and post-post-revisionist (prime responsibility to Stalin after the Soviet archives opened, often stressing ideology).

Where the marks are on 9489/32

Assessment objectiveWhat it rewardsMarks
AO4Analysing the historian’s interpretation and approach20
AO1Relevant, accurate own knowledge used with the extract20
Total40
  • AO4 sets the level. Examiners mark AO4 first and usually put AO1 in the same level, so excellent knowledge with a weak reading of the extract will not score highly.
  • Both parts of the interpretation matter. In all three extracts the main interpretation has two elements, and Level 6 needs both explained.
  • Labels must fit the extract. In the Holocaust question only intentionalism reached Levels 5 and 6; in the Cold War question post-revisionism was the best fit for Level 6.

How to self-mark 9489/32 with the mark scheme

  1. Write the mark scheme’s two-part interpretation next to your opening. Does your answer state both parts?
  2. Mark AO4 first. Summary only is Level 2; sub-messages, Level 3; the main idea with a side issue given equal weight, Level 4; a sound reading without the whole picture, Level 5; both parts and the approach, Level 6.
  3. Check your label against the mark scheme’s guidance for your topic, and that you supported it from the extract.
  4. Mark AO1 in the same level unless there is a clear reason not to. Strike out any paragraph of context that never refers back to the interpretation.
  5. Add the two marks for a total out of 40.

Sit 9489/32 as a timed mock

You have 75 minutes for one 40-mark answer.

BlockMarksTime
Read the extract twice; mark the main argument and supporting points–12 minutes
Write the two-part interpretation in one or two sentences; plan the approach and knowledge to use–8 minutes
Write the answer, opening with the interpretation4050 minutes
Check that both parts are explained and any label is supported from the extract–5 minutes

Open with the interpretation, then use each paragraph to show how part of the extract supports it and how your own knowledge tests it.

9489/32 in other series

May/June 2026 kept the same three topics, one 40-mark question per topic and the same AO4 and AO1 grids. The Cold War extracts in both series blamed both sides, with post-revisionism the label the mark scheme preferred each time, while the Holocaust label differed: intentionalism was the only top-level label here, and in 2026 intentionalism was acceptable while functionalism was capped at Level 3.

Other October/November 2025 9489 papers

Practise and download

Need help with a 9489 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level History tutor →

Frequently asked questions

What were the extracts on 9489 Paper 32 October/November 2025? +

Section A had an extract on Germany's leaders and the July Crisis of 1914, Section B an extract on the Nazis' intentions towards the Jews before the war, including the Madagascar plan and Hitler's January 1939 prophecy, and Section C an extract on the 1945 London Foreign Ministers' Conference between Byrnes and Molotov.

How many marks is 9489/32 and how long is it? +

It is out of 40 marks and lasts 1 hour 15 minutes. You answer one question, from the topic you studied, made up of one extract and one question: 20 marks for AO4 (the interpretation and approach) and 20 for AO1 (own knowledge).

What was the interpretation in the 9489/32 Holocaust extract? +

The mark scheme said the historian holds Hitler and the Nazis responsible because genocide was implicit in Nazi Jewish policy and became explicit in early 1939 as war approached. It called this clearly intentionalist, the only label acceptable in Levels 5 and 6.

Which label fitted the 9489/32 Cold War extract? +

Post-revisionist, because the historian blames both sides: the US for trying to pressure the USSR to meet its own aims, and the USSR for being inflexible and aggressive. The mark scheme said a traditional reading, argued properly, could reach Level 5 depending on support.

What was the interpretation in the 9489/32 First World War extract? +

The mark scheme said the historian blames Germany for choosing war in 1914 because of its deteriorating international position, and for the Schlieffen Plan, which forced rapid mobilisation in a crisis. The historian argues against Fischer that Germany's leaders were not ruthless militarists seeking world power.

Where can I download 9489/32 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +

Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489 past papers page.

What is 9489_w25_qp_32? +

9489_w25_qp_32 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489 Paper 32 (Paper 3 Interpretations Question, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9489_w25_ms_32, and the code printed on the cover is 9489/32/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level History with free topic quizzes