Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 Document Question): Question-by-Question Guide
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 Document Question): Question-by-Question Guide

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 10 min read
Updated

Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489/12 is the October/November 2025 Paper 1 (Document Question), variant 2. It is an AS Level component that lasts 1 hour 15 minutes and is worth 40 marks. You answer one question from one of three sections (European, American or International), and every question has the same two parts: a 15-mark comparison of two sources and a 25-mark question that tests a view against all four sources. This guide goes through the paper source by source and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

For the newest series of the same paper, see 9489 Paper 12 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.

For an overview of all four 9489 papers from this series, see A Level History 9489 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme.

9489/12 at a glance

Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9489/12/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9489_w25_qp_12 and the mark scheme file is 9489_w25_ms_12.

Rubric: answer one question from one section only, and answer both parts of it.

QuestionSection and topic(a) 15 marks(b) 25 marks
1A European: Liberalism and nationalism in Germany, 1815–71Compare B and C as evidence about attitudes to the spread of liberal ideas in the 1830sHow far the sources agree that the desire for unity was the main cause of discontent in the Confederation
2B American: The origins of the Civil War, 1820–61Compare the views in C and D about slaves and slaveryHow far the sources show hostility to slavery was the main reason for the Republican Party’s growth
3C International: The League of Nations and international relations in the 1930sCompare B and C as evidence about the making of the Naval AgreementHow far the sources support the view that the Naval Agreement improved relations between European powers
Total answered (one question, (a) + (b))40

Question-by-question walkthrough

How every question is marked

All three questions use the same two generic level grids.

Part (a), 15 marks, four levels:

  • Level 1 (1–3): you describe or paraphrase the sources. Very simple comparisons, such as one being a letter and the other a speech, stay here.
  • Level 2 (4–7): you find similarities or differences, but one-sided, or you assert both without supporting them from the sources.
  • Level 3 (8–11): you compare views, identifying similarities and differences and supporting them with source content.
  • Level 4 (12–15): you make a developed comparison and explain why the points of similarity and difference exist, through contextual awareness, source evaluation or both.

Part (b), 25 marks, five levels:

  • Level 1 (1–5): you describe the sources with little link to the question, or write an essay with little or no reference to the sources.
  • Level 2 (6–10): you use the sources to support the statement or to challenge it.
  • Level 3 (11–15): you use the sources to support and to challenge it.
  • Level 4 (16–20): you evaluate the sources in context, for example their nature, origin and purpose, to show how they support and challenge the statement.
  • Level 5 (21–25): you weigh the evidence and reach a supported judgement on how far the sources support the statement.

Each question ends with “accept any other valid responses”, so the content below is indicative.

Section A: Liberalism and nationalism in Germany, 1815–71

The sources:

  • Source A: an account of the Hambach Festival, 1832, by a radical lawyer who had been in a student nationalist society and took part in the events in Source C. Speakers blame the division into 38 states, with different laws, currencies and customs borders, for Germany’s weakness, and complain of Austrian and Prussian pressure on the Diet.
  • Source B: Metternich’s Ten Articles, July 1832, enforced across the Confederation. They ban unapproved political newspapers from outside the Confederation, unapproved assemblies and festivals, and political speeches, put known revolutionaries under police surveillance and apply the 1819 measures against student societies.
  • Source C: a print by a radical French artist of armed students storming Frankfurt’s main police station to free political prisoners, April 1833, under a flag reading “liberty for Germany”.
  • Source D: a German businessman’s letter to the Prussian Interior Ministry, March 1848, complaining of no trust in the Diet, no protection of constitutional rights, the monarch’s unrestrained power in Prussia, violations of Protestants’ beliefs, working-class opposition in the Rhine Province and no national institution.

1(a) Compare B and C as evidence about attitudes to the spread of liberal ideas in the 1830s (15 marks)

  • Similarities: both show the spread of liberal ideas will not be tolerated, with B listing restrictions on writing, meetings and universities and C showing the authorities opposing students trying to free political prisoners; both show liberal ideas are popular with students active in opposition; and both show committed attitudes on each side.
  • Differences: B is repressive and threatens harsh punishment, while C seems to support the students and suggests liberal ideas still have wider support despite B; and B assumes the measures will be “unfailingly applied”, while C, with students arming themselves and attacking a police station, suggests they have not been fully effective.
  • To reach Level 4: explain through Metternich’s beliefs and earlier legislation such as the Carlsbad Decrees of 1819, which restricted the press and universities; C shows people arrested, just as B threatens. Revolutionary events across Europe in 1832 revived student societies, and large numbers went to festivals such as Hambach.

1(b) How far do the sources agree that the desire for German unity was the main cause of discontent? (25 marks)

  • Support: A laments the “lack of national union” and speaks of keeping “the liberty and unity of the Fatherland” alive. D complains there is no “secure, unified bond” or national institution, and implies Austrian and Prussian domination makes the Diet powerless.
  • Challenge: B could show that Austrian domination and repression was the main cause. In C, the lack of political freedom drives the students, who are trying to free political prisoners. D also lists other grievances: workers’ discontent, religious freedom and the desire for constitutional monarchy.
  • Evaluation: A’s author was a committed nationalist who wanted to show support for nationalism was widespread, which may weaken it. B can be tested against your knowledge of Metternich’s policies. C seems to have a propaganda purpose, portraying the students as heroes. D was written at the start of the 1848 revolutions to persuade the Prussian authorities to change policy, and context on growing discontent in the 1840s can strengthen it.

Section B: The origins of the Civil War, 1820–61

The sources:

  • Source A: a letter by Stephen Douglas to a leading Southern Democrat, October 1858. He calls the Republicans a party of ethnic hatred backed by anti-immigrant extremists, likens them to the Know-Nothings, and urges his party to end its divisions.
  • Source B: a speech by a Pennsylvania congressman, formerly a Whig and a Free-Soiler, October 1858. He calls the party a coalition of dishonourable expediency but praises its 1856 Philadelphia Platform and its view that slavery and freedom cannot coexist, with principles broad enough for anti-slavery men and those wary of emancipation.
  • Source C: a prominent New York lawyer’s private diary, August 1859. He once thought slaves better off than free black people in the North, but the attack on Senator Sumner and the Fugitive Slave Law have turned him against slavery, towards emancipation with citizenship rights, and towards the Republicans.
  • Source D: a Democratic politician’s letter in the abolitionist New York Daily Tribune, December 1859. He says Republicans are growing because they oppose slavery, but out of Northern workers’ fear of losing work to slave labour rather than sympathy, and he does not think freed slaves should share the same rights.

2(a) Compare the views in C and D about slaves and slavery (15 marks)

  • Similarities: both oppose slavery; both were influenced by the Fugitive Slave Law (“barbarism” in C, “brutal enforcement” in D); and both call it a crime (“crime” in C, “criminal activity” in D).
  • Differences: C changed his mind, while D’s opposition is “long-held”; C shows sympathy for slaves (“my feelings go out”), while D says it is “not a question of sympathy” but a threat to Northern labour; and C wants emancipation with citizens’ rights, while D doubts freed slaves should have the same rights.
  • To reach Level 4: explain through purpose. C is a private diary not meant for publication; D is a serving politician writing in an abolitionist paper, probably anxious for votes and careful not to offend. In 1859 the Republicans were making inroads in working-class Democratic areas, enforcement of the Fugitive Slave Law was hardening Northern opinion, and the Whig and Democrat parties were splitting into Northern and Southern sections.

2(b) How far do the sources show hostility to slavery was the main reason for the Republicans’ growth? (25 marks)

  • Support: B says the party “did not turn a deaf ear” and that slavery and freedom cannot coexist. C is the strongest support, calling slavery a “crime”. D says the party grows because it opposes slavery, though more from dislike of slave owners and their economic threat.
  • Challenge: A clearly challenges, putting Republican support down to hostility to immigrants, especially Irish Catholics after the famine, and mentioning the Democrats’ own divisions. B also challenges, because the platform was broad enough to attract men wary of emancipation.
  • Evaluation: A is by a leading Northern Democrat, just re-elected against Lincoln, so it carries political propaganda. B reflects the broad coalition of moderates, Free-Soilers and ex-Whigs after the Whigs split over the Fugitive Slave Act. C’s change of view was typical of many better-off Northerners, and the Sumner assault became a symbol of Southern aggression. D’s author, a state legislator in New York with a broad male franchise, would know working-class feeling.

Section C: The League of Nations and international relations in the 1930s

The sources:

  • Source A: Churchill’s speech to Parliament, July 1935. He says British action has weakened the League, collective security and the Stresa Front and approved German treaty-breaking; Germany would have become a naval power anyway, and the Agreement is not disarmament.
  • Source B: Ribbentrop’s memoirs, written during his war crimes trial, 1946. The talks with Simon and Eden were friendly; he rejected making the agreement depend on the Versailles powers; it ended naval rivalry and laid foundations for Anglo-German friendship; Hitler called it the happiest day of his life; the French were annoyed.
  • Source C: the memoirs of the French Ambassador in Berlin, published 1949. Stresa was the climax of European unity, but within two months Hitler bluntly demanded a fleet of 35% of Britain’s, Simon listened politely without objecting, and Britain “leaped at the bait” and made the Agreement on its own.
  • Source D: the memoirs of Samuel Hoare, British Foreign Minister in 1935, published 1954. The Agreement restricted German rearmament and bought time; the alternatives were drift or preventive war; Laval said he understood Britain’s position; Mussolini only wanted more consultation.

3(a) Compare B and C as evidence about the making of the Naval Agreement (15 marks)

  • Similarities: both describe the meeting with Simon and Eden in Berlin; both suggest the early talks were friendly; both say negotiations were between Germany and Britain only and concerned naval limits; and both show the Germans were pleased.
  • Differences: B shows two sides engaged in talks, while in C Hitler “stated his claims quite roughly” while his visitors listened; B suggests genuine wish for friendship, while C’s word “bait” suggests a trap; and B suggests Britain wanted to act with its allies but was stopped by Ribbentrop, while C stresses Britain acted “quietly on its own”.
  • To reach Level 4: the similarities reflect the timeline (a Berlin meeting, talks in London, the Agreement of 18 June 1935 limiting the German Navy to 35% of the British, made quickly without Britain’s allies). The differences reflect motives: Ribbentrop presents his side as courteous but in control, while the French ambassador shows Hitler as bombastic and Britain as gullible and secretive, perhaps from a wish to keep Germany weak and frustration with Britain.

3(b) How far do the sources support the view that the Agreement improved relations between European powers? (25 marks)

  • Support: B credits it with “enduring Anglo-German friendship”, removing a cause of the First World War and benefiting France. D stresses continuing dialogue and a hoped-for Air Pact, with Laval understanding and Mussolini not criticising the terms.
  • Challenge: A condemns it for weakening the League, the Stresa Front and collective security. B concedes France was annoyed. C sees it as a break in cohesion against the Third Reich. D admits the French press raged and Mussolini wanted more consultation.
  • Evaluation: Churchill was sceptical of arms limitation and pushed for faster rearmament. Ribbentrop casts himself as a peacemaker, which can be tested against German rearmament and conscription. C shows the embittering of Anglo-French relations. D is a justification by one of the Agreement’s authors, though it makes the point that the alternatives were worse and it bought Britain time.
  • The mark scheme’s overall view: the Agreement did little to change relations, since Germany was already ignoring Versailles and French and Italian outrage seems to have been largely for show.

Where the marks are on 9489/12

SkillPartMarksHow it is marked
Comparing two sources and explaining why they agree or differ(a)15Four levels
Testing a view with all four sources and reaching a judgement(b)25Five levels
Total40
  • Part (b) carries 62.5% of the paper. Plan it before you start part (a) so you don’t run short of time.
  • One source can work both ways. The mark scheme uses D in Question 1, B in Question 2 and B and D in Question 3 to support and to challenge. Using a source on both sides shows you read it closely.
  • Explanation is the gate into Level 4. In part (a), say why the sources agree or differ; in part (b), evaluate the sources’ nature, origin and purpose.

How to self-mark 9489/12 with the mark scheme

  1. Sort your part (a) points into similarities and differences, and check each points to both sources. Both kinds, supported, is Level 3.
  2. Look for a “why”. If you explained a similarity or difference through provenance or context, such as Metternich’s aims or the Tribune politician’s need for votes, you are in Level 4.
  3. Tick and cross each source in part (b) as support or challenge. One side only is Level 2; both is Level 3.
  4. Check your evaluation. Did you question who wrote each source, when and why, and say how that changed its weight? That is Level 4.
  5. Test your conclusion. Level 5 needs a weighed verdict on “how far”, not a repeat of both sides.

Sit 9489/12 as a timed mock

You have 75 minutes for one 40-mark question.

BlockMarksTime
Read all four sources and annotate provenance (who, when, for whom, why)–12 minutes
Part (a): plan the comparison, then write1523 minutes
Part (b): sort sources into support and challenge, then write2536 minutes
Check the part (b) conclusion answers “how far”–4 minutes

Before writing part (b), decide your verdict in one sentence and which source carries the most weight.

9489/12 in other series

May/June 2026 kept the same shape and the same level grids: one question from three sections, a 15-mark comparison and a 25-mark “how far” question. The American option moved on from the origins of the Civil War here to the Civil War and Reconstruction in 2026, while the European and International options changed to Russia and to China and Japan.

Other October/November 2025 9489 papers

Practise and download

Need help with a 9489 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level History tutor →

Frequently asked questions

What topics came up on 9489 Paper 12 October/November 2025? +

Section A (European) was liberalism and nationalism in Germany, 1815–71, with sources from the 1830s and 1848. Section B (American) was the origins of the Civil War, 1820–61, on the rise of the Republican Party. Section C (International) was the League of Nations in the 1930s, on the 1935 Anglo-German Naval Agreement.

How many marks is 9489/12 and how long is it? +

It is out of 40 marks and lasts 1 hour 15 minutes. You answer one question from one section: part (a), a 15-mark comparison of two sources, and part (b), a 25-mark question using all four sources.

What do you need for Level 4 in 9489/12 part (a)? +

A developed comparison that explains why the two sources agree or differ, using contextual awareness or source evaluation, worth 12 to 15 marks. Finding supported similarities and differences without explaining them is Level 3, 8 to 11 marks.

Which source challenged the view in 9489/12 Question 2(b)? +

Source A, a letter by Stephen Douglas, most clearly challenged the view: he argued Republican support came from anti-immigrant prejudice and linked the party to the Know-Nothings. The mark scheme also used Source B to challenge, because the party's platform was broad enough to attract men wary of emancipation.

Did the Naval Agreement improve relations according to the 9489/12 mark scheme? +

The mark scheme concluded that the Agreement did little to change relations between European powers: Germany was already ignoring the Versailles limits, and French and Italian outrage seems to have been largely for show. Sources B and D support the view, and Sources A and C challenge it.

Where can I download 9489/12 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +

Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489 past papers page.

What is 9489_w25_qp_12? +

9489_w25_qp_12 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level History 9489 Paper 12 (Paper 1 Document Question, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9489_w25_ms_12, and the code printed on the cover is 9489/12/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level History with free topic quizzes