Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990/42 October/November 2025 (Paper 4 Specialist Options: Application and Research Methods): Question-by-Question Guide
Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990/42 is the October/November 2025 Paper 4 (Specialist Options: Application and Research Methods), variant 2. It lasts 1 hour 30 minutes, is worth 60 marks and is an A Level paper. You answer five questions from two options: both Section A questions from each option (18 marks per option), then one 24-mark planning question from Section B. The paper prints 168 marks across its four options, but a candidate answers 60. The biggest single part is the 10-mark plan, which is marked on a five-level grid. This guide goes through every question in all four options and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.
For the newest series of the same paper, see 9990 Paper 42 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.
For an overview of all four 9990 papers from this series, see A Level Psychology 9990 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme.
9990/42 at a glance
Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9990/42/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9990_w25_qp_42 and the mark scheme file is 9990_w25_ms_42.
The rubric is: answer five questions in total, from two options. In Section A, answer four questions (both questions from each of your two options); in Section B, answer one question. You write in an answer booklet.
| Question | Section and option | Topic | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A: Clinical | Lovell et al. (2006): two measures, testing validity, rating scales | 10 |
| 2 | A: Clinical | Miller’s feeling-state theory of impulse control disorders; generalising from one study | 8 |
| 3 | A: Consumer | Snyder and DeBono (1985): the two messages, telephone interviews, student participants | 10 |
| 4 | A: Consumer | Cialdini’s scarcity in closing a sale | 8 |
| 5 | A: Health | Savage and Armstrong (1990): ethics, other ways to collect data, timing of the questionnaire | 10 |
| 6 | A: Health | Fear arousal to promote health; fire safety | 8 |
| 7 | A: Organisational | Landry et al. (2019): controls for individual differences, using a laboratory | 10 |
| 8 | A: Organisational | Scouller’s private level of leadership; a closed question; asking workers | 8 |
| 9 | B: Clinical | Plan a questionnaire on thoughts about fires in people with pyromania | 24 |
| 10 | B: Consumer | Plan an experiment on brand recognition in adult males and females | 24 |
| 11 | B: Health | Plan an interview on unrealistic optimism in adults’ health beliefs | 24 |
| 12 | B: Organisational | Plan an interview on whether praise or recognition motivates workers more | 24 |
| Printed on the paper (4 × 18 in Section A, plus 4 × 24 in Section B) | 168 | ||
| Total answered (two options × 18, plus one plan) | 60 |
Each Section A option adds up to 10 + 8 = 18, and each plan to 10 + 4 + 4 + 2 + 2 + 2 = 24, so a candidate answers 18 + 18 + 24 = 60.
Question-by-question walkthrough
How Section A is marked
Most Section A parts are point-marked. For “suggest” and “explain” parts, a point that is stated earns 1 mark, and a point that is applied to the study or topic with detail, elaboration or an example earns 2. The 4-mark “outline” or “describe” parts on key studies use definitive answers: 2 marks for each detailed answer, 1 for a partial one, and sometimes 1 mark just for naming both items correctly.
Clinical Psychology (Questions 1 and 2)
- 1(a) Two measures in Lovell et al., other than the satisfaction questionnaire (4 marks): the definitive answers were the Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS) checklist, self-report version: 10 items each scored 0 (no symptoms) to 4 (severe), with totals banded from 0–7 (very mild) to 32–40 (severe); and the Beck Depression Inventory, a secondary outcome measure with 21 items scored 0 to 3 (63 maximum). Naming both earned 1; naming only one earned 0. Lovell et al. used the self-report Y-BOCS, so “interview” earned nothing, and saying only what each scale measures (OCD or depression) scored 0.
- 1(b) Testing the validity of one measure (2 marks): concurrent validity, comparing Y-BOCS or BDI scores with another measure of OCD and looking for a strong correlation; construct validity, checking the scale matches the theory of what it should measure; ecological validity, whether the questions reflect real experiences of people with OCD; or testing over time to see whether improvement shows. You did not need the terms “criterion” or “construct” validity.
- 1(c) Two strengths of rating scales for telephone treatment of OCD (4 marks): they can assess the same person over time to see whether their OCD improves after treatment; they allow one person to be compared with another; and they work as an assessment tool, showing the features and severity of a person’s OCD on a standardised scale.
- 2(a) Miller’s feeling-state theory (2 marks): an impulse control disorder forms when an intense positive feeling (intense desire) becomes linked with a specific behaviour, creating a state-dependent memory or feeling-state. To recreate that feeling, the person compulsively repeats the behaviour, even when it is harmful. A diagram was not needed.
- 2(b) Another way to support the theory (2 marks): an observation of how much or how often a person engages in the behaviour; an interview by someone qualified to assess feeling-states; or a questionnaire built to assess feeling-states, each with an example for 2 marks.
- 2(c) Why one study cannot support generalisations (4 marks): feeling-state theory is only one explanation, alongside cognitive, behavioural and psychodynamic ones; Miller’s support came from a case study of one man, John, with a gambling problem; there is only one study, so methodological support is thin; and the theory may not apply to every impulse control disorder. Cultural differences scored nothing, because feeling-states are psychological processes everyone has.
Consumer Psychology (Questions 3 and 4)
- 3(a) The two messages in study 3 of Snyder and DeBono (4 marks): the definitive answers were the image message, which said the shampoo rated about average for cleaning but consistently above average for how good it made hair look, and the quality message, which said the reverse: about average for looks, above average for how clean it got hair. Naming both earned 1; naming only one earned 0.
- 3(b) A telephone interview feature applied to the study (2 marks): keep questions simple, because nothing is written down, as with asking how much participants would like to try the shampoo; keep the number of questions small, since only one main question was asked; keep the interview short; and keep the answers uncomplicated, as with the five-point scale from “definitely not” to “definitely yes” used in the study.
- 3(c) A strength and a weakness of using university students (4 marks): strengths, they are readily available and form a standardised sample, and students are consumers with personalities like anyone else; or the study can act as a pilot before testing people of all ages. Weaknesses, students may respond to demand characteristics because they know they are in a study about advertising; or they may have little experience of real working life, so results may not generalise.
- 4(a) Scarcity, with a sales example (2 marks): 1 for the outline (products are valued more when they are limited, so “buy now before there are none left”) and 1 for an example, such as Worchel et al.’s (1975) cookie jar experiment, where the cookies in a jar of two were rated higher than those in a jar of ten, or flight and hotel sites saying “only two more available”. Only scarcity was credited, not Cialdini’s other principles.
- 4(b) Why scarcity makes people buy (2 marks): people like a bargain, such as the last seat at this price; people want to get something before others can; or if they delay they will miss out.
- 4(c) Two strengths of scarcity for the seller (4 marks): they sell more, such as plane seats or hotel rooms, even when plenty are still available; and they clear the end of a line before a new model arrives, such as an offer on an older phone before the latest one is released.
Health Psychology (Questions 5 and 6)
- 5(a) Two ways ethical guidelines were followed in Savage and Armstrong (4 marks): 1 mark for identifying any two guidelines, then 2 for each full description. Informed consent: every patient got a written request to allow audio-recording of the consultation as part of a research project, and if a patient refused, the next eligible patient was chosen. Protection from psychological harm: patients were excluded if they might be upset by taking part, could not complete it, or had a life-threatening condition. Right to withdraw: 30 did not complete the first assessment and 110 did not complete the one a week later. Other guidelines could be credited with a real example from the study.
- 5(b) Another way to collect satisfaction data (2 marks): a telephone interview asking the same questions as the postal questionnaire, or asking patients to return to the surgery to complete it, so more data would come back.
- 5(c) A strength and a weakness of collecting data a week later (4 marks): strengths, a week is close enough for patients to remember the consultation, or long enough to reflect rather than give a knee-jerk emotional response. Weaknesses, a week may be long enough to forget important details, or for patients to drop out or be unavailable, so the data on consulting style may be flawed.
- 6(a) One study using fear arousal (2 marks): any suitable study was credited. Janis and Feshbach (1953) compared minimal, moderate and strong fear presentations on dental hygiene with a control group, using questionnaires before, immediately after and a week later. The strong fear group felt most fear, but the minimal fear presentation was most effective: 36% conformed to the advice, against 8% for the strong presentation.
- 6(b) Fear arousal plus information for fire safety (2 marks): show something that arouses fear of fire, such as an image or video, then give information on how to put a fire out, how to escape or how to prevent one. Unethical suggestions scored 0.
- 6(c) Two weaknesses of fear arousal (4 marks): too much fear can make people react negatively; too little produces no change in behaviour; and fear without information leaves people not knowing what to do. A health example, such as smoking, diet or dental care, earned the second mark.
Organisational Psychology (Questions 7 and 8)
- 7(a) The two control measures in Landry et al. (4 marks): 1 mark for naming both, then the descriptions. Perceived value of the reward: participants rated on a 3-item scale how valuable the reward was, and the composite score controlled for differences in motivation caused by how much they valued it. Positive and negative affect (mood): participants completed the short form of the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule, rating feelings such as “alert” and “inspired” or “upset” and “nervous”, and these scores controlled for differences in mood after reading the instructions.
- 7(b) Why a lab limits application to organisations (2 marks): participants know they are in a lab, which is not a real organisation, and this may change how they perform; or they know the rewards are artificial.
- 7(c) Two strengths of a lab for studying rewards (4 marks): situational variables such as temperature and lighting can be controlled, so only the task is measured; the procedure is standardised, with everyone receiving the same instructions; and participants know they are in a study, so informed consent can be obtained.
- 8(a) Scouller’s private level of leadership (2 marks): handling individuals one to one, treating each person with respect because they differ in knowledge, experience, motivation and confidence. Scouller describes 14 private leadership behaviours in two groups: individual purpose and task (such as appraising, disciplining and setting goals) and individual building and maintenance (such as building relationships and recognising talent).
- 8(b) A closed question for workers (2 marks): 2 marks for a closed question with its answer options that targets a private leadership behaviour, such as “On a scale of 1 to 5, how good is your leader at building relationships?” or “Is your leader good at recognising talent? Yes or No”. A closed question with no answer options earned 1.
- 8(c) Two weaknesses of asking workers about their leader (4 marks): workers may exaggerate, play down or not tell the truth, leading to inaccurate conclusions; they may fear losing their job if they are honest; and their follower type matters, because a conformist follower may back every decision while an alienated follower may not.
How the Section B plans are marked
Each planning question has the same structure: (a) the plan (10 marks), (b)(i) describe the psychological knowledge behind it (4), (b)(ii) explain how you used two features of it (4), and (c) three 2-mark justifications.
The 10-mark plan is marked for AO2 application on five levels:
- Level 5 (9–10): the method the question asks for; a good range of method-specific and general features in accurate detail; a coherent plan that could be replicated; good use of ethical guidelines.
- Level 4 (7–8): the right method; a range of method-specific features in detail and general features with some detail; a coherent plan; ethics used appropriately.
- Level 3 (5–6): the right method; a range of features that may lack detail; some coherence; ethics referred to.
- Level 2 (3–4): the right method, but features are listed and the plan would be hard or impossible to replicate; ethics listed or absent.
- Level 1 (1–2): may not use the required method or answer the question; few features.
A plan scores zero if it describes the study on the syllabus or is unethical. The general features credited in every plan are the sample and sampling technique, ethics, a procedure, the type of data and analysis (including descriptive statistics), an aim or hypothesis, and steps for validity and reliability.
Part (b)(i) is levelled: 3–4 marks for appropriate knowledge described in good detail, 1–2 for basic points. Part (b)(ii) gives 2 marks per feature when you explain how it was used or adapted in your plan, and 1 when you only identify it. Part (c) gives 2 marks when a reason is applied to your plan and 1 when it is not, and the choices must match what you wrote in (a).
Question 9: thoughts about fires in pyromania (Clinical, 24 marks)
- 9(a) The plan (10 marks): a questionnaire, including the question format and the questionnaire technique. Method-specific features: technique (paper and pencil, online or postal), format (open, closed or both), example questions, how answers are scored or interpreted, and the number of questions.
- 9(b)(i) Knowledge (4 marks): the ICD-11 criteria for pyromania: an urge to set fires deliberately (and often to watch them or the emergency services), tension or arousal beforehand, an attraction to fire, relief or satisfaction from setting and watching the fire, and no other motive. Griffiths’ characteristics of addiction could also be used. A “PSAS” scale does not exist, so describing one scored 0.
- 9(b)(ii) Using two features (4 marks): for example, an open question such as “Describe how you feel after watching a fire”, linked to the knowledge about feelings after a fire.
- 9(c): (i) a reason for your question format (open questions give rich detail and let people explain feelings; closed questions give the same format for everyone, are easy to score and quick to ask), (ii) a weakness of that format (open answers are harder to analyse, and participants may not want to explain themselves; closed answers stop people explaining how they feel), and (iii) a reason for your technique (paper and pencil may make people more likely to complete it honestly; online or postal reaches a larger, more diverse sample with no researcher influencing answers).
Question 10: brand recognition in men and women (Consumer, 24 marks)
- 10(a) The plan (10 marks): an experiment, including a directional or non-directional hypothesis and descriptive statistics. Method-specific features: type of experiment, IV, DV, controls and experimental design, plus counterbalancing, random allocation or blind procedures where appropriate.
- 10(b)(i) Knowledge (4 marks): brand recognition is how well a consumer can identify a product from its logo, tag line, packaging or advertising; some brands have become the name for their function, such as “hoovering” the carpet. The syllabus covers children, but the question asked about adults, and the Fischer et al. (1991) study could be used. For (b)(ii), the scheme’s example made correct identification of a brand from its logo the DV.
- 10(c): (i) a reason for your hypothesis: 2 marks for a directional or non-directional hypothesis applied to the plan, correctly worded, with a reason (directional because previous research suggests the direction; non-directional because there is no such evidence); 1 for incomplete wording; and 0 for a null hypothesis. (ii) A strength of your type of experiment (a lab gives high control, so the DV is more likely to be caused by the IV; a field experiment gives higher ecological validity). (iii) A reason for your descriptive statistics (means, medians, modes or ranges summarise the results, or a bar chart displays them).
Question 11: unrealistic optimism about health (Health, 24 marks)
- 11(a) The plan (10 marks): an interview, including the question format and the interview format. Method-specific features: technique (telephone or face to face), format (structured, semi-structured or unstructured), question format, example questions, scoring or interpretation, and the number of questions.
- 11(b)(i) Knowledge (4 marks): unrealistic optimism (optimistic bias, or the illusion of invulnerability) explains why people ignore health advice, such as continuing to smoke because they believe cancer will not happen to them. Weinstein (1980) could be used: college students rated their own chances of positive events as above average and of negative events as below average, and in a second study the bias fell, but did not disappear, when participants realised others were just like them.
- 11(b)(ii) Using two features (4 marks): for example, a structured interview with a closed question asking participants to rate from 1 (highly likely) to 5 (highly unlikely) their chances of living beyond the average age of death.
- 11(c): (i) a reason for your question format, (ii) a weakness of it (as in Question 9), and (iii) a reason for your interview format (structured: the same questions in the same order for everyone; semi-structured: fixed questions with room to follow up; unstructured: participants can answer as they please).
Question 12: praise or recognition at work (Organisational, 24 marks)
- 12(a) The plan (10 marks): an interview, including the sampling technique and the interview format. The method-specific features are the same interview features as Question 11.
- 12(b)(i) Knowledge (4 marks): non-monetary (intrinsic) motivators. Praise can be a simple “well done” from a manager and must be given fairly and consistently; recognition rewards hard work, responsibility, leadership and other valued skills, for example with an award or certificate. Contrasting these with monetary (extrinsic) rewards was also credited.
- 12(b)(ii) Using two features (4 marks): the scheme’s example used an unstructured interview with “How do you feel when a manager praises your work?” for praise and “How do you feel when a manager presents you with a small award for your work?” for recognition.
- 12(c): (i) a reason for your sampling technique (random gives everyone an equal chance; opportunity gets large numbers easily; volunteers are willing to take part), (ii) a weakness of it (people chosen at random may refuse; opportunity sampling risks researcher bias; volunteers may respond to demand characteristics), and (iii) a reason for your interview format, as in Question 11.
Where the marks are on 9990/42
| Part | Assessment | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Section A key study questions (two options × 10) | Point-marked | 20 |
| Section A topic and method questions (two options × 8) | Point-marked | 16 |
| Section B plan, part (a) | AO2 levels | 10 |
| Section B psychological knowledge, parts (b)(i) and (b)(ii) | Levels and points | 8 |
| Section B justifications, part (c) | Point-marked | 6 |
| Total | 60 |
- Section B is 40% of the paper, and only 10 of its 24 marks are for the plan itself. The rest reward knowing the topic and justifying your choices.
- Applying a point is worth double. Across Section A, most 2-mark points need the study or topic in the answer, not just a stated strength or weakness.
- The key study “outline” parts are definitive recall: the Lovell et al. measures, the Snyder and DeBono messages, the Savage and Armstrong ethics and the Landry et al. controls. Naming only one of two items in 1(a), 3(a) or 7(a) loses the naming mark.
How to self-mark 9990/42 with the mark scheme
- Learn the layout. A slash or “or” separates ways of making the same point; semicolons or a (1) separate different points. “Definitive” means only the listed answers count.
- Mark Section A point by point. Give 1 for a stated point and 2 only if it is applied to the study or topic. Strike out the answers the scheme rejects, such as “interview” for the Y-BOCS and cultural differences in 2(c).
- Check the plan for zero triggers first: the wrong method, an unethical plan or a description of the syllabus study.
- Tick the features in your plan, split into method-specific and general, and note which are detailed. Then ask whether someone could replicate it, and choose the level.
- Check (b)(ii) links back to both (b)(i) and (a), and that each (c) justification uses what you actually wrote in (a).
- Log each lost mark as a missing study detail, an unapplied point or a missing plan feature, and practise that next.
Sit 9990/42 as a timed mock
The paper allows 90 minutes for the 60 marks you answer, one and a half minutes per mark. A workable plan:
| Block | Marks | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Section A, first option (two questions) | 18 | 25 minutes |
| Section A, second option (two questions) | 18 | 25 minutes |
| Read the Section B questions for your options and choose | – | 2 minutes |
| Section B part (a): the plan | 10 | 16 minutes |
| Section B part (b): knowledge and how you used it | 8 | 11 minutes |
| Section B part (c): three justifications | 6 | 8 minutes |
| Check applications, ethics in the plan and (c) links | – | 3 minutes |
| Total | 60 | 90 minutes |
Write the two required details from the question at the top of your plan, so you cannot leave them out.
9990/42 in other series
The May/June 2026 paper had the same shape: a 10-mark and an 8-mark question per option in Section A, then one 24-mark plan. Lovell et al. and Landry et al. were the Clinical and Organisational key studies in both series, but with different angles: the measures and the lab setting here, the telephone procedure and the sample in 2026. Interview plans appeared in both, and the 2026 Organisational plan used Claypoole and Szalma rather than intrinsic motivators.
Other October/November 2025 9990 papers
- 9990 Paper 12 (Approaches, Issues and Debates)
- 9990 Paper 22 (Research Methods)
- 9990 Paper 32 (Specialist Options: Approaches, Issues and Debates)
Practise and download
- Download 9990/42 and its mark scheme on the Learning Portal →
- All 9990 October/November 2025 papers: overview and marking patterns
- All 9990 May/June 2026 papers: overview and marking patterns
- Try a free A Level Psychology quiz
Need help with a 9990 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Psychology tutor →
Frequently asked questions
What came up on 9990 Paper 42 October/November 2025? +
Section A key studies were Lovell et al. (2006) for Clinical, Snyder and DeBono (1985) for Consumer, Savage and Armstrong (1990) for Health and Landry et al. (2019) for Organisational, with topic questions on Miller's feeling-state theory, Cialdini's scarcity, fear arousal and Scouller's private level of leadership. Section B set plans on a pyromania questionnaire, brand recognition in men and women, unrealistic optimism and praise or recognition at work.
How many questions do you answer on 9990/42? +
Five: the two Section A questions from each of your two options (18 marks per option, 36 in total) and one 24-mark planning question from Section B. You answer 60 marks in 1 hour 30 minutes, although the paper prints 168 marks across its four options.
What were the two measures in Lovell et al. (2006) asked about in 9990/42 Question 1(a)? +
The Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale (Y-BOCS) in its self-report version, with 10 items each scored 0 to 4 (a total of 0 to 40, from very mild to severe), and the Beck Depression Inventory, a secondary outcome measure with 21 items scored 0 to 3 (63 points maximum). Calling the Y-BOCS an interview earned no credit.
How are the 10-mark plans on 9990/42 marked? +
With a five-level AO2 application grid. Level 5 (9 to 10 marks) needs the method the question asks for, a good range of method-specific and general features in accurate detail, a plan coherent enough to replicate and good use of ethical guidelines. A plan that describes the syllabus study or is unethical scores zero.
How was the hypothesis part of the brand recognition plan on 9990/42 marked? +
Question 10(c)(i) gave 2 marks for a directional or non-directional hypothesis applied to the plan and worded correctly with a reason, and 1 if the wording was incomplete. A null hypothesis scored 0.
Where can I download 9990/42 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +
Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990 past papers page.
What is 9990_w25_qp_42? +
9990_w25_qp_42 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990 Paper 42 (Paper 4 Specialist Options: Application and Research Methods, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9990_w25_ms_42, and the code printed on the cover is 9990/42/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.
Ready to Excel in Your Studies?
Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.
Book Your Free TrialWritten by
Mahira Kitchil
Connect on LinkedIn →Project Head, Tutopiya
Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.
Related Articles
A Level Biology 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes
Free 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Paper 1 and Paper 3 with mark schemes: the topics tested, the practical tasks and how examiners awarded marks on each.
A Level Computer Science 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Marking
Free 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 papers and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of Papers 1 to 4 and how examiners gave marks for code and theory.
A Level Geography 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme
Free 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 papers, inserts and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of the data questions, options and essays and how they were levelled.
