Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 Approaches, Issues and Debates): Question-by-Question Guide
Past Papers

Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 Approaches, Issues and Debates): Question-by-Question Guide

Mahira Kitchil Project Head, Tutopiya
• 11 min read
Updated

Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990/12 is the October/November 2025 Paper 1 (Approaches, Issues and Debates), variant 2. It lasts 1 hour 30 minutes, is worth 60 marks and tests the AS Level core studies. All ten questions are compulsory, and every one names a core study. The biggest question is Question 9, worth 12 marks, on the participant in Saavedra and Silverman and how that study compares with Bandura et al., followed by the 10-mark evaluation of Pozzulo et al. This guide goes through the paper question by question and shows what the official mark scheme gave marks for. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.

For the newest series of the same paper, see 9990 Paper 12 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.

For an overview of all four 9990 papers from this series, see A Level Psychology 9990 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme.

9990/12 at a glance

Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9990/12/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9990_w25_qp_12 and the mark scheme file is 9990_w25_ms_12.

The rubric is: answer all questions. You write on the question paper.

QuestionSectionCore study and taskMarks
1AMilgram (obedience): the number who reached 450 volts, two signs of tension, the Yale students’ predictions5
2ABandura et al. (aggression): another conclusion, a weakness of the sample4
3APiliavin et al. (subway Samaritans): two features of the models, a result for the drunk victim4
4AHassett et al. (monkey toy preferences): how ethical guidelines for animals were followed4
5AHölzel et al. (mindfulness and brain scans): “acting with awareness”, a strength of the FFMQ4
6APerry et al. (personal space): biological factors from the background (3), whether the study was ethical (4)7
7ADement and Kleitman (sleep and dreams): the individual and situational explanations debate4
8AAndrade (doodling): advice for a language teacher (4), a reason for one piece of advice (2)6
9BSaavedra and Silverman (button phobia): the participant (4), a similarity and a difference with Bandura et al. (8)12
10BPozzulo et al. (line-ups): two strengths and two weaknesses, one about ecological validity10
Total60

Question-by-question walkthrough

Question 1: Milgram, obedience (5 marks)

  • 1(a) How many pressed the 450-volt switch (1 mark): 26. Only the first answer counts.
  • 1(b) Two signs of tension other than nervous laughter (2 marks): the list was definitive. Sweating, trembling or shaking, stuttering, biting lips, groaning, digging nails into their flesh, smiling, and violent convulsions or seizures. Verbal comments and asking to stop were accepted. Shouting was not, and repeating nervous laughter earned nothing.
  • 1(c) What the 14 Yale students were asked to predict (2 marks): the definitive points were that they reflected on the behaviour of 100 hypothetical people, plotted the distribution of obedience, and said what percentage, or how many, would press the 450-volt switch. “At which voltage they would stop” was credited for the last point. The students’ actual predictions were not credited, because the question asked what they were asked, not what they said.

Question 2: Bandura et al., aggression (4 marks)

  • 2(a) One other conclusion (2 marks): 2 for a full conclusion, 1 for a brief one. Two-mark examples: witnessing an aggressive act is enough to produce aggression in the observer; children reproduce aggressive behaviour when the model is no longer present; children are more likely to imitate a same-sex model. “Children will imitate aggression” and “girls are more likely to imitate verbal aggression” were worth 1. Watch the traps: a conclusion with no mention of aggression was capped at 1, a comparison with the no-model or non-aggressive model group was a result worth 1 at most, any mention of a “group” or “condition” scored 0, and “boys showed more gun aggression” is a result, not a conclusion.
  • 2(b) A weakness of the sample (2 marks): 1 for identifying it and 1 for an example from the study. The scheme’s answer: it is hard to generalise because all the children came from one university nursery, so they may not represent children in other nurseries or countries. “Not representative” and “cannot be applied” were accepted for the first mark. “Cannot generalise to adults” was not credited, and an ethics argument about using children earned 1 at most.

Question 3: Piliavin et al., subway Samaritans (4 marks)

  • 3(a) Two features of the models (2 marks): the list was definitive. White, male, aged 24 to 29, wearing informal clothes. There were four of them, and “boys”, “students” and “Caucasian” were accepted. “Adults” was not.
  • 3(b) A result for the drunk victim before any model helped (2 marks): 2 for a result with a meaningful comparison, 1 without one. Two-mark examples: a white drunk victim was helped more than a black drunk victim; more people left the critical area, or made comments, when the drunk victim was white; same-race helping was more common than other-race helping. The scheme also gave 2 for “the drunk victim received spontaneous help on 19 of 38 trials”. Comparing the drunk and ill victims was capped at 1, and speed of helping was ignored.

Question 4: Hassett et al., ethics with animals (4 marks)

One mark per correct point, and one of the four can be for naming a relevant guideline: harm or distress, species, number, housing, or reward and deprivation. You can still reach 4 without naming one. Credited points:

  • The monkeys were housed socially, matching a social species.
  • Food and water were available, so there was no deprivation.
  • They had a 25 m × 25 m outdoor enclosure and a temperature-controlled indoor area.
  • Environmental enrichment met the NIH guidelines.
  • The toys were not dangerous, so harm was minimised.
  • Rhesus monkeys were chosen because they are close to humans on the evolutionary scale (species).
  • Behaviour was recorded on cameras rather than watched directly, and testing took place in a familiar area, both to reduce stress.

Guidelines for human participants were ignored.

Question 5: Hölzel et al., the FFMQ (4 marks)

  • 5(a) “Acting with awareness” (2 marks): for 2 marks, you need both halves: focusing consciously on what you are doing now, as opposed to behaving automatically. “Focusing on current behaviour” alone earned 1, and so did “knowing what you are doing”. “Being aware of…” was not credited.
  • 5(b) A strength of the FFMQ (2 marks): 1 for the strength and 1 for an example from the study. The scheme’s answer: it gave quantitative data that allowed statistical comparison, so scores before and after the MBSR programme could be compared to see its effect. It being a standardised test, a baseline measure or used in other studies (reliable) were also credited. General strengths of the Hölzel study scored nothing, and so did anything being “easier”.

Question 6: Perry et al., personal space (7 marks)

  • 6(a) Biological factors in the background (3 marks): one mark per point, with no mark for naming a factor. Oxytocin plays a role in personal space, empathy and social salience; lesions in the amygdala reduce the need for personal space; amygdala activity in healthy people correlates with discomfort at close distances; oxytocin levels affect amygdala activation; in some contexts oxytocin promotes risk aversion or envy; and oxytocin affects the distance people keep from someone they find attractive. Perry’s own procedure and findings were not credited.
  • 6(b) One reason the study was ethical and one reason it was not (4 marks): for each friend, 1 mark for evidence or the relevant guideline and 1 for the explanation. Ethical side: written consent was taken and participants knew the study was about personal space and oxytocin; an ethics committee approved it; participants could press the spacebar to stop the approaching figure, which protected them from stress. Unethical side: in Experiment 2 participants were told they would chat with another participant, which never happened (deception) and might have been distressing; having your personal space invaded, even by an animation, can be stressful; and nobody could know how a participant would react to oxytocin, so there was a risk of physical harm.

The deception mark was only given when it was linked to distress. “Not knowing whether they had oxytocin or a placebo” was not credited as deception. If you used the same guideline for both friends, the guideline mark was given once, although physical and psychological harm counted separately.

Question 7: Dement and Kleitman, individual and situational explanations (4 marks)

1 mark for outlining each side and 1 for an example of each from the study. The individual side explains behaviour by factors within the person (dispositional); the situational side by factors in the external environment. The scheme’s examples: every dream reported was unique, such as people throwing tomatoes at each other, so individual personality shows in dreams; and participants slept in a laboratory with EEG electrodes attached, which may have affected how well they recalled dreams or estimated time in REM sleep.

Tautological definitions such as “individual factors” were ignored, and “different people have different dreams” did not earn the individual example mark.

Question 8: Andrade, advice for a language teacher (6 marks)

Carole’s students struggle to concentrate on, and recall, a recording of people speaking a second language.

  • 8(a) The advice (4 marks): one mark per piece of advice clearly based on Andrade. Credited ideas: give each student a sheet with shapes to shade in, with a margin to write down the target information; tell them not to worry about neatness; ask them to listen for specific pieces of information; tell them there will be a test afterwards; tell them not to draw their own doodles; and play the recording in a quiet room. “Ask them to start shading in the shapes” alone earned 2. “Doodle”, “doodling” or “a secondary task” on its own, scribbling, a monotonous recording, a surprise test and free drawing were not credited. A different named secondary task, such as a fidget toy, could earn 1. Justifying the advice earned nothing in part (a).
  • 8(b) A reason for one piece of advice (2 marks): 2 for a detailed reason, 1 for a brief one, and it must link to your answer in 8(a). Full marks: in Andrade’s study, the group who doodled while listening to a dull telephone message recalled more of the monitored and incidental information, so doodling helps concentration and recall. “Doodling aided memory recall” on its own was worth 1.

Question 9: Saavedra and Silverman and Bandura et al. (12 marks)

  • 9(a) The participant (4 marks): the list was definitive, one mark per point. A 9-year-old Hispanic American boy, brought by his mother to a Child Anxiety and Phobic Program; he met the DSM-IV criteria for a phobia but not for OCD; a bowl of buttons had fallen on him at school; and the phobia had started at age 5, four years before the study. “He had a phobia of buttons” earned nothing, because the question already says so.
  • 9(b) One similarity and one difference, not about sampling (8 marks): each half was levelled from 1 to 4.
LevelSimilarity or difference (each half)
4Well explained, using both studies as examples
3Well explained with only one study, or both studies used briefly
2Brief with an attempt at using one study, or well explained with no study evidence
1Brief, with no use of either study

Similarities the scheme suggested were collecting quantitative data and both being about learnt behaviour. Differences included experimental against non-experimental method and the learning theory each focuses on. The scheme’s model difference: Bandura focused on social learning through observation and imitation, while Saavedra and Silverman focused on operant and classical conditioning, with the boy rewarded by his mother during treatment, so one is about vicarious learning and the other about direct experience.

Watch the caps: “both used children” and “both from the learning approach” were Level 1 for a similarity, a different aim was Level 1 for a difference, and quantitative against qualitative data was capped at Level 2. A point that reads like a description of both studies, without saying explicitly what is similar or different, was Level 1.

Question 10: evaluate Pozzulo et al. (10 marks)

You had to give two strengths and two weaknesses, with at least one about ecological validity (the named issue). Strengths the scheme listed: reliability (standardisation), quantitative data, validity and ethics. Weaknesses: ecological validity, ethics, generalisability and quantitative data.

The scheme showed three grades of point. In detail: the procedure was standardised, with the same line-up instructions for everyone and Dora and Diego as the cartoon targets, so it can be replicated and tested for reliability. Brief but in context: the sample came from a participant pool at an Eastern Ontario university, so they may not represent others because they could be more motivated. With no context: “there were controls, so cause and effect can be established”.

The essay was marked with five levels:

  • Level 5 (9–10): very good evaluation including the named issue, with both strengths and both weaknesses in detail.
  • Level 4 (7–8): good evaluation including the named issue, three or four points with most in depth.
  • Level 3 (5–6): mostly appropriate evaluation that may not include the named issue; two points in detail, or all four briefly.
  • Level 2 (3–4): weak evaluation of a strength or a weakness; brief points, some without context.
  • Levels 1 and 0: little or no evaluation, or nothing creditable.

Where the marks are on 9990/12

Split by what each question asks you to do:

SkillQuestionsMarks
Recall study details (state, identify, describe, outline a result)1, 3, 6(a), 9(a)16
Outline a conclusion, concept, strength or weakness with study evidence2, 5, 712
Ethics in a named study4, 6(b)8
Apply a study to everyday life86
Compare two studies9(b)8
Evaluate a study1010
Total60
  • Recall carries 16 marks, and much of it is from definitive lists, so precise details (26 participants, models aged 24 to 29, a 9-year-old boy) score directly.
  • Ethics carries 8 marks across two studies, one with animals and one with humans. Hassett et al. needed the animal guidelines, and human guidelines were ignored there.
  • The two Section B questions are 22 marks, and both the 8-mark comparison and the 10-mark essay reward explanation with study evidence more than description.

How to self-mark 9990/12 with the mark scheme

  1. Learn the layout. A slash or “or” separates ways of making the same point; semicolons, bullets or a (1) separate different points. Text in brackets is context for the examiner and is not needed for the mark. “List is definitive” means only the points listed can score.
  2. Mark the two-part answers in halves. For 2(b), 5(b), 6(b) and 7, award the identification or guideline mark first, then check the example really comes from the named study.
  3. Strike out results in Question 2(a) and anything already given in the question (nervous laughter in 1(b), the button phobia in 9(a)).
  4. Check each piece of advice in Question 8(a) is clearly from Andrade. “Doodle” on its own does not count.
  5. Level each half of 9(b) separately. Ask whether you explained the point and whether you used both studies, then apply the Level 1 and Level 2 caps.
  6. Find the named issue in Question 10 first. Levels 4 and 5 both require it, so if ecological validity is missing, your mark cannot go above 6. Then count how many of the four points are detailed and in context.
  7. Log each lost mark as a missing study detail, a missing example or a missing explanation, and revise that study next.

Sit 9990/12 as a timed mock

The paper allows 90 minutes for 60 marks, one and a half minutes per mark. A workable plan:

BlockMarksTime
Section A, Questions 1 to 83852 minutes
Question 9(a) and 9(b)1217 minutes
Question 10 essay (plan the four points first)1016 minutes
Check examples, the named issue and that 9(b) avoids sampling–5 minutes
Total6090 minutes

Decide before you write Question 10 which point covers ecological validity, and put it first.

9990/12 in other series

Eight of the ten core studies on this paper came up again in May/June 2026: Milgram, Piliavin et al., Hassett et al., Hölzel et al., Dement and Kleitman, Andrade, Saavedra and Silverman, and Pozzulo et al. The roles changed, though. Pozzulo et al. was the 10-mark essay here and the individual and situational question in 2026, while Andrade was an advice question here and a background question in 2026. Bandura et al. and Perry et al. appeared only in 2025.

Other October/November 2025 9990 papers

Practise and download

Need help with a 9990 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Psychology tutor →

Frequently asked questions

Which core studies came up on 9990 Paper 12 October/November 2025? +

Ten: Milgram (obedience), Bandura et al. (aggression), Piliavin et al. (subway Samaritans), Hassett et al. (monkey toy preferences), Hölzel et al. (mindfulness and brain scans), Perry et al. (personal space), Dement and Kleitman (sleep and dreams), Andrade (doodling), Saavedra and Silverman (button phobia) and Pozzulo et al. (line-ups).

How many marks is 9990/12 and how long is it? +

It is out of 60 marks and lasts 1 hour 30 minutes. All ten questions are compulsory: eight short questions in Section A worth 38 marks and two longer questions in Section B worth 22.

How many participants went to 450 volts in Milgram, as asked in 9990/12 Question 1(a)? +

26. It was a 1-mark question, and only the first answer given was marked.

How was the 10-mark Pozzulo et al. essay on 9990/12 marked? +

With a five-level grid. The named issue was ecological validity. Level 5 (9 to 10 marks) needed very good evaluation that included the named issue and covered both strengths and both weaknesses in detail. Level 4 also needed the named issue, so an answer without it could not go above Level 3 (6 marks).

How was the similarity and difference question on 9990/12 marked? +

Question 9(b) compared Saavedra and Silverman with Bandura et al. It gave up to 4 marks for the similarity and 4 for the difference, each levelled separately. Level 4 needed the point well explained using both studies. Saying both used children, or that both come from the learning approach, scored only Level 1.

Where can I download 9990/12 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +

Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990 past papers page.

What is 9990_w25_qp_12? +

9990_w25_qp_12 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level Psychology 9990 Paper 12 (Paper 1 Approaches, Issues and Debates, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9990_w25_ms_12, and the code printed on the cover is 9990/12/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.

Ready to Excel in Your Studies?

Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.

Book Your Free Trial
M

Written by

Mahira Kitchil

Connect on LinkedIn →

Project Head, Tutopiya

Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.

Mahira Kitchil on LinkedIn

Get Started

Courses

Company

Subjects & Curriculums

Resources

Book a Tutor

Struggling with this topic?

Practise A Level Psychology with free topic quizzes