Cambridge International AS & A Level Global Perspectives & Research 9239/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 Written Exam): Question-by-Question Guide
Cambridge International AS & A Level Global Perspectives & Research 9239/12 is the October/November 2025 Paper 1 (Written Exam), variant 2. It lasts 1 hour 30 minutes, is worth 45 marks and you answer all three questions on two documents in the insert. Both documents are about climate activism, and the questions build from 5 marks of short identification to a 15-mark evaluation of one document’s evidence and a 25-mark comparison of both arguments. This guide goes through every question and shows what the official mark scheme credited and how its grids turn annotations into marks. The paper, the insert and the mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.
9239/12 at a glance
Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9239/12/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9239_w25_qp_12, the mark scheme file is 9239_w25_ms_12 and the insert file is 9239_w25_in_12.
Rubric: answer all questions. Spend about 15 minutes reading both documents first; this is included in the time. Answer Question 1 briefly, in short sentences or bullet points, and Questions 2 and 3 in continuous prose.
| Question | Documents | Task | AOs | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1(a) | A | Identify two scientists who comment on scientists’ role in climate activism | AO1 | 2 |
| 1(b) | B | Identify three newspapers that published articles criticising climate activism | AO1 | 3 |
| 2 | A | Assess the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence for scientists’ civil disobedience, including its impact on the argument | AO1 | 15 |
| 3 | A and B | Evaluate both arguments, consider both perspectives and judge whether one is stronger | AO1 20, AO3 5 | 25 |
| Total | 45 |
Question-by-question walkthrough
The two documents
- Document A is adapted from a 2022 article in Inside Climate News, a Pulitzer Prize-winning non-profit news organisation in the US, by Kristoffer Tigue, a journalist who writes about environmental justice. It reports climate scientists urging colleagues to risk arrest through civil disobedience, citing a Nature article, protests by around 1000 scientists in more than 25 countries, extreme weather including the Pakistan floods, and comments from two scientists.
- Document B is adapted from an October 2022 article in Guardian Australia by Jeff Sparrow, a Melbourne-based writer, editor and former activist. It defends art gallery protests, such as the soup thrown at Van Gogh’s Sunflowers, argues that no art was damaged, criticises journalists who attacked the activists, and ends by saying that anyone who dislikes gallery protests should organise something better.
The scheme defines a perspective as a coherent world view in response to an issue, made up of argument, evidence and assumptions, and possibly influenced by a particular context.
Question 1: identifying information (5 marks)
One mark per correct answer, ticked in the text.
- 1(a), two scientists (2 marks): Tierra Curry and Peter Kalmus. Rejected: Sherry Rehman and Kristoffer Tigue (neither is a scientist), and any other name.
- 1(b), three newspapers (3 marks): The Australian, the Courier Mail and the Herald Sun. Rejected: the IPCC (a report, not a newspaper) and The Guardian, because the document does not say it published an article critical of climate activism.
Both parts reward careful reading of the exact question. Document A names other people, and Document B names other publications, that do not fit.
Question 2: evaluating Document A’s evidence (15 marks)
You assess the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence the author uses to argue that climate scientists need to engage in civil disobedience to save the planet, including the impact of the evidence on the argument. There are three aspects, each marked out of 5:
- AO1a, identifying evidence (5): name a type of evidence and give an example. Examiners annotate T for a type alone and EG for a type with an example. Four or more EG earns 5; three EG earns 4; two EG earns 3; two T or one EG earns 2; one T earns 1.
- AO1b, strengths and weaknesses (5): each strength (+) or weakness (–) with limited explanation, and EXP for one clearly explained. The top mark needs at least two strengths and two weaknesses with two or more clearly explained. Two of one and one of the other with one explained earns 4; the same with none explained earns 3. Only strengths or only weaknesses caps you at 2.
- AO1c, impact on the argument (5): an asserted impact (A) earns 1; an attempted but unexplained evaluation earns 2; one explained impact on the argument (I) earns 3; two or more earn 4; and two or more plus an explained impact with a judgement of its effectiveness (I J) earn 5.
Strengths in the scheme’s indicative list:
- Relevant statistics: the projected 3.2 °C of warming by 2100, USD 10 billion of damage and a third of Pakistan under water. The scheme’s model paragraph explains that precise figures look carefully calculated and objective, which makes readers more likely to believe that urgent action is needed.
- Reputable and named expert sources: the Nature article, Peter Kalmus of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Lab, Tierra Curry of the US Center for Biological Diversity and Climate Minister Sherry Rehman.
- Relevant examples of protest action, such as blocking traffic, deflating car tyres, interrupting sporting events and gluing themselves to artworks.
- Corroboration: Nature, Kalmus, Curry and the leading scientists all say the same thing about the climate.
- The author and publisher: a journalist covering environmental justice, writing for a credible organisation; he is based in the US, where some of the action took place.
- Global scope and recency: evidence from the US, Europe and Pakistan, in a 2022 article describing then-current events.
- Direct quotations from experts and activists.
Weaknesses in the scheme’s list:
- Approximate figures, such as around 1000 scientists, more than 25 countries, several scientists and thousands killed.
- Unsourced evidence and predictions, such as saying extreme weather events are further evidence, or that scientists expect things to worsen dramatically.
- Vague, unnamed experts, such as a group of climate scientists or a growing number of leading scientists.
- Unsupported claims, such as the monsoon being made worse by climate change, with no data given.
- Lack of balance: only scientists who support the argument are quoted.
- Possible lack of expertise: the author is a journalist, not an academic.
- No evidence of impact: the protests are listed, but we are not told what effect they had.
- Imprecise dates, such as “this summer”.
No set answer is expected, and other valid comments about the evidence are credited. Technical terms earn nothing unless linked directly to the assessment you make.
Question 3: comparing the two arguments (25 marks)
You evaluate both authors’ arguments, consider their perspectives and reach a reasoned judgement about whether one argument is stronger. There are five aspects, each out of 5:
- AO1a, key components (5): K for a component identified in one document, C for one compared across both. Three or more C earns 5, two C earns 4 and one C earns 3; two or more K with no comparison earns 2.
- AO1b, perspectives (5): comparing and explaining both perspectives (PE) earns 5; comparing and describing them (PD) earns 4; identifying both with limited description earns 3. The scheme’s model PE answer: Document A reports scientists’ perspective that they should act to change government policy, because their expertise and status can convince governments; Document B’s perspective is that everyone must play a part and doing something is better than nothing, because urgent action is needed and even stunts can work.
- AO1c, evaluating arguments (5): the top mark needs evaluation illustrated by clear, balanced reference to both documents (at least one EVAL per document). Clear reference that lacks balance earns 4. An answer that does not mention both documents cannot get more than 1.
- AO1d, judgement (5): a clearly reasoned and supported judgement with intermediate conclusions and a main conclusion earns 5; with only one of these, 4. A partly supported judgement earns 3, a reasoned but unsupported one 2, and a bare statement 1.
- AO3, communication (5): a clearly written, well-structured, logical argument focused on the question throughout. The guidance starts a clear, continuous-prose answer at 3. An introduction, clear paragraphs, balanced treatment of both documents and a judgement can reach 4; add logic and no irrelevant content for 5. Bullet points or very little content cap it at 2, and no attempt to develop an argument caps it at 1.
Components of the arguments the scheme suggests comparing:
- Structure: its model answer argues Document A is better organised, from a clear introduction through reasoned, evidenced paragraphs to its conclusion, while Document B jumps from the soup protest to criticising other journalists before its closing line.
- Author credibility: Document B’s author has a background in activism, which suits a piece about activism; Document A’s author is a journalist.
- Points of view: Document A has one view, that scientists must act; Document B briefly weighs two ways of protesting, mass collective action against stunts.
- Variety of action and impact: Document A gives several types of protest but says little about their impact; Document B gives only art protests but does describe impacts to some extent.
- Scope: Document A refers to several countries; Document B is almost entirely about Australia, with a brief mention of London.
- Sources: Document A uses more expert and reputable sources; Document B uses more unsourced or anecdotal information.
- Language: Document B uses more emotional language, while Document A is more neutral.
- Themes: Document A focuses on environmental and economic themes, Document B on social ones.
Judgement: the scheme accepts Document A as stronger (structure, expert sources and evidence), Document B as stronger (first-hand experience and the way it answers counter-arguments), or both as equally strong. At each point of comparison you may argue either way. The marks are for how well the judgement is reasoned and supported.
Where the marks are on 9239/12
| Aspect | Question | Marks |
|---|---|---|
| Identifying information | 1(a), 1(b) | 5 |
| Identifying types of evidence with examples (AO1a) | 2 | 5 |
| Strengths and weaknesses of evidence (AO1b) | 2 | 5 |
| Impact of evidence on the argument (AO1c) | 2 | 5 |
| Comparing key components of arguments (AO1a) | 3 | 5 |
| Comparing perspectives (AO1b) | 3 | 5 |
| Evaluating arguments (AO1c) | 3 | 5 |
| Judgement (AO1d) | 3 | 5 |
| Communication (AO3) | 3 | 5 |
| Total | 45 |
- Forty of the 45 marks are AO1 (research, analysis and evaluation). Only 5 marks, in Question 3, are for communication.
- Questions 2 and 3 are marked aspect by aspect. Each 5-mark aspect has its own grid, so a strong judgement cannot make up for missing comparison, and vice versa.
- Balance matters at the top. Question 2’s best AO1b mark needs both strengths and weaknesses; Question 3’s best AO1c mark needs balanced reference to both documents.
How to self-mark 9239/12 with the mark scheme
- Mark Question 1 strictly. Only the names in the scheme count. A non-scientist in 1(a) or The Guardian in 1(b) scores nothing.
- Annotate Question 2 like an examiner. Write T or EG beside each type of evidence, + or – beside each strength or weakness, EXP where it is clearly explained, and A, I or I J for each comment on impact. Then read each mark off its grid.
- Check for a judgement in Question 2. The top AO1c mark needs at least one explained impact that also judges how effective the evidence is.
- Count comparisons in Question 3. A point about one document is K; a point that links both is C. Three or more C is needed for the top AO1a mark.
- Check you explained the perspectives. Describing what each author thinks reaches PD; saying why they think it reaches PE.
- Look for intermediate conclusions. A short judgement at the end of each comparison, plus a main conclusion, is what the top AO1d mark describes.
- Mark communication last. Start at 3 for clear continuous prose and move up or down using the scheme’s guidance.
Sit 9239/12 as a timed mock
The paper allows 90 minutes for 45 marks, including the 15 minutes of reading the paper recommends.
| Block | Marks | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Read and annotate both documents | – | 15 minutes |
| Question 1 | 5 | 5 minutes |
| Plan Question 2 | – | 5 minutes |
| Write Question 2 | 15 | 20 minutes |
| Plan Question 3 | – | 7 minutes |
| Write Question 3 | 25 | 33 minutes |
| Check the judgement and the balance between documents | – | 5 minutes |
Practise and download
- Download 9239/12, the insert and the mark scheme on the Learning Portal →
- Try a free A Level Global Perspectives & Research quiz
Need help with a 9239 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level Global Perspectives & Research tutor →
Frequently asked questions
What was 9239 Paper 12 October/November 2025 about? +
Climate activism. Document A, from Inside Climate News, reports scientists calling on colleagues to commit civil disobedience to push governments into faster climate action. Document B, from Guardian Australia, defends climate activists' art gallery protests and criticises the journalists who attack them.
How many marks is 9239/12 and how long is it? +
It lasts 1 hour 30 minutes and is out of 45 marks. You answer all three questions: Question 1 is worth 5 marks, Question 2 is worth 15 and Question 3 is worth 25. The paper advises about 15 minutes reading the two documents, which is included in the time.
What were the answers to 9239/12 Question 1? +
1(a): the two scientists in Document A are Tierra Curry and Peter Kalmus. Sherry Rehman and Kristoffer Tigue were rejected because they are not scientists. 1(b): the three newspapers in Document B are The Australian, the Courier Mail and the Herald Sun. The Guardian and the IPCC report were rejected.
How is 9239/12 Question 2 marked? +
It is out of 15, with 5 marks each for identifying types of evidence with examples (AO1a), analysing strengths and weaknesses with explanation (AO1b) and evaluating the impact of the evidence on the argument with a judgement (AO1c). Examiners count annotations for each aspect to set the mark.
Which document was stronger in 9239/12 Question 3? +
The mark scheme accepts any reasoned conclusion: Document A stronger, Document B stronger, or both equally strong. What earns marks is comparing key components of the arguments, explaining both perspectives, evaluating with reference to both documents, and a supported judgement with intermediate and main conclusions.
Where can I download 9239/12 October/November 2025, the insert and the mark scheme? +
All three are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge International AS & A Level Global Perspectives & Research 9239 past papers page.
What is 9239_w25_qp_12? +
9239_w25_qp_12 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge International AS & A Level Global Perspectives & Research 9239 Paper 12 (Paper 1 Written Exam, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9239_w25_ms_12, and the code printed on the cover is 9239/12/O/N/25. The insert that goes with it is 9239_w25_in_12. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.
Ready to Excel in Your Studies?
Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.
Book Your Free TrialWritten by
Mahira Kitchil
Connect on LinkedIn →Project Head, Tutopiya
Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.
Related Articles
A Level Biology 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes
Free 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Paper 1 and Paper 3 with mark schemes: the topics tested, the practical tasks and how examiners awarded marks on each.
A Level Computer Science 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Marking
Free 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 papers and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of Papers 1 to 4 and how examiners gave marks for code and theory.
A Level Geography 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme
Free 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 papers, inserts and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of the data questions, options and essays and how they were levelled.
