Cambridge AS & A Level English Language 9093/12 October/November 2025 (Paper 1 Reading): Question-by-Question Guide
Cambridge AS & A Level English Language 9093/12 is the October/November 2025 Paper 1 (Reading), variant 2, an AS Level component. It lasts 2 hours 15 minutes, is worth 50 marks and you answer both questions: a two-part directed response worth 25 marks and a 25-mark text analysis. There is no choice, so the challenge is pacing: Question 2 is the single biggest task, and the 15-mark comparison in Question 1(b) is worth more than the email you write for it. This guide covers every part and explains how the official mark scheme’s assessment objective (AO) grids give marks. The paper and its mark scheme are free on the Tutopiya Learning Portal.
For the newest series of the same paper, see 9093 Paper 12 May/June 2026: questions and mark scheme.
9093/12 at a glance
Paper codes: the code printed on the cover is 9093/12/O/N/25, the question paper file is 9093_w25_qp_12 and the mark scheme file is 9093_w25_ms_12.
Rubric: answer all questions. Dictionaries are not allowed.
| Question | Section | Text and task | AOs | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1(a) | A: Directed response | Using a visitor guide article on the Minack Theatre, write a 150 to 200-word email to a friend or relative suggesting a visit | AO1 5, AO2 5 | 10 |
| 1(b) | A: Directed response | Compare your email with the article: form, structure and language | AO1 5, AO3 10 | 15 |
| 2 | B: Text analysis | Extract from a book about natural wonders: the narrator’s encounter with a whale shark | AO1 5, AO3 20 | 25 |
| Total | 50 |
Question-by-question walkthrough
How every question is marked
Each part has its own grid with one column per AO. The examiner places your answer in a level (5 down to 1, plus 0) for each AO separately and adds the marks.
- AO1 (understanding) rewards accurate understanding of the text’s meaning, context and audience and reference to its characteristic features. Where comparison is needed, it rewards recognising similarities and differences, not analysing them.
- AO2 (writing) is judged equally on expression (range of features and accuracy) and development (organisation and relevance to task and audience).
- AO3 (analysis) is judged equally on analysing form, structure and language and on how the writer’s stylistic choices relate to audience and shape meaning.
- Best fit. Within a level, each bullet point counts equally. The notes for each question are illustrative, not exhaustive, and other valid comments are credited.
Question 1(a): the Minack Theatre email (10 marks)
The source is a complete visitor guide to the Minack Theatre, a Greek-inspired open-air amphitheatre on the cliffs above Porthcurno Beach in Cornwall. It describes the setting and views, then the history: Rowena Cade began building it in 1929 with her gardener, Billy Rawlings; the first performance was The Tempest in 1932; and she gave it to a charitable trust in 1976. You live in Cornwall, and a friend or family member visiting the area has asked for ideas. You write an email suggesting a trip to the theatre, in 150 to 200 words.
- Marks: AO1 and AO2, 5 marks each. Each level is worth one mark, from 1 (basic) to 5 (sophisticated).
- What the scheme expects: form, audience, purpose, style, conventions, language and structure adapted to the task. Content might include personal references and advice about the different aspects of the site, and the tone may advise but could also inform.
- Moving up: AO1 rises from minimal to insightful reference to the article’s characteristic features, so draw on what the article says about the setting and the history. AO2 rises from frequent errors that impede communication to sophisticated expression with a high level of accuracy and ideas developed throughout.
- The word limit: there is no direct penalty, but staying within 150 to 200 words counts towards relevance to purpose in the AO2 column.
Question 1(b): comparing your email with the article (15 marks)
- Marks: AO1 5 (one mark per level) and AO3 10 (Level 5 is 9 to 10, Level 4 is 7 to 8, Level 3 is 5 to 6, Level 2 is 3 to 4, Level 1 is 1 to 2).
- Form points in the scheme: the typical conventions of each text, how their different purposes affect content and style, and how each appeals to its audience, for example through tone and register.
- Structure points: how headings and paragraphs or sections are used in the article, how it develops the subject, how it moves between aspects such as the history, past productions and the setting, and how it ends.
- Language points:
- Facts and history, such as the 1976 donation, the Cornish origin of the name and the stage first lit by batteries and car headlights.
- Rowena Cade’s investment in the site: her privileged upbringing set against building the theatre with her own hands and etching designs into wet cement with a screwdriver.
- Descriptions of beauty, remoteness and uniqueness, such as golden cliffs, turquoise sea and craggy granite.
- Superlatives that impress the reader, such as “most beautiful” and “most unique and magical”.
- Named places, such as Porthcurno Bay and the Lizard peninsula, adding credibility to what seems an incredible site.
- Colloquial expressions, such as being “blown away”.
- Lists, such as the four qualities given to Billy Rawlings.
- Direct address to draw the reader in.
- A sense of isolation, remoteness and even danger, in details such as the sheer drop into the ocean.
- Moving up: the top three AO3 levels all describe comparative analysis. Levels 2 and 1 describe limited or minimal comparison. Writing about each text in turn, without linking them, keeps you low in both columns. You may organise the answer in any appropriate way and don’t need separate sections for form, structure and language.
Question 2: the whale shark (25 marks)
The text is an extract from a book about natural wonders of the world. The narrator describes swimming with sharks for the first time, including a whale shark, in an environment that turns out to be artificial, and ends angry at the creatures being kept there.
- Marks: AO1 5 (one mark per level) and AO3 20 (Level 5 is 17 to 20, Level 4 is 13 to 16, Level 3 is 9 to 12, Level 2 is 5 to 8, Level 1 is 1 to 4).
- Form: the typical conventions of non-fiction, how the purpose affects content and style, and how the extract appeals to its audience through tone and register.
- Structure: the use of minor, short and long sentences and short and long paragraphs, and how the extract is shaped to follow the narrator’s experience as she swims with the sharks for the first time.
- Language points in the scheme:
- Her vivid imagination and fears, such as being sure she would be swallowed whole.
- A lexical field of fear: terror, terrified, frighten, wept.
- Repetition and anaphora in “I wasn’t prepared for…”, showing how reality differs from her expectations.
- The dive master’s speech, which develops from bland reassurance into panic, including the shouted “Flaaat!”.
- The physical impact on the narrator: she can barely walk after tensing every muscle for half an hour, and weeps with her face in her hands.
- Lists, for example of the dangers: the different species of shark she names.
- Disgust at the artificial, limited environment the creatures are trapped in, with its planted coral and fake sea-cliff.
- The conclusion’s anaphora, a run of short fragments beginning “For…”, which conveys her anger.
- Moving up: Level 4 needs detailed, coherent, effectively structured analysis with an effective selection of features. Level 5 needs sophisticated, insightful selection and precise language linking evidence with explanatory comments. Awareness of how style relates to audience and meaning appears in every level from 3 up.
Where the marks are on 9093/12
| Assessment objective | Q1(a) | Q1(b) | Q2 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AO1 Understanding | 5 | 5 | 5 | 15 |
| AO2 Writing | 5 | – | – | 5 |
| AO3 Analysis | – | 10 | 20 | 30 |
| Total | 10 | 15 | 25 | 50 |
- Analysis is 60% of the paper. Your own writing earns only 5 marks, so a polished email cannot make up for a thin comparison or analysis.
- AO1 is 5 marks in every part. It is the same kind of grid each time: understanding of meaning, context and audience, and reference to characteristic features.
- Question 2 is twice the analysis of Question 1(b). Give it the most time.
How to self-mark 9093/12 with the mark scheme
- Count your email. Check it sits within 150 to 200 words before you mark it; this feeds the AO2 relevance bullet.
- Check the email does the task. It should suggest the Minack Theatre to someone you know, give advice about the site, and sound like an email from a local rather than a copy of the guide.
- Mark each AO separately. For every part, place the answer in a level for each column, then add. Do not average across columns.
- Test 1(b) for comparison. Highlight each paragraph that covers both texts. If most cover only one, the Level 2 wording (“limited comparison”) probably fits.
- Check your evidence-to-comment link in Question 2. For each feature, ask whether you said what it does for the reader. Naming features without an effect points to Level 2 or 1.
- Compare with the scheme’s notes, but don’t treat them as a checklist. Credit valid points the notes do not list.
- Choose the mark within the level by best fit. Weigh each bullet equally, then pick the top or bottom of the band.
Sit 9093/12 as a timed mock
The paper allows 135 minutes for 50 marks.
| Block | Marks | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Read the Minack Theatre article and plan the email | – | 10 minutes |
| Write the email (1(a)) | 10 | 20 minutes |
| Plan and write the comparison (1(b)) | 15 | 35 minutes |
| Read the whale shark extract and plan | – | 15 minutes |
| Write the analysis (Question 2) | 25 | 50 minutes |
| Check the word count and the links between evidence and comment | – | 5 minutes |
9093/12 in other series
The shape and the AO grids were the same in May/June 2026: a 150 to 200-word directed response from an article, a 15-mark comparison and a 25-mark analysis. The 2026 directed response was a magazine advertisement rather than an email, and its Question 2 text was a food website article, where this paper used a first-person narrative extract.
Practise and download
- Download 9093/12 and its mark scheme on the Learning Portal →
- All 9093 May/June 2026 papers: overview and marking patterns
- Try a free A Level English Language quiz
Need help with a 9093 topic? Book a free trial lesson with an A Level English Language tutor →
Frequently asked questions
What texts were set on 9093 Paper 12 October/November 2025? +
Question 1 used a visitor guide article about the Minack Theatre, an open-air theatre built into the cliffs in Cornwall by Rowena Cade. Question 2 used an extract from a book about natural wonders of the world, in which the narrator describes her encounter with a whale shark.
How long is 9093/12 and how many marks is it worth? +
It lasts 2 hours 15 minutes and is worth 50 marks. You answer both questions: Question 1 has two parts worth 10 and 15 marks, and Question 2 is worth 25 marks.
What did you have to write in 9093/12 Question 1(a)? +
You live in Cornwall, and a friend or family member planning to spend time in the area has asked for advice on interesting places to visit. You write an email suggesting a trip to the Minack Theatre, in 150 to 200 words.
Is there a penalty for going over 200 words in 9093/12 Question 1(a)? +
There is no direct penalty. The mark scheme treats keeping to 150 to 200 words as part of relevance to purpose, the second AO2 bullet, so a response well outside the limit can lose marks there.
Which assessment objective matters most on 9093/12? +
AO3 analysis. It carries 30 of the 50 marks: 10 in the Question 1(b) comparison and 20 in the Question 2 text analysis. AO1 understanding carries 15 marks and AO2 writing only 5.
Where can I download 9093/12 October/November 2025 and its mark scheme? +
Both are free to download and print on the Tutopiya Learning Portal, on the Cambridge AS & A Level English Language 9093 past papers page.
What is 9093_w25_qp_12? +
9093_w25_qp_12 is the file name of the question paper for Cambridge AS & A Level English Language 9093 Paper 12 (Paper 1 Reading, variant 2), October/November 2025. Its mark scheme is 9093_w25_ms_12, and the code printed on the cover is 9093/12/O/N/25. In these file names, w25 means the October/November 2025 series, qp means question paper and ms means mark scheme.
Ready to Excel in Your Studies?
Get personalised help from Tutopiya's expert tutors. Whether it's IGCSE, IB, A-Levels, or any other curriculum — we match you with the perfect tutor and your first session is free.
Book Your Free TrialWritten by
Mahira Kitchil
Connect on LinkedIn →Project Head, Tutopiya
Mahira Kitchil is a Project Head at Tutopiya, where she works with Cambridge IGCSE and Edexcel A-Level teachers in more than 20 countries on how exams are set and marked. She writes practical guides that help students find the right past papers and use the mark scheme the way examiners do, so every practice paper counts.
Related Articles
A Level Biology 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Mark Schemes
Free 9700 Oct/Nov 2025 Paper 1 and Paper 3 with mark schemes: the topics tested, the practical tasks and how examiners awarded marks on each.
A Level Computer Science 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers & Marking
Free 9618 Oct/Nov 2025 papers and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of Papers 1 to 4 and how examiners gave marks for code and theory.
A Level Geography 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 Papers: Topics & Mark Scheme
Free 9696 Oct/Nov 2025 papers, inserts and mark schemes, plus a paper-by-paper breakdown of the data questions, options and essays and how they were levelled.
