Which opinion fits an inventory the directors will not correct
During the audit of Brennan plc for the year ended 31 March 2026, the external auditor found that closing inventory is overstated by $64 000. Profit before tax is $900 000. The directors refuse to change the financial statements. The auditor is satisfied that every other figure is free from material misstatement.
Which audit opinion should the auditor give?
A an unmodified opinion, because the directors are responsible for the financial statements
B a qualified opinion, stating that the statements give a true and fair view except for the inventory
C an adverse opinion, stating that the statements do not give a true and fair view
D a disclaimer of opinion, because the auditor cannot form an opinion
[1]
- 1
Is it material? 64 000 ÷ 900 000 × 100 = 7.11% of profit before tax, above the usual 5% guide, so the misstatement is material and the opinion cannot be clean.
- 2
Is it pervasive? The error is confined to one item, inventory (and so profit and net assets by the same amount). The rest of the statements can be relied on, so the auditor modifies the opinion only for that item: a qualified, 'except for' opinion. Answer B (1).
- 3
Why the others are wrong. A is the error of thinking the directors' refusal settles the matter; the auditor reports independently to the shareholders and cannot ignore a material misstatement. C is the error of treating one material item as pervasive; an adverse opinion is for misstatements so widespread that the statements as a whole are misleading. D is the error of confusing a disagreement with a lack of evidence; the auditor has the evidence here and knows the amount.
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: choose the opinion with two questions: is the problem material, and is it pervasive? Material but not pervasive gives 'except for'; material and pervasive gives adverse (if it is a misstatement) or a disclaimer (if evidence is missing).
Common mistake: picking D because the directors 'will not co-operate'. A disclaimer is for when the auditor cannot obtain sufficient evidence, not for when the directors refuse to correct a known error.