Checking that every customer balance was transferred
A business is transferring its manual records to a computerised accounting system. Each customer's balance is keyed into the new receivables ledger.
Which check gives the best evidence that the individual customer balances have been transferred completely?
A The debit and credit totals of the computer trial balance agree with each other.
B The total of the computer's list of customer balances agrees with the balance of the manual sales ledger control account at the changeover date.
C The bank balance in the computer agrees with the bank statement at the changeover date.
D Every customer code keyed in passes an existence check.
[1]
- 1
Reject A. A computerised system will not accept unequal opening debits and credits; it posts any difference to a suspense or opening-balance difference account. So the computer trial balance always 'agrees' with itself and tells us nothing about missing customers.
- 2
Reject C and D. The bank balance has nothing to do with customer balances (C). An existence check only shows that each code keyed belongs to a real customer; it cannot detect a customer who was never keyed at all (D).
- 3
Choose B. The manual control account balance is an independent total of all the individual customer balances. If the computer's list adds up to the same figure, no customer has been left out or keyed at the wrong amount overall. Answer B (1).
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: a control total checks completeness only if it comes from a different source from the figures being checked. The manual control account was built from the sales journal totals, so it is a genuine independent check on the list of customer balances.
Common mistake: choosing A because 'the trial balance balances'. In a computerised system the double entry is automatic, so an agreed trial balance on its own is not evidence that the transfer was complete.