How far can the annual inflow fall
Corran Ltd is considering a machine costing $120 000, payable now. It is expected to produce net cash inflows of $40 000 at the end of each of the next four years. The cost of capital is 10%.
| Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Discount factor at 10% | 0.909 | 0.826 | 0.751 | 0.683 |
By what percentage could the annual net cash inflow fall before the net present value of the project becomes zero?
A 4.23%
B 5.33%
C 5.63%
D 16.90%
[1]
- 1
NPV. Present value of inflows = 40 000 × (0.909 + 0.826 + 0.751 + 0.683) = 40 000 × 3.169 = $126 760. NPV = 126 760 − 120 000 = $6 760.
- 2
Sensitivity. The inflows can lose $6 760 of present value before NPV is zero. Because every year's inflow falls by the same percentage, the fall = 6 760 ÷ 126 760 × 100 = 5.33%. Answer B (1).
- 3
Why the others fail. A divides the NPV by the undiscounted inflows (4 × 40 000 = 160 000). C divides by the initial cost of $120 000. D divides by one year's inflow of $40 000, as if only one year's cash could fall.
- 4
What the figure tells the directors. The annual inflow can fall only to about $37 870 before the project stops adding value, so a small error in the forecast would change the decision.
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: the percentage fall in an inflow that makes NPV zero is the NPV divided by the present value of that inflow, not by the undiscounted total or the cost. The smaller the percentage, the riskier the decision to accept.
Common mistake: choosing C. The initial cost is not the figure that falls; it is the present value of the inflows that must shrink by $6 760.