The principle breached by an undisclosed family interest
Darius is the management accountant of Brightwater Ltd. He has been asked to compare three tenders for a new payroll system and recommend one to the board. One of the tendering firms is owned by his brother-in-law. Darius recommends that firm and does not tell the board about the relationship.
Which fundamental ethical principle has Darius most clearly failed to follow?
A confidentiality
B objectivity
C professional behaviour
D professional competence and due care
[1]
- 1
What the principle requires. Objectivity means not allowing bias, a conflict of interest or the undue influence of others to override professional judgement. A family link with a tendering firm is a conflict of interest, and by hiding it Darius lets it influence his recommendation without the board being able to allow for it. Answer B (1).
- 2
Why the others are wrong. A is the error of treating 'not telling the board' as a confidentiality matter; confidentiality is about not disclosing information about a client or employer, and here disclosure was what was needed. C is the error of assuming every lapse breaks the law or discredits the profession; nothing illegal has been done. D is the error of reading the case as a skills problem; nothing suggests Darius cannot evaluate the tenders, only that he is not impartial.
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: a conflict of interest points to objectivity. The safeguard is to declare the interest and take no part in the decision.
Common mistake: choosing A because the case is about 'disclosing' something. Confidentiality restricts what an accountant reveals about others' affairs; it never requires an accountant to hide his own interests.